News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How many products does Microsoft have named 'Copilot'? I ... by layer8 on Saturday April 04, 2026 @07:57PM (#47644773)
A "Windows subsystem" is a specific interface between user-mode applications and the Windows kernel. It's a technical notion that exists in Windows. So there are different Windows subsystems for different types of applications. The naming convention is "Windows subsystem for <application type>". It makes more sense when you read it as "Windows subsystem for [running] Linux [applications]".

WSL2 deviates from the native concept of what a Windows subsystem is; it is named that way because it is the successor of the original WSL.

Re:How many products does Microsoft have named 'Copilot'? I ... by zarzavat on Saturday April 04, 2026 @08:38PM (#47645014)
> It makes more sense when you read it as "Windows subsystem for [running] Linux [applications]".

You can't have ellipsis when the shortened version already has its own meaning.

X for Y when both X and Y are nouns means that X is part of Y, not that Y is part of X.

e.g. "I bought new tyres for my car". The tyres are part of my car. You can't flip it and say "I bought new my car for tyres", it's just not how the word "for" works.

Grammatically it has to be "Linux for Windows subsystem", or "Windows subsystem for running Linux" as you said. The verb is essential for it to parse correctly.

Re:How many products does Microsoft have named 'Copilot'? I ... by ternaryoperator on Saturday April 04, 2026 @08:58PM (#47645127)
There are many exceptions to what you state as an ironclad rule: i bought a display case for my baseball, i bought an album for my photos, etc. “for” can go in either direction.
Re:How many products does Microsoft have named 'Copilot'? I ... by jasomill on Saturday April 04, 2026 @09:53PM (#47645425)
This, and it may have also been a legal thing. "Product for Third-Party OS" has been accepted as a descriptive use of a third-party trademark for decades, requiring only proper attribution rather than a license, whereas marketing a product that didn't even originally use the Linux kernel as a "Linux Subsystem" might have been considered riskier by Microsoft's lawyers in spite of the nonstandard use of the former.
Re:How many products does Microsoft have named 'Copilot'? I ... by al_borland on Sunday April 05, 2026 @03:08AM (#47646920)
It could be even more simple. Microsoft would want to their own product, Windows, to come before Linux in the name.

I read through the brand guidelines where I work, and we have a similar stipulation. Maybe there is some law mixed in there, but from a pure branding play, a company will never want to put someone else first.

Re:How many products does Microsoft have named 'Copilot'? I ... by GeekyBear on Saturday April 04, 2026 @11:19PM (#47645829)
WSL was a traditional subsystem in the Windows NT tradition, it just never worked properly.

WSL2 runs real Linux in a virtual machine.

Re:How many products does Microsoft have named 'Copilot'? I ... by pjmlp on Sunday April 05, 2026 @04:36AM (#47647370)
Actually no, that is what many without Windows background think.

WSL 1.0 was based on Drawbridge research project of library OSes, also used to port SQL Server into Linux.

See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46110904

Re:How many products does Microsoft have named 'Copilot'? I ... by GeekyBear on Sunday April 05, 2026 @09:41AM (#47649349)
Microsoft had to warn users that they would corrupt the original WSL subsystem if they touched Linux files using Windows tools:

> DO NOT, under ANY circumstances, access, create, and/or modify Linux files inside of your `%LOCALAPPDATA%` folder using Windows apps, tools, scripts, consoles, etc.

They did overcome that problem eventually, but by then everyone had moved on to WSL2.

Re:How many products does Microsoft have named 'Copilot'? I ... by pjmlp on Sunday April 05, 2026 @12:13PM (#47650881)
That is no different from having file systems problems across OSes, as old as there are multiple OSes.

Even Linux best practices for SMB access have been as read only.

Re:How many products does Microsoft have named 'Copilot'? I ... by GeekyBear on Sunday April 05, 2026 @02:29PM (#47652401)
Sorry, but WSL1 was unstable by Microsoft's own admission.

That's why Microsoft abandoned it in favor of WSL2 running real Linux in a VM.

Re:How many products does Microsoft have named 'Copilot'? I ... by pjmlp on Monday April 06, 2026 @02:28AM (#47657602)
Nope, Microsoft redid the design due to the amount of Linux syscalls that were still left to implement.

What is this goal post moving? First the was file system access, then it became being unstable, what is going to be the next point?

Let me make it easier, WSL 1.0 did not support the syscalls for X Windows implementation.

Re:How many products does Microsoft have named 'Copilot'? I ... by GeekyBear on Monday April 06, 2026 @10:47AM (#47661646)
> What is this goal post moving? First the was file system access, then it became being unstable, what is going to be the next point?

If you can't touch the Linux files with Windows tools without corrupting them, your implementation is unstable.

WSL1 was unstable, unfit for purpose, and never worked properly.

It was abandoned in favor of just running real Linux in a VM.

Re:How many products does Microsoft have named 'Copilot'? I ... by dataflow on Sunday April 05, 2026 @12:09AM (#47646034)
I believe you're almost entirely wrong unfortunately. It is true that Windows has subsystems as a technical feature, yes. However, I don't think it's true that WSL (v1) was based on those, despite the name. AFAIK that existing subsystem notion was a user-mode one, where each subsystem was built mostly in user-mode on top of the NT ("native") subsystem, with binaries in the PE format. WSL just completely got rid of the whole thing, and even the existing notion of processes, and IIRC came up with a separate new thing called "picoprocesses" that it barely wired through some kernel data structures via a custom driver that executed Linux binaries intact, implementing the Linux syscalls.

If you want a list of actual subsystems Windows recognizes, this should be pretty accurate:

https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/win32/debug/pe-for...

The real reason for calling it a subsystem was almost entirely for familiarity with the previous attempts at running Linux programs, which were based on that subsystem feature (the POSIX subsystem and the Subsystem for UNIX-based Applications).

Re:How many products does Microsoft have named 'Copilot'? I ... by rusk on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:50AM (#47648106)
It needs an apostrophe then it makes more sense “Windows’ Subsystem for Linux”

It is a Windows Subsystem, that caters to running Linux.

It’s a functional title not an architectural one.

Re:How many products does Microsoft have named 'Copilot'? I ... by Jenk on Sunday April 05, 2026 @06:57AM (#47648139)
Or a colon:

    Windows Subsystem for: Linux
Re:How many products does Microsoft have named 'Copilot'? I ... by 1718627440 on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @07:32AM (#47673570)
Subsystem isn't used as a random English word here, "Windows Subsystem" is already a fixed term. So you wouldn't introduce a possessive relation into the term when using it.
Re:How many products does Microsoft have named 'Copilot'? I ... by rusk on Monday April 13, 2026 @02:33AM (#47748398)
Indeed, I was trying to make it easier for you.
Re:How many products does Microsoft have named 'Copilot'? I ... by lxgr on Sunday April 05, 2026 @07:07AM (#47648188)
That doesn't seem like a contradiction to the idea that "Windows subsystem" is (at least after WSL 1 and especially 2) a description for a functionality (i.e. running binaries targeting a different OS's interfaces), not an implementation.
Re:How many products does Microsoft have named 'Copilot'? I ... by dataflow on Sunday April 05, 2026 @10:58AM (#47650108)
No, as I explained, that's not what the actual subsystem architecture did. The binaries very much targeted Windows and did not target any other OSes. They weren't (say) ELF files targeting Linux, they were PE files targeting Windows, and you had to compile them from source with special flags to target those subsystems on Windows. You could not run those binaries on other OSes. The compatibility was at the source level, not at the binary level.