News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Open source calculator firmware DB48X forbids CA/CO use d... by tliltocatl on Friday February 27, 2026 @01:49PM (#47184038)
For Linux it will be way more problematic because:

- A lot of of corporate contributions comes from SV.

- Linux Foundation is incorporated in CA.

- Linus himself is CA's resident AFAIR.

So there is zero chance of claiming no jurisdiction. The only hope is whoever is enforcing this batshit wouldn't go after what is essentially not an OS for the purpose of the bill, but rather an internal component (it would be like going after a vendor of bolts and nuts for noncompliance of a toaster).

Re:Open source calculator firmware DB48X forbids CA/CO use d... by thayne on Friday February 27, 2026 @04:12PM (#47185685)
It's more likely to be an issue for distributions like Debian, Ubuntu, Red Hat, etc.

Although, if I'm understanding this correctly, I think all they would have to do to comply is have something during installation that asks for the age category, and write a file that is world readable, but only writable by root that contains that category that applications can read.

Re:Open source calculator firmware DB48X forbids CA/CO use d... by Brian_K_White on Friday February 27, 2026 @05:10PM (#47186396)
That is already way too much as far as I'm concerned. It's not that it's difficult, it's that it's arbitrary and a form of commanded speech or action. Smallness and easiness isn't an excuse.

If you write a story, there must be a character in it somewhere that reminds kids not to smoke. That's all. It's very easy.

Re:Open source calculator firmware DB48X forbids CA/CO use d... by fc417fc802 on Friday February 27, 2026 @06:05PM (#47187171)
I actually don't mind mandating the market take reasonable actions. The EU mandating USB C was an excellent move that materially improved things.

However I think mandated actions should to the greatest extent possible be minimal, privacy preserving, and have an unambiguous goal that is clearly accomplished. This legislation fails in that regard because it mandates sharing personal information with third parties where it could have instead mandated queries that are strictly local to the device.

Re:Open source calculator firmware DB48X forbids CA/CO use d... by Brian_K_White on Friday February 27, 2026 @07:51PM (#47188448)
You've confused and confabulated like 11 different things there. None of what you said has anything to do with either what I said or what the law says.

The way this currently exists is basically unenfoceable because the critical terms are not even defined. It's not even ultimately intelligible, which is a prerequisite to enforcing, or even being able to tell where it does and does not apply, and whether some covered entity is or is not in compliance.

Re:Open source calculator firmware DB48X forbids CA/CO use d... by fc417fc802 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:43AM (#47190923)
> You've confused and confabulated like 11 different things there.

Feel free to elaborate. As it stands that's nothing more than name calling.

I wasn't speaking to the current CA or CO proposed implementations (which I don't support as it happens). I responded specifically to your statement:

> It's not that it's difficult, it's that it's arbitrary and a form of commanded speech or action.

My response being that I think it's acceptable for the regulator to require action under certain limited circumstances.

Re:Open source calculator firmware DB48X forbids CA/CO use d... by iamnothere on Friday February 27, 2026 @06:13PM (#47187282)
Under no circumstances should we be “mandating” how hobbyists write their software. If you want to scope this to commercial OSes, be my guest. That’s not what was done here.
Re:Open source calculator firmware DB48X forbids CA/CO use d... by fc417fc802 on Friday February 27, 2026 @06:26PM (#47187454)
I'm not sure where the line between "hobby" and "professional" lies when it comes to linux distributions. Many of them are nonprofit but not really hobbyist at this point. Debian sure feels like a professional product to me (I daily drive it).

We regulate how a hobbyist constructs and uses a radio. We regulate how a hobbyist constructs a shed in his yard or makes modifications to the electrical wiring in his house.

I think mandating the implementation of strictly device local filtering based on a standardized HTTP header (or in the case of apps an attached metadata field) would be reasonably non-invasive and of benefit to society (similar to mandating USB C).

Re:Open source calculator firmware DB48X forbids CA/CO use d... by jolmg on Saturday February 28, 2026 @01:59AM (#47191425)
> I'm not sure where the line between "hobby" and "professional" lies when it comes to linux distributions. Many of them are nonprofit but not really hobbyist at this point. Debian sure feels like a professional product to me (I daily drive it).

"Professional" means you're being paid for the work. Debian is free (gratis), contributors are volunteers, and that makes it not professional.

Re:Open source calculator firmware DB48X forbids CA/CO use d... by thayne on Saturday February 28, 2026 @02:22AM (#47191628)
What about Ubuntu? Its a combination of work by volunteers and paid employees, it is distributed by a commercial company, and said company sells support contracts, but the OS itself is free.

And there are developers who are paid to work on various components of linux from the kernel, to Gnome, does that make it professional?

Is Android not professional, because you don't pay for the OS itself, and it is primarily supported by ad revenue?

Re:Open source calculator firmware DB48X forbids CA/CO use d... by jolmg on Saturday February 28, 2026 @10:42AM (#47196631)
I would argue they're not, because they're not fully under the responsibility of a commercial entity, because they're open source. Companies can volunteer employees to the project, even a project they started themselves, but the companies and employees can come and go. Open source projects exist independently as public goods. Ultimately, it just takes anyone in the world to fork a project to exclude everybody else from its development.

