News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Important Was the Battle of Hastings? by jongjong on Saturday March 07, 2026 @08:36PM (#47293424)
All I can say is that people do seem to overestimate the impact of losing a war. Just like they overestimate the need to wage war in the first place.

The main outcome of a war is loss of lives and infrastructure. Political changes are minor; maybe they will start teaching the language of the invader in schools as an elective... Maybe restaurants will get new foods added to the menu. Maybe taxes will go up a little... A bit more immigration from that country... Money will go to a different set of politicians.

But if you want a modern proof; look at Iraq and Afghanistan... Under US occupation for many years. They have the same people, same language, same culture, same everything as before... It's like they never lost any battles. Look at Germany after they lost WW2; they still speak German. Their cultural identity is still very strong; maybe it affected their foreign policy a little but apart from that, it's hard to tell.

War is truly useless except for those selling weapons and for a couple of big companies that are trying to acquire some mineral resources or securing some trade routes. There's really no other purpose.

My ancestors are from a country which (during the French revolution) had voluntarily changed 'ownership' from France to Britain and later back to France again. They still speak French. Nothing changed, at all, except for the fact that the elites conveniently avoided the Guillotine... Fast forward 300 years and you can't tell any cultural or economic difference at all from the other neighboring nations which remained under France and had experienced the Guillotine; same GDP numbers, same culture, same everything.

Anglo-Saxons like to make fun of the French for surrendering easily but as a regular citizen, it actually makes logical sense. I think it just shows that the government is better aligned with the interests of the people.

Strategic surrender is smart; if you know ahead of time which force is most powerful and can evaluate it objectively, you can save yourself the trouble of dying and you end up with a better outcome than you would have otherwise. It's risk management.

Of course, the Swiss are even smarter for staying neutral but France is too big to take a neutral stance (and they can actually drive outcomes) so they take one stance and then back-peddle if the tide turns.

And France does something else really smart which is; they embrace internal opposition; so if the tides turn, they allow the opposing elite take control without any fighting and it looks like France was always on the winning side.

Almost nobody recalls this, but during WW2, France was actually on the German side; president Philippe Pétain allowed the Germans in. But then later General De Gaulle pushed back when it looked like there was a good chance to turn the war around. And now everyone thinks France was always part of the allied forces.

French people hacked politics. I think now Americans are now also doing something similar. This is why the country is divided IMO and it's smart. Internal division is the cost of guaranteed victory.

It works so long as the population is politically flexible and only focus on what's important to them. If people don't mind changing religion or language or some laws, then it really doesn't matter who wins the war. If the enemy doesn't have clear objectives for a war, then the loser of the war can still control the outcome.

Re:How Important Was the Battle of Hastings? by bigDinosaur on Saturday March 07, 2026 @08:51PM (#47293518)
Describing Germany's loss in WW2 as 'affecting their foreign policy a little' represents a profound disconnect with reality, which is that WW2 fundamentally reshaped the entire world, cemented the US as a superpower, set up the USSR for its rise, split Germany in two (with major political effects to this day), ended European empires (UK, French), and ultimately brought about the EU. And those are just some of WW2's effects, which would have all gone completely different directions if Germany or Japan had won.
Re:How Important Was the Battle of Hastings? by jongjong on Sunday March 08, 2026 @05:23AM (#47295831)
This is an elite narrative. What happened to normal people? In the real world? Germans still speak German. Germany is still very wealthy, many of the same companies are still around; including those which supported the Nazi war effort like Hugo Boss and Mercedes Benz. German chemical industry is extremely successful... Population of Germany exceeds that of France...

How did Germany's defeat actually negatively affect things for the people in the long run?

One of my ancestors (French side) had to close their business because they made the decision to keep paying for employee wages during the war while their business was forcibly put on hold by the French government... Winning the war didn't mean much to them... Mercedes people who made the German war machines were filling their pockets throughout the entire war. Didn't even negatively affect their reputation!

What happened to normal people is very different.

The people who won are those who looked out only for their own interests! It doesn't matter what side they were on.

