News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by 0xbadcafebee on Monday April 27, 2026 @01:51PM (#47924907)
Important to note it's not Glyphosate on trial, it's Roundup. There is a huge gulf between studies and conclusions on Glyphosate, and studies and conclusions on Roundup. Glyphosate is the safest and most effective herbicide known to mankind. Roundup - which includes Glyphosate, in addition to other additives - may be unnecessarily dangerous.

Also worth noting that Monsanto could stop selling Roundup entirely, and it wouldn't really matter. Monsanto's Glyphosate patent expired, so you can get cheaper Glyphosate from many different manufacturers. Which is great, because it means we can avoid the potentially-more-dangerous Roundup, and use the simpler base chemical instead. Distancing the pesticide from the "evil corporation" might actually make people less afraid of it.

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by parineum on Monday April 27, 2026 @02:26PM (#47925324)
> you can get cheaper Glyphosate from many different manufacturers. Which is great, because it means we can avoid the potentially-more-dangerous Roundup, and use the simpler base chemical instead.

Unspecified Glyphosate product isn't better because it's not Roundup. If some ingredient in Roundup is dangerous, let's drop the Glyphosate conversation and look for herbicides without that other mystery chemical.

It really seems like you're looking for a reason to justify Roundup as uniquely bad, in the face of evidence, with extremely vague statements.

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by victorbjorklund on Monday April 27, 2026 @03:05PM (#47925833)
They literally said that Roundup is bad because of the OTHER chemicals that it contains in addition to Glyphosate which is not dangerous. Then it makes total sense to use pure Glyphosate instead of Roundup.

Of course you can claim that they are wrong about their claim. But that is another point.

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by parineum on Monday April 27, 2026 @03:12PM (#47925936)
> Unspecified Glyphosate product isn't better because it's not Roundup. If some ingredient in Roundup is dangerous, let's drop the Glyphosate conversation and look for herbicides without that other mystery chemical.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by victorbjorklund on Monday April 27, 2026 @04:07PM (#47926642)
That makes no sense. If you accept that Glyphosate is 100% harmless. Why on earth would you drop it?
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by recursive on Monday April 27, 2026 @04:21PM (#47926827)
> Why on earth would you drop [Glyphosate]?

You wouldn't. You'd drop the conversation regarding whether it was safe.

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by keane on Monday April 27, 2026 @03:11PM (#47925927)
A key paper on its safety from 2000 was retracted: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46161125

Like the tobacco industry before them, a Monsanto employee proposed producing a scientific paper with outside scientists: “by us doing the writing and they would just edit & sign their names so to speak” — see https://retractionwatch.com/2025/12/04/glyphosate-safety-art...

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by tptacek on Monday April 27, 2026 @03:25PM (#47926126)
There isn't one single study that glyphosate safety is based on. It's an intensively studied substance.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by keane on Monday April 27, 2026 @03:39PM (#47926310)
I didn’t claim there was only one study. The concern is the corporate culture introducing biases into studies. In the tobacco industry, this was a pattern.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by tptacek on Monday April 27, 2026 @03:48PM (#47926419)
There was overwhelming evidence, some of it preceding modern human health science, that smoking was damaging.
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by pfdietz on Monday April 27, 2026 @06:04PM (#47928005)
Indeed. It's rare in environmental medicine to see an effect as strong as that from smoking. The straw the tobacco industry clung to for a while (it was debunked) was that people who had cancer smoked to sooth their lungs (or, that cancer caused smoking, not vice versa.)
Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by brightball on Monday April 27, 2026 @06:54PM (#47928417)
There are numerous studies that show glyphosate binds with aluminum and other metals, having negative impacts on public health.

"Aluminum and Glyphosate Can Synergistically Induce Pineal Gland Pathology: Connection to Gut Dysbiosis and Neurological Disease"

https://www.scirp.org/journal/paperinformation?paperid=53106

"Glyphosate, a chelating agent—relevant for ecological risk assessment?"

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5823954/

"Glyphosate complexation to aluminium(III). An equilibrium and structural study in solution using potentiometry, multinuclear NMR, ATR–FTIR, ESI-MS and DFT calculations"

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S01620...

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by tptacek on Monday April 27, 2026 @08:00PM (#47928840)
That first paper you cited is kind of a running joke. ScienceBasedMedicine ran a whole article on Seneff's work:

https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/glyphosate-the-new-bogeyman...

It's based on a Rube Goldberg causal mechanism and a slapdash correlation analysis that vibes glyphosate as the presumed cause of sleep disorder and autism diagnostic increases over the preceding 20 years --- glyphosate went up, autism went up, what more is there to say?

A later review of the literature on glyphosate went out of its way to exclude it:

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00420-022-01878-0...

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by stubish on Monday April 27, 2026 @08:36PM (#47929080)
While glyphosate may technically be considered safe, there are reports and I believe lawsuits about it reacting with hard water creating extremely unsafe compounds. ie. it poisons your ground water.

https://www.worldenergydata.org/roundup-herbicide-ingredient...

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by 0xbadcafebee on Monday April 27, 2026 @10:23PM (#47929841)
I'm not opposed to further studies, but basic critical thinking makes it unlikely that this is a danger outside of those specific areas.

First remember that glyphosate has been used around the world continuously for 52 years. If there is some kind of pattern of harm due to its use, it's already happened, so it should be possible to find those harms all over the place.

85% of the USA has hard water. If glyphosate being in hard water causes 10% of children to have early onset kidney disease, we would have been seeing that in the USA for at least the last 42 years. But we haven't. So it's likely that whatever is happening in Sri Lanka, is specific to Sri Lanka.

You can take this same basic logical premise and apply it to all of the concerns about glyphosate. None of them stand up to scrutiny, because we have been using it for so long, everywhere, and despite that, we have no concrete evidence of any significant harms caused by glyphosate itself.

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by hinkley on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @03:18AM (#47931350)
And real farmers have bad days and have difficulty maintaining the prescribed application conditions.

For one, you can't control what the weather does in the afternoon after you've applied it in the morning (and it might take all morning because farms are huge and you have to tank up again)

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by defrost on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @07:30AM (#47932982)
Real farmers, all 3,500 of them in local coop, take careful measures to control everything on large farms- spraying is generaly done at night for the cooler temps, rates are watched as over spray costs $$'s etc. Seed volumes are manually run through air seeder calibrate seed weight per acre, etc.

The trend today is toward AgBot / SwarmBot type boom sprayers with onboard weather stations for wind speed and air temp, coupled with computer vision to limit spray to actual weeds rather than broad area even spray for weed / non weed alike.

Again, driven by $$ watching, etc.

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by hinkley on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @03:16AM (#47931335)
Monsanto is pretty consistent about trying to change the noun to glyphosate from roundup any chance they get.

If you refer to it as glyphosate, as GP does, that either means you've fallen victim to their PR campaign, or labels you as a paid astroturfer.

Re:Supreme Court to Hear Arguments in Landmark Roundup Weedk... by 0xbadcafebee on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @11:27AM (#47935918)
Or, third option, it could mean you're one of the few scientifically literate critical thinkers who doesn't jump on one or another end of extreme arguments, looks for evidence, and understands nuance

I admit that's probably like 1 out of every 100,000 people, but they're out there