News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:America vs. Singapore: You Can't Save Your Way Out of Eco... by rayiner on Thursday February 19, 2026 @10:06AM (#47074563)
A confounding factor here is that savings behavior is cultural rooted: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6135367/. Studies show that people within a country can have substantially different savings behaviors, robustly correlated with their origin countries, even among people who are third generation immigrants. It’s a mistake to treat either the U.S. or Singapore as homogenous populations for purposes of this analysis.
Re:America vs. Singapore: You Can't Save Your Way Out of Eco... by guardianbob on Thursday February 19, 2026 @10:24AM (#47074791)
Both sides see declines when hit with economic shocks

We are talking about material impacts, not culture

Re:America vs. Singapore: You Can't Save Your Way Out of Eco... by janalsncm on Thursday February 19, 2026 @12:52PM (#47076718)
75% of Singaporeans are ethnically Chinese so based on what you are saying it would be worth comparing SG Chinese to Chinese CN on regret since China has a much less robust safety net.
Re:America vs. Singapore: You Can't Save Your Way Out of Eco... by dexwiz on Thursday February 19, 2026 @07:56PM (#47082231)
I once heard a linguistic explanation for this.

European languages have a future tense, which means people have different ideas of themselves in the present and future. You can even hear this in phrases like "that's a problem for future me."

While Chinese lacks the European styled future tense, ignoring time phrases, auxiliary verbs, etc. So people more clearly conceptualize their present and future selves as the same. Leading to things like increased saving.

This of course is rooted in linguist psychology, a very soft science. But still an interesting idea.

Re:America vs. Singapore: You Can't Save Your Way Out of Eco... by itemize123 on Friday February 20, 2026 @01:57AM (#47084632)
dont think this hold much water at all.
Re:America vs. Singapore: You Can't Save Your Way Out of Eco... by rudolftheone on Friday February 20, 2026 @02:51AM (#47084992)
This sounds like the 'Future Time Reference' hypothesis by Keith Chen (2013). It’s indeed a fascinating idea, but it’s essentially an example of Galton’s problem (treating related cultures/languages as independent data points).

What makes this story (scientifically) great is that Chen himself co-authored a follow-up study just two years later [1] to rigorously test his own theory. When they re-analyzed the data using mixed-effects models to control for cultural phylogeny and relatedness, the correlation between grammar and savings pretty much disappeared.

They concluded the original finding was likely a spurious correlation.

It turns out that cultural history drives both the language we speak and our saving habits, rather than the grammar causing the behavior.

[1] https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal...

Re:America vs. Singapore: You Can't Save Your Way Out of Eco... by dexwiz on Friday February 20, 2026 @01:45PM (#47092075)
Thanks for the follow up. I am always hesitant to believe things that sound too Gladwellian.