Re:How Important Was the Battle of Hastings? by mathgeek on Sunday March 08, 2026 @06:30AM (#47296173)
Survivorship bias in action. We cannot see what didn’t happen.
Re:How Important Was the Battle of Hastings? by gherkinnn on Sunday March 08, 2026 @02:38PM (#47299801)
> This is an elite narrative. What happened to normal people? In the real world?

What a rubbish point you're pushing. Millions and millions died or were exterminated. Countless fled or were forcefully displaced. The country was occupied and then split apart, the effects of the DDR can be felt to this day. The collective shame will outlast any generation alive today.

Many institutions survived, yes, as they often do. But everything else was a nightmare that echoes to this day.

Re:How Important Was the Battle of Hastings? by keiferski on Saturday March 07, 2026 @11:51PM (#47294508)
The world would be completely different if Germany or Japan had won, or not been totally defeated, in WW2. Geopolitically, culturally, everything.
Re:How Important Was the Battle of Hastings? by PaulDavisThe1st on Saturday March 07, 2026 @11:13PM (#47294332)
The question was about the Battle of Hastings in 1066. Since the battle and the period following it are pretty well documented, there's no need to look for modern examples - we know what happened in England/Britain after William/Guillame won, and the results were absolutely transformative. Your summary of "the main outcome of a war" is completely disconnected from what took place in England after 1066.
Re:How Important Was the Battle of Hastings? by rixed on Saturday March 07, 2026 @11:30PM (#47294407)
I believe his point was that it was transformative for the elites (who are the one writing history) but not so much for society in general. A refreshing point of view; I also believe we tend to inflate the influence of war and politics and agency really in history.
Re:How Important Was the Battle of Hastings? by PaulDavisThe1st on Saturday March 07, 2026 @11:46PM (#47294474)
If that was their point, then their point is completely wrong in the context of the War of Hastings.

Do you and the GP really not know anything about how William/Guillame's victory tranformed England, for everyone? The very language we're writing in at this very moment is a direct consequence of that victory.

Re:How Important Was the Battle of Hastings? by rixed on Sunday March 08, 2026 @07:21AM (#47296454)
I believe we all agree about the facts, just not about what constitutes an "important change".

Most people lives were unaffected; most people kept their language, their traditions etc. For contrast, compare with: the third Punic war, setting foot on America in 1493, the industrial revolutions...

Some of us have just decided that's where we draw the line: An event that is important enough to wipe out and replace the whole ruling class but that does not change, one way or another, the way people live, is not "important".

Re:How Important Was the Battle of Hastings? by PaulDavisThe1st on Sunday March 08, 2026 @12:06PM (#47298402)
There are multiple time frames to be considered.

It is true that in the immediate aftermath of Hastings, life for most folks continued on largely as it had before.

But in the longer term both the administrative structure of the country (which very much affected individual folks' lives) and the language were significantly changed.

I don't see a reason to privilege one of these over the other. You could make the case, for example, that WWII was of little consequence because Germans today live much the same sort of life that they'd have been living if there had been no WWII. That's not clearly a false claim about people's lives, but it doesn't really serve the purpose of understanding the consequences of war very well.

Re:How Important Was the Battle of Hastings? by anonlinc77 on Saturday March 07, 2026 @10:22PM (#47294068)
This is not true. War materially changes the lives of the people before and after regardless of whether or not their language in customs are noticeably affected in the short term. Would you rather be a West German in 1938 or 1960? What about if you were Jewish?

I think the Jews in France in 1939 would have wished their government put up a better fight and had better generals who actually used the radio.

Also, the statement that France was on the German side is not true. The Germans conquered most of France in the first part of the war and installed a puppet regime that was loyal to them. This does not mean France was on the side of Germany, it means the Vichy puppet regime was.

You clearly know a decent amount about history, yet your analysis is so starkly wrong it appears you have an agenda.

Re:How Important Was the Battle of Hastings? by jongjong on Sunday March 08, 2026 @05:49AM (#47295955)
My agenda is; I'm not going to war for any country because it's pointless. I think it's governments who have an agenda.

According to Claude, Petain was installed after France's defeat; that's true, but Vichy France was already considered collaborationist with Nazi Germany at the time. Many public figures were pro-nazi such as Coco Chanel.

