News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by kamaal on Saturday October 27, 2012 @11:09AM (#4706277)
This really should be 'How long will 'some' Programmers Be So Well-Paid'?

C'mon lets be frank not all programmers are well paid, You really have to be working at Google or other big place or make it big in the start up area. None, of that is any different than any other profession I know of. In fact even the author seems to be talking of 'Google and Facebook' employees, the number of people working at Google and Facebook are small enough to consider them a clear exception.

What you really must be talking about is of a time around a decade and a half back when programmers seem to be paid well. And even they were paid well not because they were programming, its just that the IT sector grew so rapidly there was a immense demand in the middle level management areas that caused a impression of rapid career progress in the software industry. That is what made people to 'come in the game for the money'.

The only distinction that I see programming has compared to other professions is programmers tend to think of themselves as people 'who solve problems' and not just people who write code. No other profession, I know of carries that tag line.

Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by jiggy2011 on Saturday October 27, 2012 @11:32AM (#4706325)
Precisely.

The article quotes the average starting salary at google to be $125,000. After converting that into GBP (for the UK where I live) you get to 77,613.

Whenever I look around at local programming jobs, a salary of 77K would be attainable mainly only by people who were project leaders/architects for large corporate systems.

Most entry level jobs are .Net, PHP or Java programming and will net you a salary of 18-25K. A programmer with 4-10 years experience can maybe expect to get paid 30-35K.

Basically a similar payscale to a plant fitter , electrician or teacher and quite a way off what you would expect for a doctor or lawyer.

Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by ef4 on Saturday October 27, 2012 @12:09PM (#4706423)
I've noticed weird cultural differences between the UK and US in terms of how programmers are perceived by businesses.

I interviewed with a major UK software consulting business that was trying to open their first US office, and it was immediately apparent that their expectations were way off from the local conditions.

The interview included a programming test, which I was "not expected to finish, we just want to see how far you can get". I finished in half the allotted time, and they didn't seem to know what to do with me. Then they offered half the salary that I was concurrently being offered by another company in the same location, and they weren't willing to negotiate upward when I pointed out that fact.

They clearly weren't interested in hiring someone who could be trusted with serious responsibility. They wanted that mythical creature: the programmer who can operate like an assembly line worker, cranking specs into code in a repeatable and easily replaceable way.

I've seen the insides of many US software companies, and I've never seen one that seemed to take such a dim view of their programmers. You might see that attitude in non-software companies that begrudgingly spend some money on internal programmers, but not in the companies that make their money directly with software.

Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by jiggy2011 on Saturday October 27, 2012 @12:22PM (#4706470)
There are more progressive software companies in the UK with better culture, although they seem to be mainly doing that by cargo-culting what google and other SV companies are doing.

Salaries paid aren't that much better in these companies though. Expectations of programmer aptitude are all over the map also, companies do like administering those "programming tests" which can vary from very tricky math problems to stuff like "What is the keyword for inheritance in Java?". Thing is that salaries in both types of jobs tend to be similar.

Another problem with these tests is that they are often administered by recruiters who don't even bother to bring them upto date, a friend had a test for a C# programming position which asked him mostly questions about VB6.

It's quite a shame because the government likes to talk about how they want tech innovation to happen in the UK as it does with the US. However most of the top programmers seem to either end up going abroad or getting assimilated into finance or into various gigantic consulting corps.

Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by bowyakka on Saturday October 27, 2012 @04:46PM (#4707184)
I can attest to the going abroad thing, I made the move and have been astonished by the jump in salary and autonomy in the US over the UK.

What makes it weirder is I didn't change company only location

Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by lnanek2 on Saturday October 27, 2012 @11:40AM (#4706342)
125k/year is pretty standard for a senior programmer who doesn't lead teams, etc. in SF/NYC where I frequent. Bump that up an extra 20k if they are willing to program something undesirable like ads or they have finance experience as well. Other locations will pay less, of course, because they aren't where all the hot tech companies are and they don't have the same cost of living. If you network a lot it is pretty easy to pull in 10k/month contracting, though.
Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by seanmcdirmid on Saturday October 27, 2012 @11:50AM (#4706376)
10k/month contracting isn't that much if you aren't taking into account taxes, insurance, being on the beach, etc...you'd have to pull in around 20k/month to match a 120k salary.
Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by ryanwaggoner on Saturday October 27, 2012 @01:14PM (#4706609)
This is an exaggeration, at least for the US. Yes, it's true that taxes will take a big chunk out of your $10k / month, but they'll take a pretty big chunk out of your $120k / yr salary, too. The only real tax "savings" you get by being employed is that your employer pays the other half of your Social security and medicare taxes (12.4% total for 2012), which means that you'll have to pay an "extra" 6.2% if you're self-employed. And most of that is SS, which caps at $106k or something. Couple this with the fact that self-employed folks have a variety of deductions that employees usually don't get (home office, special retirement options, lots of business expenses), and it starts to look a little more even.

