News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Austin's Surge of New Housing Construction Drove Down Rents by nomilk on Wednesday March 18, 2026 @09:20PM (#47433594)
Dumb question, many cities suffer from extremely high property (i.e. land) prices. I understand the NIMBY barrier. But I don't understand why it isn't more common to simply.. start a new city. Especially in countries like Australia where property prices are sky high and alternative places for setting up a new city are abundant. Maybe internet connectivity was previously a barrier, but now.. starlink.

I put this question to grok; its response:

> Unfortunately, Australia's legal, regulatory, financial, and practical systems make this extremely difficult (bordering on impossible at any meaningful scale).

Crazy that the reason we can't have an order-of-magnitude reduction in the cost of the most important thing people need (shelter) is not due to resource constraints, but man-made ones.

Re:Austin's Surge of New Housing Construction Drove Down Rents by bluGill on Wednesday March 18, 2026 @09:42PM (#47433738)
You can't start a new city. I city exists for all the things you can do. Your new city will have nothing to do because nobody lives there and there are no jobs to attract anyone to move.

that is why we build suburbs - they get anound this by being right next to a place with everything you want in a city

Re:Austin's Surge of New Housing Construction Drove Down Rents by cuuupid on Wednesday March 18, 2026 @10:59PM (#47434360)
This is actually how you start a city though, you build a suburb and wait for it to grow into a city. This takes a really really long time so it's better to build near existing cities.

We don't observe this phenomenon occurring often in the modern day only because cities sprawl rapidly and so the evolution of the suburb becomes a borough of the existing city rather than a brand new city. Otherwise Brooklyn, Jersey City, Weehawken, etc. would all be considered new cities instead of being referred to as the NYC metro.

Re:Austin's Surge of New Housing Construction Drove Down Rents by ryanmerket on Wednesday March 18, 2026 @10:29PM (#47434099)
Sure you can. You just need enough land and money to start basic things like a post office, city hall, courthouse, roads, and a way to get power to the whole thing.

See Starbase, Texas

Re:Austin's Surge of New Housing Construction Drove Down Rents by terminalshort on Wednesday March 18, 2026 @10:43PM (#47434236)
Starbase TX isn't a city in any sense other than a legal designation. It's a massive SpaceX industrial facility that has its own municipality similar to the way Disney World has one for its park.
Re:Austin's Surge of New Housing Construction Drove Down Rents by cucumber3732842 on Thursday March 19, 2026 @12:00PM (#47441616)
I would expect the adjacent area to become some sort of a city over time. Suppliers will move nearby. Population, amenities and competition will follow. Unless of course SpaceX keels over before all this can happen.

See also: Orlando

Re:Austin's Surge of New Housing Construction Drove Down Rents by vel0city on Wednesday March 18, 2026 @10:09PM (#47433956)
It obviously wouldn't be successful on day one, and it would take some kind of exceptional pressure to jump start it, but these things have been done in the past in the US and have been done recently in China. Not arguing these were good things, but they have happened before.

Think back to the old "company towns". Lowell, Massachusetts, built for a textile mill. Hershey Pennsylvania, built around a chocolate factory. Fordlandia, Brazil, a rubber plantation town. All of these were essentially cities and towns planned out around a central industry.

Similar things happened with the ghost cities in China with several of the big notable ones eventually actually growing into real, functional cities.

Once again, these have all kinds of messy histories and I'm not saying they're all good ideas. But just pointing out, it can be done.

Re:Austin's Surge of New Housing Construction Drove Down Rents by bluGill on Wednesday March 18, 2026 @10:56PM (#47434340)
And you proved my point why you can't today.
Re:Austin's Surge of New Housing Construction Drove Down Rents by BeetleB on Thursday March 19, 2026 @11:44AM (#47441377)
Lots of examples in various countries in the 20th century prove you wrong.

Brasilia, Canberra, Islamabad, Reston, etc.

Re:Austin's Surge of New Housing Construction Drove Down Rents by jfoster on Wednesday March 18, 2026 @09:55PM (#47433847)
> Crazy that the reason we can't have an order-of-magnitude reduction in the cost of the most important thing people need (shelter) is not due to resource constraints, but man-made ones.

You say that as though reduction in cost of housing is a universal desire, but it isn't.

Suppose a couple of years ago you took a $500,000 loan to buy a $700,000 house, which you'll be paying off for the next 10 years. Would you like the market value of your house to decline substantially during that time?

If there's enough of the population bought into property, it won't be politically feasible to allow the value of homes to decline.

Re:Austin's Surge of New Housing Construction Drove Down Rents by FireBeyond on Wednesday March 18, 2026 @10:46PM (#47434261)
> Suppose a couple of years ago you took a $500,000 loan to buy a $700,000 house, which you'll be paying off for the next 10 years. Would you like the market value of your house to decline substantially during that time?