It's kind of insane actually that seemingly many of the big companies which supported the Nazis are still in business and actually grew and became synonymous with luxury after the war; Chanel, Hugo Boss, Mercedes Benz...

You'd think it would be bad for reputation; but reputation is the bread and butter of these companies today!

What better way to illustrate just how wrong the masses are when it comes to war? Clearly what we were taught is wrong! It doesn't align with economic reality!

Doesn't this corroborate my point that who wins the war doesn't matter?

Re:How Important Was the Battle of Hastings? by anonlinc77 on Monday March 09, 2026 @10:56AM (#47309966)
No, this does not corroborate your point at all.

Do you not believe the holocaust happened?

I seriously can't comprehend how anybody can say that the outcome of WWII didn't matter. For some wars, especially European wars before Napoleon, this is true. For WWII, I think there's a case to be made that no war in history has been more influential.

Your metric for what constitutes change is flawed. You can't say just because companies still exist and people still speak German that WWII doesn't matter. Seriously, take as step back and look at Germany before and after the war at all points. It's a completely different country that has fostered a people with completely different values.

Do you think Angela Merkel would have allowed so many refugees in if WWII never happened?

Re:How Important Was the Battle of Hastings? by linehedonist on Saturday March 07, 2026 @08:43PM (#47293460)
But as the article says, this battle really was tremendously important. The utter catastrophe led to the quick and permanent entrenchment of the Normans in Britain, with huge and long-reaching consequences reaching to the present: first and foremost, that the English language was profoundly altered at every level by influence from French.
Re:How Important Was the Battle of Hastings? by hluska on Saturday March 07, 2026 @09:01PM (#47293574)
Germany was divided for more than forty years after the Second World War. That absolutely changed their foreign policy and those changes have continued to be felt into the present day. The Second World War ended traditional power structures and changed foreign policy for everyone. That’s reality.
Re:How Important Was the Battle of Hastings? by Qwertious on Sunday March 08, 2026 @12:41AM (#47294783)
>Anglo-Saxons like to make fun of the French for surrendering easily but as a regular citizen, it actually makes logical sense. I think it just shows that the government is better aligned with the interests of the people.

>Strategic surrender is smart; if you know ahead of time which force is most powerful and can evaluate it objectively, you can save yourself the trouble of dying and you end up with a better outcome than you would have otherwise. It's risk management.

France didn't particularly surrender early. WW2 France surrendered because they were fucked and didn't have a choice; if they hadn't surrendered when they did, they would have been slaughtered and then their replacements would surrender just the same.

Russia would have done the same (and in fact, Ukraine tried to switch sides, especially with the Holomodor in such recent memory), but the Nazis were not pragmatic about permitting 'subhumans' to live.

Re:How Important Was the Battle of Hastings? by gherkinnn on Sunday March 08, 2026 @12:53AM (#47294871)
> Look at Germany after they lost WW2; they still speak German. Their cultural identity is still very strong; maybe it affected their foreign policy a little but apart from that, it's hard to tell.

What a comically bad take. I am looking at Germany and it is very easy to tell. Then go back a generation and look at what WWI did to Germany.

Re:How Important Was the Battle of Hastings? by pjc50 on Sunday March 08, 2026 @01:26AM (#47295068)
Lots of words to be weirdly wrong about things.

There certainly were a lot of minor "elite" wars in Europe where power shifted back and forth across the aristocracy with no real difference to daily life. WW2 was not one of them. Nor, historically, was the Thirty Years War.

OP may be confused by the American colonial wars since Korea. Korea is the last one where you can see the difference in outcomes for the population.

Re:How Important Was the Battle of Hastings? by jjk166 on Sunday March 08, 2026 @05:16PM (#47301568)
> Look at Germany after they lost WW2; they still speak German. Their cultural identity is still very strong; maybe it affected their foreign policy a little but apart from that, it's hard to tell.

Name a more dramatic overnight cultural shift in all of human history than nazi to post war germany.

Re:How Important Was the Battle of Hastings? by shoxidizer on Sunday March 08, 2026 @11:21PM (#47304525)
> Germany after they lost WW2; they still speak German

This is a trick of definition. There were a few places that spoke German before the war and don't now, but they aren't part of Germany today.