It's true that you don't get paid time off, but I can tell you from experience that a decent and determined freelance programmer can easily make $10k / month and leave plenty of time for relaxation.

The biggest thing most self-employed folks have to deal with that they wouldn't normally is health insurance, but if you're young and healthy, decent insurance is a few hundred bucks a month, at most. And you can deduct the premiums. If you're not young and/or not healthy...that's another story.

Bottom line, if you want to match a $120k / yr job as a freelancer, you need to make something like $12k - $14k / month.

Source: personal experience and a fascination with legal tax avoidance strategies.

Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by jiggy2011 on Saturday October 27, 2012 @11:47AM (#4706369)
Geography definitely matters. My numbers were based on non-London UK for example. If you were looking at jobs in London you could probably add 5-10K to each of the figures I quoted.

I assume that those 125k/year jobs are for either large companies or profitable/highly financed startups?

I'm guessing that there are lots of startup programmers out there on very low salaries who are working mainly for equity which is a much harder thing to value.

Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by mattmanser on Saturday October 27, 2012 @12:17PM (#4706456)
I just checked jobserve for C# and Java in Birmingham, Bristol, Leeds, Nottingham and Manchester.

All have plenty of jobs going up to £45k-£50k, and that's what they're offering before you even walk in the room and they find out they like you.

£35k seemed to be the ceiling about 2 years ago, I think demand is really starting to push it up.

Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by greenyoda on Saturday October 27, 2012 @05:23PM (#4707287)
One difference between programmers and doctors is that there is an artificially imposed scarcity of doctors. Nobody can be licensed to practice medicine (at least in the U.S.) without completing medical school and a residency, and the number of openings is controlled by the medical schools. In contrast, you can become a very good programmer without having any formal education in the field (I know a few such people). This allows the supply of programmers to increase more quickly than the supply of doctors.
Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by nodemaker on Saturday October 27, 2012 @11:48AM (#4706373)
I dont think we can compare salaries in Silicon Valley and UK like that. In the end its about how much you have after you pay all your basic expenses and I think the person with GBP 77K has much more left than the person with $125K in California.

Edit: Apparently living in the UK aint too cheap either. Did not know that!

Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by jiggy2011 on Saturday October 27, 2012 @11:58AM (#4706393)
Not sure what tax rates are like in San Francisco however if you that kind of money in the UK you are going to be paying 40% income tax on a pretty large chunk of it. So after income tax you are left with maybe 50K.

We also have council tax which in some places will make your eyes pop out. Not to mention VAT which is going to be 20% of pretty much everything you buy. On top of that house prices can be very high here for a family sized home even in a modest area so you're going to be paying a lot for your mortgage.

Plus we have a huge amount of tax on stuff like fuel and anything to do with cars, not to mention that food prices are generally higher here than in the USA.

OTOH medical insurance isn't really an issue as well as other things like more help available from govt to cover higher education.

Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by raverbashing on Saturday October 27, 2012 @02:18PM (#4706799)
Exactly that

I'm thinking the 125k in California may be a better deal, except the cost of living may be higher there (not much public transport, housing is expensive as well, etc)

But the UK income taxes are huge. Ireland taxes are similar. Continental Europe has smaller taxes (but then salaries may be smaller, so 'take home money' can be similar)

Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by coroxout on Saturday October 27, 2012 @02:51PM (#4706870)
Not sure about this. In my experience accommodation in the UK is more than in the US (possibly not in the big cities or SV, though it was true of SF last time I visited), gas and electricity are a lot more expensive, and food is about the same price.

  Average annual salary of software developer in US: $93,000
  Average annual salary of software developer in UK: £35,000 = $56,000 approx

  Average house price in the US: $181,500  
  Average house price in the UK: £234,000 = $376,014
Ever feel like you're in the wrong country?

