How do you feel about civil rights? Whose economic approach is more likely to fix things? Is the legality of abortion and contraception important to you?
Choose the lesser evil today. Then work for a greater good tomorrow.
I'm not from the US (and don't have a favored candidate), but I hear this rhetoric quite a lot. In each election, regardless of allegiance, we hear that this particular election is too important to throw away a vote by voting independent. After all, we don't want another Gore/Nader!
I've always wondered; in exactly which of the previous 56 elections would it have been OK?
I suspect the real answer for the majority of lesser evil types (and I'm not saying you are in this boat) is along the lines of: back when the Whigs were in power.
This is not an invariant property of the United States electoral system. Minnesota
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jesse_Ventura
and Maine
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Angus_King
have both elected governors not endorsed by either of the two largest political parties in recent years, and there are members of the United States Senate
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_current_United_States_S...
who were elected in statewide elections without major party endorsement.
Also, elections for governor do not have to account for the Electoral College which IMO is an anarchic holdover from a time when communication was much harder.
Minnesota is an outlier in my mind - it's more attributable to the fact that the Republican candidate (Norm Coleman) was a terrible candidate (he only won his Senate seat because his opponent died right before the election[2]), and the race was irregular in other ways too. It happened once, but I wouldn't bet on it happening again there anytime soon, unless things change.
[1] http://fivethirtyeight.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/10/15/in-maine...
[2] To Coleman's credit, John Ashcroft ran against a dead man and lost, so I guess Coleman had something going for him.
He lost to the dead man's wife, who the voters knew would take that seat even if the ballots couldn't be reprinted in time.
It doesn't matter what your intention when voting is, what matters is, at the end of the day, your vote wil be interpreted as being FOR the non-incumbent rather than against the incumbent.
I would say given bad choices, vote for the independent who is going to lose anyway. They're expected to lose, but people will take notice and say "oh, wow, Joe Somebody was expected to only get 2% of the popular vote, but he ended up with 7%! Will you look at that!" In that case, your vote will be first seen as discontent with the main two choices (because you're making a (let's face it) losing vote) and only second to that, as support for the independent.