Re:Traders placed over $1B in perfectly timed bets on the Ir...
by MadnessASAP on Saturday April 18, 2026 @07:50PM
(#47820556)
Yes, but the examples where it's good has a name "insurance". It exists, it's generally well regulated, and is not easily exploited.
The reason it works better is because in a prediction market, the person betting against you has no resources or ability to go after you for fraudulent behavior. Whereas an insurance company has both.
Re:Traders placed over $1B in perfectly timed bets on the Ir...
by wallst07 on Sunday April 19, 2026 @06:02AM
(#47823131)
Nobody would insure this, and if they did, that policy would take months to be written, wouldn't cover the single probability of 1 event, etc...
So you are renaming something that doesn't and won't ever exist.
Re:Traders placed over $1B in perfectly timed bets on the Ir...
by MadnessASAP on Monday April 20, 2026 @06:04PM
(#47841608)
And you're trying to rename unregulated gambling as something that is good for society.
Exploiting people with gambling addiction is not a reasonable replacement for insurance.
Re:Traders placed over $1B in perfectly timed bets on the Ir...
by amelius on Saturday April 18, 2026 @07:45PM
(#47820518)
Why not get a real insurance, where it is actually verified that your house was bombed?
Re:Traders placed over $1B in perfectly timed bets on the Ir...
by crazygringo on Saturday April 18, 2026 @07:47PM
(#47820532)
Because there are many things where insurance doesn't exist.
Re:Traders placed over $1B in perfectly timed bets on the Ir...
by amelius on Saturday April 18, 2026 @07:54PM
(#47820584)
Ok let's work on that then. But meanwhile, close down unregulated websites like polymarket, where there is no verification of actual damage.
Re:Traders placed over $1B in perfectly timed bets on the Ir...
by crazygringo on Saturday April 18, 2026 @07:58PM
(#47820600)
You can't just "work on that".
Insurance works on repeatable, predictable risks based on models.
You can't get insurance against a military attack. But you can hedge using a prediction market. It's essentially the version of insurance for one-off events, that relies on wagers since you can't use models.
Re:Traders placed over $1B in perfectly timed bets on the Ir...
by maest on Sunday April 19, 2026 @03:41AM
(#47822496)
There is a market for custom and rare risk insurance - it's called "surplus lines"
Re:Traders placed over $1B in perfectly timed bets on the Ir...
by mothballed on Saturday April 18, 2026 @07:49PM
(#47820546)
I'm not saying it's not out there, but in many cases finding insurance for act of war is difficult. It is certainly rare and almost always far less accessible than using polymarket. If you have a very large holding you can probably get someone to write it for you though.
Even if you suppose my example is bad, you should be able to envision some case where such hedge is helpful.