Re:The Audacity of Doing Nothing
by pj on Wednesday February 11, 2009 @11:25PM
(#478016)
Nothing is exactly the right thing to do.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Isn't that saying "let them eat cake?"
Please explain how you think it is like the french expression you are referring to.
French revolution, a certain Marie A. is said to have responded to the question of the fate of the masses with "let them eat cake". It's paralleled here by this guy's suggestion that we should just let the market do its work, human consequences be damned.
No.
Maybe. How about repossessing some of that money that got removed from the economy by the people that got us in to this mess in the first place.
Makes you wonder how much of that '2 trillion' came out of the system in an illicit way in the first place. After all, all that money missing must have gone somewhere.
Re:The Audacity of Doing Nothing
by hackinthebochs on Thursday February 12, 2009 @11:56AM
(#478631)
That money never existed in the first place. The "value" of the assets were based on people's confidence in it continuing to rise. Once that confidence evaporated, so did the "value".
The problem is how connected the financial system became to these bubble assets.
I don't think that's the whole of it.
Especially in the case of the resale of the bad debt packages real money changed hands for future revenue based on a misrepresentation of the facts about these packages on the part of the seller.
That money should be recoverable.
If you disagree with me I'd be much obliged to hear why.
Re:The Audacity of Doing Nothing
by mattmaroon on Thursday February 12, 2009 @12:19PM
(#478665)
I don't think its disagreement so much as you're confusing what happened. $2 trillion in wealth disappeared, not money. There's a big difference, it doesn't "come out of the system". It's simply people valuing things at less than they did before. It's not stolen, they way dollar bills would be if $2 trillion in money disappeared.
Stupid grammar, making that sentence ambiguous. I can't decide if I'm annoyed that you would post one sentence saying you agreed with the article (there's a little arrow for that), or if I'm cowed into meditating on the idea that quests for perfection are doomed.
The grammar is perfect. Do we want chance of extended pain or foreshortened? Given the purportedly uncharted macroeconomics, each solution could give us either outcome. It's a many-worlds interpretation (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Many-worlds_interpretation).
But boy, if will be wonderful wasteful fireworks, 2 trillion manically disbursed.