News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Alabama offers three tricks to fix poor urban schools by gruez on Thursday February 19, 2026 @09:07AM (#47073864)
Look at the chart. Adjusted for "poverty rate and other demographics", the top states are red states, so it's harder to chalk it up as some sort of n=1 outlier.
Re:Alabama offers three tricks to fix poor urban schools by fncypants on Thursday February 19, 2026 @09:13AM (#47073933)
What does that mean, "adjusted for poverty"? Reading level is an absolute. You're either at a third grade level or not. This adjustment seems to have no purpose other than completing a narrative that does not help solve the problem.
Re:Alabama offers three tricks to fix poor urban schools by nixon_why69 on Thursday February 19, 2026 @09:19AM (#47073996)
To be fair to gruez, the chart was made by the economist and not by them.

To be less fair to the economist, "adjusted by poverty level" is a heck of a spin, we've had many generations as a developed nation now, your state poverty level is caused by your state education outcomes. And that's without even speculating about what "demographic factors" means or implies.

Re:Alabama offers three tricks to fix poor urban schools by walthamstow on Thursday February 19, 2026 @09:46AM (#47074325)
> we've had many generations as a developed nation now

Have you? Jim Crow apartheid was in place in my parents lifetime. I don't care how many cars and ship you make, that ain't developed.

Re:Alabama offers three tricks to fix poor urban schools by nixon_why69 on Thursday February 19, 2026 @09:56AM (#47074451)
You're right, but "don't blame us, we were investing our energy in oppressing the blacks" isn't really the greatest excuse for cotton belt states when it comes to their education and gdp numbers.
Re:Alabama offers three tricks to fix poor urban schools by squeefers on Thursday February 19, 2026 @09:27AM (#47074100)
> your state poverty level is caused by your state education outcomes.

bad teachers dont make an area poor. a poor area doesnt have the money for good teachers, youve got it the wrong way around.

Re:Alabama offers three tricks to fix poor urban schools by bluGill on Thursday February 19, 2026 @10:14AM (#47074668)
Teachers generally make the same in a suburb as in an inner city school. In the Des Moines area all schools get the same amount of money per student, but you still see suburbs outperforming the city schools. I don't know what the problem is, but this disproves the money is the problem theory.
Re:Alabama offers three tricks to fix poor urban schools by squeefers on Thursday February 19, 2026 @10:39AM (#47074984)
he said the link was with poverty and education outcomes, not school funding and education outcomes
Re:Alabama offers three tricks to fix poor urban schools by the_sleaze_ on Thursday February 19, 2026 @09:36AM (#47074196)
No, gp is correct. Good public education is a profoundly good indicator of economic prosperity, though it is a long term investment.
Re:Alabama offers three tricks to fix poor urban schools by squeefers on Thursday February 19, 2026 @10:01AM (#47074522)
> Good public education is a profoundly good indicator of economic prosperity

well yeah.... because for good schools you need good money. no money = bad schools. good schools dont appear in poor areas. thats the connection.

Re:Alabama offers three tricks to fix poor urban schools by gruez on Thursday February 19, 2026 @09:28AM (#47074110)
> we've had many generations as a developed nation now, your state poverty level is caused by your state education outcomes.

Does this explain the gap between white/black poverty too?

Re:Alabama offers three tricks to fix poor urban schools by gruez on Thursday February 19, 2026 @09:23AM (#47074044)
>You're either at a third grade level or not. This adjustment seems to have no purpose other than completing a narrative that does not help solve the problem.

How should you measure an education system? Should you measure purely based on the student's performance? What if the students are just better at reading, independent of the school? It's not hard to imagine that even with identical teachers, that inner cities schools would have worse test scores than wealthy suburban schools, especially if the latter are rich enough to afford tutors, the family environment is more conductive to learning, etc. Recognizing this fact, it's fairly obvious that "you're either at a third grade level or not" is a terrible way of assessing how good of a job an educational system is doing.

Re:Alabama offers three tricks to fix poor urban schools by ch4s3 on Thursday February 19, 2026 @10:20AM (#47074751)
> What does that mean, "adjusted for poverty"? Reading level is an absolute

Reading scores are SUPER strongly correlated with family income levels in the US. The fact that Alabama does a better job teaching its poorest students to read than Massachusetts does is impressive, particularly given the disparity in funding levels.

Re:Alabama offers three tricks to fix poor urban schools by bell-cot on Thursday February 19, 2026 @09:30AM (#47074119)
If you were comparing HS basketball coaches on the basis of how well their teams perform on the court, then you might find it useful to correct for how many tall kids went to the high schools they were coaching at.