News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by wmf on Monday October 29, 2012 @12:39PM (#4713064)
Yeah, these prices look almost too good to be true. Other Android vendors may be getting some serious indigestion from this.
Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by distantparts on Monday October 29, 2012 @02:52PM (#4713820)
You can't imagine that Samsung will be thrilled about the Nexus 4. The Galaxy S3 suddenly looks poor value, and that's their flagship device. It was selling in big numbers, and although it's cheaper than the iPhone 5, presumably it's still a very profitable device.

If Google are determined to sell high quality devices at cost to gain market share, and can make the general public aware of this (non-trivial), Apple may find itself as the sole company making big profits from actually selling phone hardware.

That said, only Samsung with their Galaxy brand have come anywhere near the marketing impact of the iPhone, so if Google really want to make an impression, they're going to need market these devices at a level that they've never managed before.

Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by objclxt on Monday October 29, 2012 @03:38PM (#4714059)
You have to wonder whether Motorola are best pleased about it either - it's hardly a ringing endorsement that Google have farmed the Nexus 4 out to LG rather than use the device manufacturer that they own.
Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by wmf on Monday October 29, 2012 @03:51PM (#4714123)
Google said the Motorola integration will take 12-18 months. The Nexus 4 was probably being designed before the acquisition.
Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by gamble on Monday October 29, 2012 @03:52PM (#4714126)
I'm waiting for them to shut Motorola down. It's generating huge losses, yet Google is doing nothing with it. And they've stated the patents are all Google values.
Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by Supermighty on Monday October 29, 2012 @03:58PM (#4714163)
These devices have 18 month lead times. Give them some time. The next round of devices from Motorola should be heavily influenced by Google by then.
Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by voltagex_ on Monday October 29, 2012 @06:46PM (#4714948)
The Nexus 4 maxes out at 16gb available storage and there's no expansion. It only really competes with the base model S3.

It's Samsung's own fault they haven't got the 4.2 update out properly yet.

Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by jug6ernaut on Monday October 29, 2012 @01:02PM (#4713211)
While I have no hard figured I believe the cost difference is because Google is probably selling these devices at or around there cost. They are selling them (like how amazon does with their tablets) as content delivery systems. Simply as a way to get more people to into the google ecosystem.

Other companies must sell their devices to make a profit, google does not. As long as they are close to making even on device cost they can make up for and exceed it elsewhere.

Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by ImprovedSilence on Monday October 29, 2012 @02:14PM (#4713645)
But you can't buy one of these through verizon, you have to pay the full price. Most people will still get the other phones at the "discounted" price after 2 year contract.... It just seems like the path of least resistance for the consumer.
Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by icebraining on Monday October 29, 2012 @02:08PM (#4713617)
But Google doesn't make the devices, LG does.
Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by mattmanser on Monday October 29, 2012 @02:09PM (#4713624)
I thought Apple's app store makes a fraction of what they make on the phones?

Although Google's profit's are in the billions, so are their users. Their profit per user is actually pretty small to be running an at a loss hardware device.

And we can't pretend that people don't use their ecosystem on other devices anyway.

I honestly have no clue at what Google are trying to achieve sometimes. I mean it makes sense for Amazon, but Google? Not so much.

Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by MaxDPS on Monday October 29, 2012 @04:42PM (#4714358)
I think it makes sense for Google because the more devices they have in the wild, the more advertisements they can serve. Also, the more data they can get from users (location/maps/statistics). And I very much doubt that they are selling these at a loss. More like breaking even.
Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by Retric on Monday October 29, 2012 @02:36PM (#4713746)
Last I checked it was the other way around, iTunes and the App store are basically run at cost to get people to buy more devices.
Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by jonknee on Monday October 29, 2012 @03:35PM (#4714041)
No, but the profit made is tiny in comparison to the giant margins they make on iOS devices ($700 iPhones that cost $175 to make really pad the bottom line).
Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by _djo_ on Monday October 29, 2012 @05:00PM (#4714421)
It does not cost $175 to make, that's just the estimated bill of materials (BOM) cost. The actual cost to manufacture includes labour, design, shipping, testing, storage and dozens of other things.

Apple's gross margins on its devices, essentially the selling price less the manufacturing costs, is about 30-40% company-wide. That translates into an operating margin (which includes all costs) in the 20-30% range.

That's high for a consumer electronics company, but not as high as the $700 - $175 comparison makes it sound.

Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by RShiki on Monday October 29, 2012 @06:41PM (#4714930)
The entry level, 16gb iPhone has a profit margin that is bigger than average, but not huge. The 64gb iPhone on the other hand.. it's like printing money. The markup doesn't even begin to compare to what the bigger storage actually cost to Apple. Apple makes a LOOOOT of money out of the customers who have bigger needs than average.