No, but when your city proposes a "missing middle" plan, watch who all comes out of the woodwork to scream murder at their research that shows that the projected effect of doing so will lower property values in my town from an 11.5% YoY average increase to a "mere" 9% YoY increase. You'd have thought the city was suggesting executing grandmothers in the streets.

(I cannot personally complain, I put down 10% on my home purchase here in 2021 and was able to get out of PMI due to having 20% equity against appraised value 366 days later, while only making required payments.)

Re:Austin's Surge of New Housing Construction Drove Down Rents by foltik on Thursday March 19, 2026 @02:44AM (#47435753)
Always comes back to the good ol “fuck you, I got mine.”
Re:Austin's Surge of New Housing Construction Drove Down Rents by jfoster on Thursday March 19, 2026 @06:10AM (#47437063)
When the problem is particularly exacerbated, it's not even "I got mine", but rather, "I already went into eye-watering levels of debt and I'm still paying off the roof over my head."
Re:Austin's Surge of New Housing Construction Drove Down Rents by foltik on Friday March 20, 2026 @08:59AM (#47453919)
So you made a half-million dollar leveraged bet and now want the government to rig the market so it pays off, at everyone else’s expense.

Being more desperate doesn’t make it any less selfish. It’s a universal desire for everyone who’s not selfish.

Re:Austin's Surge of New Housing Construction Drove Down Rents by xboxnolifes on Wednesday March 18, 2026 @10:00PM (#47433890)
In this hypothetical, who is the individual or group of people that you envision would take the initiative to start a new city? What is their incentive to do so?
Re:Austin's Surge of New Housing Construction Drove Down Rents by 1970-01-01 on Wednesday March 18, 2026 @10:29PM (#47434100)
Water. You need clean water to grow a city. There isn't much of that to spread around anymore.
Re:Austin's Surge of New Housing Construction Drove Down Rents by bluGill on Wednesday March 18, 2026 @11:14PM (#47434450)
most people posting here are talking about california or texas - desert or near deserts where there isn't enough water.

however there are many places where there is more than enough water. East of the mississippi for example. other continents also have areas where there is plenty.

Re:Austin's Surge of New Housing Construction Drove Down Rents by aorloff on Thursday March 19, 2026 @02:41AM (#47435735)
Except in the oceans, and near the oceans
Re:Austin's Surge of New Housing Construction Drove Down Rents by knappe on Wednesday March 18, 2026 @10:04PM (#47433919)
Re:Austin's Surge of New Housing Construction Drove Down Rents by abtinf on Wednesday March 18, 2026 @09:51PM (#47433788)
You might enjoy the novel A Town Like Alice by Nevil Shute.
Re:Austin's Surge of New Housing Construction Drove Down Rents by noahbp on Wednesday March 18, 2026 @09:29PM (#47433661)
Why would you think that the same thing preventing density and new development in cities won’t stop your new city from growing before any building taller than 2 stories is built?
Re:Austin's Surge of New Housing Construction Drove Down Rents by AngryData on Wednesday March 18, 2026 @10:04PM (#47433917)
People move to where there is jobs and money. You can't build the housing first, in our society you need capitalists to invest into building businesses to make people want to move there. And because we have spent decades killing small business in favor of corporations, you need corporations to decide to build where there are no people and they have to pay a small short term premium to attract workers. Except corporations don't like doing that because it is a longer term investment and they are worried about next quarter's numbers and maximizing executive level bonuses which means short term planning.
Re:Austin's Surge of New Housing Construction Drove Down Rents by steve-atx-7600 on Wednesday March 18, 2026 @10:08PM (#47433951)
You could build all the housing first in China until recently…
Re:Austin's Surge of New Housing Construction Drove Down Rents by AngryData on Thursday March 19, 2026 @01:10AM (#47435211)
China was dumping money into those cities for people to build businesses and paying people to move there though, it wasn't just the housing. So yes I agree it can work if you go beyond that, but not through applying capitalist principles first and foremost. If you tried to pay people to live in a specific city and pay them again to build a small local business in the US, people would go bonkers about communism and 99% of politicians and capitalist investors would spend every waking moment trying to stop it.
Re:Austin's Surge of New Housing Construction Drove Down Rents by jojobas on Wednesday March 18, 2026 @09:56PM (#47433850)
There is no shortage of cheaper existing cities in Australia, but everyone wants to live in Sydney, Brisbane, Melbourne and Perth.

The existing smaller cities just slowly wither.

Existing homeowners of the capitals have little interest in real estate prices dramatically dropping - would you?

Re:Austin's Surge of New Housing Construction Drove Down Rents by renewiltord on Thursday March 19, 2026 @10:47AM (#47440442)
Subject to the same constraints. They tried to make one in California and it was blocked by others in the same county. It’s fine to be honest. Over time California will become less relevant to the US and Texas more so.