News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by tptacek on Monday April 27, 2026 @02:08PM (#47925120)
I don't think the case law supports this argument that farmers got roped into subscription crops. Farmers use this system because it has value, and is economically superior to the systems that preceded it (or they don't use it).
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by victorbjorklund on Monday April 27, 2026 @03:09PM (#47925892)
There is a problem though. If you opt out of it and just use seeds without any IP and your neighbor uses IP seeds and some of the seeds are blowing into your field from your neighbour you risk trouble.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by tptacek on Monday April 27, 2026 @03:18PM (#47926012)
No in fact you do not. This is an Internet/activist myth.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by victorbjorklund on Monday April 27, 2026 @04:06PM (#47926630)
Source that it is legal to keep the profits and the plants from a patented crop that can’t be prove you have intentionally planted it there? As far as I understand Montosanto claims it would always belong to them no matter how the seed ended up there.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by HDThoreaun on Monday April 27, 2026 @05:00PM (#47927252)
There is absolutely no case law suggesting it is illegal to harvest and keep accidentally cross contaminated seed. Seeing as farming seeds is default legal there would need to be precedent otherwise for such an act to be illegal.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by gzread on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @09:52AM (#47934608)
There is patent law. Patent law says you can't do the patented thing without the license. Growing the seeds is patented. So you can't grow them without license. This may be so obvious that it never needed to become a notable precedent-setting case.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by tptacek on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @01:16PM (#47937431)
Nice of you to axiomatically rederive patent law for us, but this is false. You cannot be sued simply for allowing seeds that blew onto your land grow.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by gzread on Wednesday April 29, 2026 @07:26AM (#47946818)
You can for using them commercially.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by tptacek on Wednesday April 29, 2026 @09:59AM (#47948579)
Feel free to cite a case where that happened. I don't think you can.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by tptacek on Monday April 27, 2026 @05:02PM (#47927267)
Feel free to cite the case they've brought where they claim that!

They have sued farmers for innocently acquiring their seeds (through the wind or whatever) and then spraying their crops with Roundup (ie: using the whole system).

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by yosamino on Monday April 27, 2026 @05:58PM (#47927929)
I worded it so carefully to not have an argument, just for illustration, but...

Yes, you are correct, and you are not contradicting me: This is a system that makes sense on the surface. It's economically superior to pay some more money to a seed supplier to get a better yield on my fields.

But this economic advantage is captured by the seed supplier after all farmers moved to this new system where you are no longer able to rely on the previous' harvest seeds. Once everyone is on the economically superior system, the seed supplier can start capturing more of the value that is created by farming.

The point here is that Monsanto creates a superior yield in a crop. All your farmer peers move to use it, and now you have to too or get priced out of the market.

hence: > skew towards concentrating money towards those who already live a comfortable life. > skew

The word "farmers" is doing some heavy lifting here - might be some multinational, might be a small family making a living.

The point is not that the market is pricing out inefficient farms, the point is that it turns a millennia old practice on it's head and using government force to enable monopolies to remove competition.

Farmers use it because their time horizon is 1-5 years, but the government monopoly on seeds is more like 20 years.

It's skewed.

Easy to disagree and argue with these points, but the original question was why there are people opposed to GMOs and while GMOs are not the only patented organisms they are the most obvious for people to have concerns over the economics

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by pfdietz on Monday April 27, 2026 @06:18PM (#47928145)
I find the objection to patents on GMO plants to be completely indefensible.

If there was ever an area where patents are justified and necessary, this is it. This is a product that in normal operation manufactures itself. Without patent protection, the farmer would buy at most one batch to seed his fields, and then never again.

Objection to patents on GMO plants is just a way to object to GMO plants themselves without coming out and saying so directly.

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by justinclift on Monday April 27, 2026 @06:31PM (#47928268)
> This is a product that in normal operation manufactures itself. Without patent protection, the farmer would buy at most one batch to seed his fields, and then never again.

Isn't that a massive societal benefit vs rent seeking though?

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by pfdietz on Monday April 27, 2026 @06:34PM (#47928291)
If we got the seeds from the GMO fairy, yes.

If we have to get the seeds from expensive R&D that wouldn't occur without patent protection, then no.

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by justinclift on Monday April 27, 2026 @06:46PM (#47928368)
> then no.

Why not?

It's literally a self replicating system. Trying to control that for rent seeking purposes seems pretty unethical.

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by pfdietz on Monday April 27, 2026 @06:49PM (#47928380)
> Why not?

(rolls eyes)

Because if no one does the R&D to create the seeds they WON'T EXIST.

I would have thought that was 100% obvious, but apparently not!

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by justinclift on Monday April 27, 2026 @07:26PM (#47928648)
> Because if no one does the R&D to create the seeds they WON'T EXIST.

Sure. If no-one does the R&D.

Perhaps if rent seeking is the mechanism for getting there, then it's better off if they don't? :)

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by pfdietz on Monday April 27, 2026 @07:49PM (#47928791)
Yes, yes, let's imagine automated turbo communism where all inventions can be made outside the free market.

Here in the real world, private firms are the source of things like this. Roundup Ready soybeans involved cooperation from multiple private firms that contributed various elements.

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by justinclift on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @06:14AM (#47932473)
That's the same line Private Equity often trots out, and those seem to corrode the world far more than they improve it.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by pfdietz on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @09:25AM (#47934256)
Wow. If a correct argument is made by a morally compromised actor, we can dismiss the argument! Logic is wonderful.