News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Who Is Satoshi Nakamoto? My Quest to Unmask Bitcoin's Cre... by tovej on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @03:29AM (#47686604)
I think this misses the point. The point is that interests and writing style matches, which means there's a higher chance they are the same person.

The more similarities you find, the closer the match. It's in no way proof, of course. But it does provide good reason to look closer

Re:Who Is Satoshi Nakamoto? My Quest to Unmask Bitcoin's Cre... by rcxdude on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @04:58AM (#47687321)
Only if those similarities are indicating more than 'generic internet hacker' for both of them. You only need 23 bits to identify a person but those are 23 uncorrelated bits, and all the 'similarities' presented here are extremely strongly correlated with themselves.
Re:Who Is Satoshi Nakamoto? My Quest to Unmask Bitcoin's Cre... by extraduder_ire on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @09:56AM (#47690287)
Where are you getting 23 from? That's only 8-ish million values max.
Re:Who Is Satoshi Nakamoto? My Quest to Unmask Bitcoin's Cre... by bnjemian on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @02:21PM (#47694207)
Suspect it's a typo. 33, not 23, gives ~8.6*10^9.
Re:Who Is Satoshi Nakamoto? My Quest to Unmask Bitcoin's Cre... by rcxdude on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @07:01PM (#47697315)
D'oh, yeah.
Re:Who Is Satoshi Nakamoto? My Quest to Unmask Bitcoin's Cre... by emmelaich on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @11:30PM (#47698976)
Probably used logn not log2.

   >>> math.log(8_000_000_000)
   22.80270737862625
Re:Who Is Satoshi Nakamoto? My Quest to Unmask Bitcoin's Cre... by FarmerPotato on Thursday April 09, 2026 @03:09PM (#47708276)
Yeah, but as Wordle fans know, some clues yield more bits than others. The search space is not balanced.

The search space of hackers is a small subtree of all humans. So it's like a smaller tree of groups in Wordle that contains the letter "H".

However, in reality there is no binary "hacker" bit, so maybe we're back to the brute force 33-bit space. And then, you don't know Satoshi's unique signature, and it's worse if Satoshi is a group.

Come to think of it, do all hacker news posters even share a hacker bit?

I still rely on information-theoretic proofs at work, they just don't involve messy humans.

Re:Who Is Satoshi Nakamoto? My Quest to Unmask Bitcoin's Cre... by defrost on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @05:29AM (#47687621)
Similarities in style and word were common enough in small circles such as the cyphyrpunks that spawned those discussions.

Then there's not altogether unlikely chance that Satoshi is a nodding homage to Nicolas Bourbaki, each contributor holding part of a multiparty voting key.

Re:Who Is Satoshi Nakamoto? My Quest to Unmask Bitcoin's Cre... by alwa on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @12:56PM (#47692920)
The interests and writing style differentiate Mr. (Dr.?) Back from the general public, sure. But from what I’m reading, they don’t do a great job of distinguishing between 90s hackers.

“Get this, his PhD thesis dealt with a computer language called C++, just like Bitcoin papers used” seems both confused and impossibly lazy to me.

> “Scrap patents and copyright,” Mr. Back wrote in September 1997.

> Satoshi did a similar thing. He released the Bitcoin software under M.I.T.’s open-source license

Really?

Like saying “get this, his college-aged musical interests included the Urban American musical style known as ‘Hip Hop’; therefore Tupac didn’t really die and this is him.” Heavy on insinuation, light on seriousness. Strong “…you’re not from around here, are you?” vibes.

What does this kind of journalism hope to accomplish, anyway? Beyond bothering middle-aged nerds for gossip? And providing a frame for the author’s cute little sleuth jape?

“Good reason to look closer” assumes there’s good reason to pick through ancient rubble in the first place.

Re:Who Is Satoshi Nakamoto? My Quest to Unmask Bitcoin's Cre... by freejazz on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @06:13PM (#47696963)
Did you read most of the article or what?
Re:Who Is Satoshi Nakamoto? My Quest to Unmask Bitcoin's Cre... by alwa on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @10:42PM (#47698737)
All 12,000 words. Kept expecting it to take a turn toward something beyond pre-judgment and insinuation. Instead it unfolded as a cautionary tale about the power of a premature conclusion to close an investigator’s mind to alternatives. About escalating commitment to an early hunch, even as it leads you down an investigative dead end.

The colorful journey down a dead end, fine—but call it what it is, don’t plaster the guy’s name and spooky hacker photo montage across the New York Times as if it proved what it set out to.

Re:Who Is Satoshi Nakamoto? My Quest to Unmask Bitcoin's Cre... by alwa on Thursday April 09, 2026 @12:43AM (#47699347)
All 12,000 words. Kept expecting it to take a turn toward something beyond pre-judgment and insinuation. Instead it unfolded as a cautionary tale, of the power of a premature conclusion to close an investigator’s mind to reasonable alternative possibilities. About escalating commitment to an early hunch, even as it leads you down an investigative dead end.

For example it sure seems like his mountain of circumstantial evidence fits better with the theory that “Satoshi” could be a pen name for a small group of people—maybe even the small group whose history he traces and whose styles he has trouble teasing apart—rather than one “suspect” (as he calls it). But we don’t even really weigh that possibility seriously.

So, like—why are we coming at this one guy by name and spooky hacker photo in the New York Times, with the suggestion that he has $110 billion under his mattress? All these speculations and arguments have been done over and over—what does this reporting add that’s worth 12,000 words?

The colorful journey down a dead end, fine—but leave it at “My Quest,” don’t do the weasel subhed “the trail of clues […] led to Adam Back” to insinuate that it proved what it set out to prove. Or even added anything significant to the well-trodden record.

Re:Who Is Satoshi Nakamoto? My Quest to Unmask Bitcoin's Cre... by freejazz on Thursday April 09, 2026 @10:13AM (#47704049)
>For example it sure seems like his mountain of circumstantial evidence fits better with the theory that “Satoshi” could be a pen name for a small group of people—maybe even the small group whose history he traces and whose styles he has trouble teasing apart—rather than one “suspect” (as he calls it). But we don’t even really weigh that possibility seriously.

Does it? I didn't come to that conclusion. Do share!

>So, like—why are we coming at this one guy by name and spooky hacker photo in the New York Times, with the suggestion that he has $110 billion under his mattress? All these speculations and arguments have been done over and over—what does this reporting add that’s worth 12,000 words?

Well, they identified this guy and the reporting here is better than the others I've seen in the past. This article obviously has nothing to do with what past writers wrote, so I don't really get the point of pretending like it all comes from one place.

>The colorful journey down a dead end, fine—but leave it at “My Quest,” don’t do the weasel subhed “the trail of clues […] led to Adam Back” to insinuate that it proved what it set out to prove. Or even added anything significant to the well-trodden record.

Yawn