News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Humans 40k yrs ago developed a system of conventional signs by WalterBright on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @05:08PM (#47254632)
They could also be simply idle doodling or decorations.
Re:Humans 40k yrs ago developed a system of conventional signs by bryanlarsen on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @05:11PM (#47254675)
Too bad we don't have a paper that applies information theory techniques to answer that question. Oh wait...
Re:Humans 40k yrs ago developed a system of conventional signs by WalterBright on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @05:44PM (#47255034)
I remain skeptical. Pictures in clouds.
Re:Humans 40k yrs ago developed a system of conventional signs by djtango on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @08:27PM (#47256302)
What are you skeptical about? 40k years ago humans were just as we the humans of today, but they also faced harsher environments to survive in.

Technology has enabled us to compound advanced intergenerationally but I don't really believe we're actually that special when compared to our forebears...

Re:Humans 40k yrs ago developed a system of conventional signs by WalterBright on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @09:42PM (#47256837)
Take a look at Fig 1. A grid of dots. A sequence of X's. Does it mean "Property of Thag?" "Happy Birthday, Mom"? Are the X's there to improve one's grip on the object? Are they just idle doodling around the campfire? Hunter-gatherers have little use for writing.

We'll never know.

When I was young I was fascinated by drawing 5 pointed stars. It meant nothing.

Re:Humans 40k yrs ago developed a system of conventional signs by card_zero on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @10:45PM (#47257282)
Pictures in clouds, face on mars, pareidolia, I Want To Believe. That's what's to be skeptical about.
Re:Humans 40k yrs ago developed a system of conventional signs by chmod775 on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @08:38PM (#47256381)
Given that pressure from natural selection has lessened a lot, chances are that we are less special now.

Our intellect evolved for survival, but now it's very much optional - has been for many generations. It and may now even be inversely correlated with having offspring.

I would be unsurprised if we're noticably dumber now than we used to be.

Re:Humans 40k yrs ago developed a system of conventional signs by sebmellen on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @08:50PM (#47256475)
We seem to be making up for it with better nutrition and medicine.
Re:Humans 40k yrs ago developed a system of conventional signs by jamiek88 on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @09:02PM (#47256564)
Plus all the lead we spewed into the air for three generations.
Re:Humans 40k yrs ago developed a system of conventional signs by KevinMS on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @06:36PM (#47255529)
considering there are so many of them I think you are right.
Re:Humans 40k yrs ago developed a system of conventional signs by coldtea on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @08:35PM (#47256355)
Yes, the specialist researchers didn't think of that.
Re:Humans 40k yrs ago developed a system of conventional signs by card_zero on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @10:27PM (#47257153)
The researchers were not invested in thinking of that.
Re:Humans 40k yrs ago developed a system of conventional signs by dash2 on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @10:45PM (#47257290)
But they explicitly discuss it!
Re:Humans 40k yrs ago developed a system of conventional signs by card_zero on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @10:56PM (#47257353)
I wouldn't mind a quote, because the paper was incredibly hard to read, full of hedging, and never seemed to get to the point.

OK, there's this section:

> The Question of Decoration.

> Recent studies have measured the regularity of notches on bones to determine whether they are more or less visually striking as a decoration. Increasing the regularity of distances between notches—up to the differences just about perceivable by humans—is argued to enhance the decorative value. Such technological and experimental analyses are useful to thoroughly understand the production processes behind a given mobile artifact. On the other hand, categories such as “decoration” and “numerical system,” or “decoration” and “writing system” are not mutually exclusive. Rather, sign systems can be used as decoration without losing their information value. This is exemplified in historic times by calligraphy, inscriptions on pottery and temples, tattoos of graphemes on human bodies, and many other artistic expressions. “Information density” in an information-theoretic sense is a fundamental property of a sign sequence, irrespective of whether there is a human present to interpret it—or merely find it aesthetically pleasing.

So what are they saying: yes it looks like decoration, but maybe that's because it's calligraphy, and it's less than completely random. That means it's proto-writing because there's a scientific theory we can use to cloud the question of what it is exactly that we're claiming.

The BBC article on this quotes a researcher saying "The Stone Age sign sequences are an early alternative to writing." Fucking hell, "alternative to writing". We're not going out on a limb and saying its writing, but we want to heavily imply that without risking being wrong.

Re:Humans 40k yrs ago developed a system of conventional signs by WalterBright on Thursday March 05, 2026 @01:26AM (#47258239)
Yah, I'm not impressed by the obtuse language, either.
Re:Humans 40k yrs ago developed a system of conventional signs by empath75 on Thursday March 05, 2026 @09:39AM (#47262019)
I think the paper was just an exploration of various possibilities and doesn't come to any firm conclusion, because there isn't enough information to conclude anything.

I would assume that people in the past generally did things because they found it useful, though, and the idea that they were merely idly creating art is a more remarkable claim than that they were doing something primarily utilitarian, at least from their point of view.

To me, all of it seems like tally marks and counting and tally marks are among the earliest forms of writing we have in pretty much every case that I am aware of.

Re:Humans 40k yrs ago developed a system of conventional signs by adzm on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @08:49PM (#47256453)
It's probably both, each lending to the existence of the other.
Re:Humans 40k yrs ago developed a system of conventional signs by Netcob on Thursday March 05, 2026 @06:37AM (#47260449)
For that they used their Warhammer 80k figurines