Mint started off as Ubuntu. Same project, with none of the support contracts, no involvement from Canonical needed at the end of the day, etc.

On a practical level, it doesn't make sense to put thousands of dollars per user in liabilities to non-compensated volunteers whatever the case may be with regards to the employment of other contributors.

Re:Open source calculator firmware DB48X forbids CA/CO use d... by fc417fc802 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @03:27PM (#47199866)
At some point it seems to devolve from a meaningful discussion about how things should be done into a semantic argument (which are almost always pointless).

> it doesn't make sense to put thousands of dollars per user in liabilities to non-compensated volunteers

I agree when it comes to individuals. But it probably does make sense to hold formally recognized groups (such as nonprofits) accountable to various consumer laws. I think the idea odd that Windows, RHEL, Ubuntu, and Debian should all be regulated differently within a single jurisdiction given that they seem to me largely equivalent in purpose.

Re:Open source calculator firmware DB48X forbids CA/CO use d... by iamnothere on Friday February 27, 2026 @05:20PM (#47186534)
And then another state will pass a law mandating scanning of all local images, and another state will want automated scanning of text, and a different country will want a backdoor for law enforcement. We have to stop this here and now.
Re:Open source calculator firmware DB48X forbids CA/CO use d... by helterskelter on Friday February 27, 2026 @02:47PM (#47184711)
I believe Linus lives in Oregon.
[dead]
Re:Open source calculator firmware DB48X forbids CA/CO use d... by tliltocatl on Friday February 27, 2026 @02:43PM (#47184659)
Stop spreading disinformation. Linus and others did most of the work in the kernel. GNU project on the kernel side was architecture astronaut vaporware aka "Hurd". They were much more successful in userland (coreutils, gcc and the toolchain, gdb, Emacs, to name a few).
Re:Open source calculator firmware DB48X forbids CA/CO use d... by mghackerlady on Friday February 27, 2026 @02:47PM (#47184713)
I meant the userland specifically. By calling what is fundamentally a GNU system running on a different kernel just "linux" it makes people think linux and his crew made all of the userland, in part because saying a college student made "an entire operating system" is far more profitable for news agencies than acknowledging his important but overall relatively small role in what they call "linux"
Re:Open source calculator firmware DB48X forbids CA/CO use d... by tliltocatl on Friday February 27, 2026 @03:01PM (#47184829)
Because the kernel is the irreplaceable piece. None of what GNU did is: there are numerous implementations of coreutils and shells and at least one non-GNU production-quality compiler toolchain (clang-llvm), a few alternative libcs. And many distribution do actively use the non-GNU parts. But none of this is useful without the kernel that is compatible with computers people have. And the only usable kernel we have is Linux (while BSDs are out there too, they take a much different tightly-integrated approach to userspace).
Re:Open source calculator firmware DB48X forbids CA/CO use d... by spijdar on Friday February 27, 2026 @03:14PM (#47184959)
To add to this: I can appreciate the significance of GNU, especially in early Linux distributions, but the position of "GNU was the real OS, Linux was just the kernel" is also deceptive, IMO.

Sure, a lot of the userspace was GNU, but a lot of it ... wasn't. Things like PAM, the init system, and the network config tools, off the top of my head. A lot of system-specific tools come from "not-GNU", too.

You can't discount how much of early Linux was "GNU", and how big a deal GCC and GNU libc (and the rest!) were, but it's disingenuous in my opinion to call GNU an "operating system" that you just plugged Linux, the kernel, into. Even today, as far as I can tell, there is still not a true GNU system. Guix comes close, in terms of being "GNU-ish", but the most usable Hurd distro (AFAIK!) is Debian, where, again, a lot of components come from Debian, rather than GNU.

And, as you say, modern systems have drifted even further from being GNU. They have lots of GNU components, but so did, say, the Sprite OS, or a lot of 4.4BSD derivatives.

Re:Open source calculator firmware DB48X forbids CA/CO use d... by mghackerlady on Monday March 02, 2026 @10:06AM (#47218908)
On that note, one of these days I want to make the GNU system as it was imagined a reality. Perhaps with the linux kernel as its kernel, maybe with co-official status with the hurd
Re:Open source calculator firmware DB48X forbids CA/CO use d... by mghackerlady on Monday March 02, 2026 @10:04AM (#47218879)
Oh, I don't discount that! That's why I find it important to specify GNU/Linux. Not only is it respectful, but it makes the very important distinction that it is a Linux system running a GNU userland instead of a plan9 one or a busybox one. Usually when people speak of "linux" they're referring to GNU/Linux though
Re:Open source calculator firmware DB48X forbids CA/CO use d... by pkaye on Friday February 27, 2026 @04:26PM (#47185853)
I think Linus Torvalds lives in Oregon.
Re:Open source calculator firmware DB48X forbids CA/CO use d... by fsckboy on Friday February 27, 2026 @11:04PM (#47190248)
"Linux" is just the source code to the kernel, pure free speech, and it can't run by itself in order to ask anybody anything. Underage programmers will benefit from the education of reading it.
Re:Open source calculator firmware DB48X forbids CA/CO use d... by josephg on Friday February 27, 2026 @11:22PM (#47190393)
Exactly. More bluntly, the Linux kernel isn't an operating system.