That's been Apple's strategy forever, people who want more have to pay a lot more than what it's really worth. I can remember the entry level iBook (during the PPC days) being sold with goddamn combo DVD reader/CD writer drives in a time where EVERY SINGLE PC LAPTOP SOLD, even the cheapest crap, had a DVD writer. Just to push people onto the higher profit margin.

I love Apple products but they really know how to milk their customers dry. Hacker News's audience wouldn't fall for that, but I can remember the markup on ram, when they still sold devices with 1 or 2gb of ram when the competition had 4gb on their cheapest stuff, with huge markups on the online apple store if you ordered a laptop with more ram. People here know how to put more ram in their computers and know not to order a macbook with "Apple's ram" (... a traditional thing that is going to die with the retina mbp and its soldered ram), but the average joe just got ripped off hardcore.

If you only look at their entry products, like the 16gb iPhone, the 21" iMac, the 11" MBA, yeah, Apple seems reasonable. Any other Apple product ? the margins on those things is something no one else could pull off without getting lynched.

Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by kooshball on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @02:56AM (#4716413)
>If you only look at their entry products, like the 16gb iPhone, the 21" iMac, the 11" MBA, yeah, Apple seems reasonable. Any other Apple product ? the margins on those things is something no one else could pull off without getting lynched.

This is a pretty common case of price discrimination. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_discrimination

Apple is certainly not the only company that does it. However they do commonly have a higher profit margin than their competitors.

Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by _djo_ on Monday October 29, 2012 @07:20PM (#4715100)
I remember how ridiculous Apple's RAM prices used to be and you're right about their pricing strategy on iPhone storage representing a large markup. As I said, Apple's margins are high for a consumer electronics company, partly because they're able to employ those pricing tiers.

The point of my post wasn't to defend Apple, it was to show that comparing the selling price and bill of materials figures to highlight profit is simplistic and wrong. What actually matters is gross margin and operating margin, both of which are made public so there's no need to refer to the estimated BoM as the OP did. This applies to all companies, the all-too-common misunderstanding of BoM figures is a pet hate of mine.

Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by RShiki on Monday October 29, 2012 @07:40PM (#4715174)
Point taken, and I'm not really hating on Apple either so I don't really think of you as "defending" them, I'm just stating my thoughts about their strategy.

Apple completely changed the way I look at mobile devices. My first smartphone and tablet were the iPhone and iPad. I just wish they'd be more reasonable on some points, but they're obviously too successful to change their strategy unless a strong competitor shows up (and I hope that Google's strategy with the Nexus pays off).

I also am part of those who switched to Android but think that Apple had some reasonable arguments against Samsung that made them go wild against them. When you go as far as to make the charger look like an Apple charger you know there's something wrong going on. Samsung clearly tried to ride on the popularity of Apple products by making it look as much as possible as the iPhone and iPad, be it in the packaging, included accessories, look, early TouchWiz releases... there's a reason why TouchWiz on the S3 isn't like TouchWiz on the first Galaxy phones.. The customization on early Samsung android devices went too far toward Apple's direction. Even the "hardware" buttons, making the home button prominent and the other two android buttons more invisible in the design, and still keeping the home button as fully hardware on the S3 rather than going onscreen or capacitive like the other android OEMs.

Apple makes great products, but I feel like they're trying too much to milk us as much as they can.

Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by _djo_ on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @07:15AM (#4716921)
Heh, I think we may both have misunderstood each other. My apologies.

I agree though, Apple's price discrimination may be understandable but as a customer it can really grind sometimes. When I went for an iPad I decided on the 16GB model for cost reasons and regretted it ever since, but the price jump to the 32GB was big enough that I shied away from it. It was annoying that the premium for a component that cost a fraction of what they charged created an uncomfortable dilemma for me that as a customer I shouldn't really have faced.

In all I'm excited about the level of competition, with MS's Surface bringing in another interesting angle, and I hope it continues for a long time. For one, though I have an iPad already I'm pretty sure I'm going to be picking up a Nexus 7 soon.

Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by jonknee on Monday October 29, 2012 @06:38PM (#4714921)
> Apple's gross margins on its devices, essentially the selling price less the manufacturing costs, is about 30-40% company-wide. That translates into an operating margin (which includes all costs) in the 20-30% range.

Of course there are other expenses (those $10M Apple Stores don't build themselves), but you're incorrect about the operating margin. For Q4 2012 AAPL had an operating margin of 34% (gross margin was 40%).

Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by _djo_ on Monday October 29, 2012 @07:09PM (#4715047)
The last figures I saw matched what I put in my post, though they may be older than I realised. Thanks for the correction.
Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by bitcartel on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @12:35AM (#4716086)
ZTE just announced a phone with a retail price of 999 yuan ($160). If they can eek out a profit margin, makes you wonder what the real manufacturing cost is for the big players.

"ZTE U950 smartphone packs a 1.3GHz Tegra 3 chip, 1GB of RAM, 4GB of internal storage and a 2,000mAh battery beneath the 4.3-inch display."

http://www.engadget.com/2012/10/29/ztes-u950-tegra-3-phone/

Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by gutnor on Monday October 29, 2012 @02:42PM (#4713781)
Other vendors have already failed, except on the low cost. Samsung rules the phone market, it is everyday closer to become synonym with Android and could be tempted to secede like Amazon.

That is not a good situation for either Android or Google - and except Google breaking the price, there is little else that can revive the market a little bit.

Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by kevin_p on Monday October 29, 2012 @11:34PM (#4715897)
They already did in China. My wife bought a Galaxy S2 in January, and it came with Samsung Apps instead of Google Play, no Google Maps, no Gmail or Google Talk etc. Yes, it's a legitimate Samsung product, not some Chinese knockoff.

She's hugely disappointed with it and refuses to buy any more Samsung products. (It doesn't help that she refuses to let me root it and install CyanogenMod, but you don't expect to have to do that if you're paying the equivalent of over $600 US for a phone)

Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by yohui on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @02:25AM (#4716345)
I wouldn't assume that was Samsung's choice. Isn't that a legacy of old disagreements between Google and the PRC?

I know that Asus Transformer Primes sold in China did not come with Google services, either, though buyers quickly learned that using a US/Taiwan/International update file would restore functionality fairly easily.

Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by kevin_p on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @09:54PM (#4720752)
China's situation does have something to do with it (you can't buy paid apps on Google Play here, YouTube is blocked and Google search frequently has 'technical problems'), and that's probably Samsung's excuse, but other manufacturers manage to keep Google services on their phones (although often alongside their own or another 3rd-party app store). I think it's just Samsung taking advantage of the situation to avoid paying Google's fees, not a case of gapps being legally banned in China.
Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by fluidcruft on Monday October 29, 2012 @04:32PM (#4714317)
Good luck if Samsung thinks they can strike it out on their own without Google Play, Google Maps and Gmail.
Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by gms on Monday October 29, 2012 @12:59PM (#4713192)
Nexus 7 devices are being sold at a loss, so I suppose in one sense yes, the price there is too good to be true.
Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by cmatthias on Monday October 29, 2012 @02:58PM (#4713848)
I'm not quite sure whether there was ever an original source for this claim other than a bunch of tech blogs parroting each other, but iSuppli shows that this was false, at least as of July 11th:

http://www.isuppli.com/Teardowns/News/pages/Low-End-Google-N...

Sure, if you add in the $25 Google play credit, and leave room for some margin for Asus (since Google is just a reseller), you might get close to breaking even, but as far as I can find, the Nexus 7 was never sold at a loss.

Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by gms on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @02:52PM (#4718852)
I stand corrected; thanks.
Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by RShiki on Monday October 29, 2012 @06:34PM (#4714903)
It's not sold at a loss, but with a very low profit margin. At a loss would mean that they're actually bearing the cost of manufacturing the device even after they got your money, which is not true.

They also get a much higher profit margin on the 16gb (now the 32gb for the Nexus 7) than on the 8gb which is what a lot of people will buy. There isn't a $50 cost in manufacturing a device with 16gb more of storage but there is a $50 markup for the customers who want more local storage. Storage is much, much cheaper than what you're paying for when you buy a tablet or phone with bigger SSDs. The profit margins on the 64gb iPhones are INSANE compared to the profit margins on the 16gb.

The base, $300 Nexus 4 is going to have a paltry 8gb. Most of the heavy users are going to spend the $50 more for the 16gb, while the $300 will still be there to please those who have to be more careful with their money.

Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by Rastafarian on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @02:45PM (#4718806)
When you factor in the huge R&D costs, the cheapest models are definitely sold at a lost.
Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by illumin8 on Monday October 29, 2012 @04:01PM (#4714178)
If the device is free (or close to cost) then buyer beware... The device is not the product; you are!
Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by trimbo on Monday October 29, 2012 @01:05PM (#4713233)
> Nexus 7 devices are being sold at a loss

Back in June... and only for the $199 model...

Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by bryanlarsen on Monday October 29, 2012 @01:32PM (#4713395)
What I heard is that Google isn't making money on them, but ASUS is.
Re:Nexus: The best of Google, now in three sizes by jonknee on Monday October 29, 2012 @01:05PM (#4713228)
Source?