(the 93k figure from this recently front-paged article: <http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4696113>; all other figures from a randomly-selected page from the first few Google results, but the UK figures seem reasonable to me - I'm in the south of England but outside London, and houses here are all above 250k but most programming jobs I see offer 30-35k. Of course using nationwide averages isn't necessarily an accurate picture as the places with most tech jobs available are probably not the ones with most houses on the market)

Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by rayiner on Saturday October 27, 2012 @06:05PM (#4707385)
To be fair, "average" is a weird measurement for comparing the US to the UK. The average density of development in the UK is far higher than in the US,a nd housing prices are higher accordingly.
Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by rsolomon on Saturday October 27, 2012 @05:29PM (#4707303)
Average SF single bedroom apartment is more than 2k per month. You'd be hard pressed to find a decent 2 bedroom house for less than a million.
Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by thereallurch on Saturday October 27, 2012 @11:52AM (#4706382)
I think you underestimated the cost of major cities in UK.
Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by robotresearcher on Saturday October 27, 2012 @01:43PM (#4706695)
Living in London was already not cheap before the US civil war. Part of the US advantage during the 20th century was that the cost of living and labour was less than most of the rest of the industrialized world.
Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by seanmcdirmid on Saturday October 27, 2012 @11:51AM (#4706379)
Don't you mean the other way around???? I mean, the UK aint a cheap place to live!
Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by michaelochurch on Saturday October 27, 2012 @04:13PM (#4707111)
Apparently living in the UK aint too cheap either. Did not know that!

The house-price plague is a worldwide problem and it's still in force. The "crash" was not as much of one as the world needed; brownstones in Manhattan are still over a million.

Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by michaelochurch on Saturday October 27, 2012 @04:06PM (#4707084)
The article quotes the average starting salary at google to be $125,000. After converting that into GBP (for the UK where I live) you get to 77,613.

Europeans quote salaries (usually monthly) after taxes, and Americans use pre-tax numbers. They also pay a higher tax rate (and get more, like real health coverage). So when you hear a European say that he makes 4000 Euros per month, that's an after-tax number and it's actually comparable to about $80,000 pre-tax salary in the US.

Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by bowyakka on Saturday October 27, 2012 @04:51PM (#4707197)
No that will be gross values, the statement about ~77K being on the high end for the UK is right.

Easy experiment I went to jobserve.com a well known UK programmer job site and did a search for the word "programmer"

its breakdown of offered gross salaries is this

  Not stated on job 39
  Below £15K  1
  £15K-£20K  28
  £20K-£25K  79
  £25K-£30K  173
  £30K-£40K  286
  £40K-£50K  247
  £50K-£75K  166
  £75K-£100K 27
  Above £100K  11
Suggests a bell curve to me with the median being £35000
Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by to3m on Saturday October 27, 2012 @04:31PM (#4707149)
UK salaries are always stated gross.

BTW while I am correcting people, I will also point out that the UK is very rarely described as "European", though nobody would (or can) deny that it's part of Europe, geographically speaking.

Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by grimlck on Saturday October 27, 2012 @04:34PM (#4707157)
That is not the case in the UK.
Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by jk4930 on Saturday October 27, 2012 @06:03PM (#4707380)
Not the case in Germany.
Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by threejay on Saturday October 27, 2012 @11:20AM (#4706300)
Well, the most successful people in any profession are "the people who solve problems". That isn't something inherently unique to programmers.
Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by seiji on Saturday October 27, 2012 @11:32AM (#4706324)
The special thing about "solving problems" is you usually create many more problems in the process. That's the definition of a startup: a company, when solving one problem, creates five new problems in the process due to imperfect foresight because everything hasn't been done before. Hence, hiring, growth, jobs, expansion, ....

Startups could be called "things that didn't exist before that are creating more problems to solve than existed before."

Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by kamaal on Saturday October 27, 2012 @11:25AM (#4706307)
They solve problems in their professions. But we programmers poke our nose in everything we see around.
Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by dbecker on Saturday October 27, 2012 @12:10PM (#4706428)
I just googled "highest paying college majors list," and computer science (and computer engineering) are consistently on the list. On the whole, I think programmers are paid well.

http://www.payscale.com/college-salary-report-2013/majors-th...

Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by Evbn on Saturday October 27, 2012 @02:36PM (#4706835)
When people say programmers are loan paid on average, they are including a large fraction of the population that do not have CS/engineering degrees from US colleges.
Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by icelancer on Saturday October 27, 2012 @03:59PM (#4707061)
All of my data science FTE jobs have paid at least that much ($115k+) in salary alone, and I have just 5 years of CS experience and I'm a college dropout. I do not live in California.

Developers/programmers are vastly overpaid. Including myself.

Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by michaelochurch on Saturday October 27, 2012 @04:09PM (#4707102)
You're not overpaid. Decent programmers, properly set up and put to work on useful projects, can easily add 4-10 times the average programmer salary in business value.

Look at house prices in the Bay Area or New York: $500,000 for starter houses, and $1 million is not uncommon. Read: someone is making a shit-ton of money, and it's not us.

Executives are overpaid. Our numbers are merely creeping up to our real value, and still 25 to 50 cents on the dollar. We're just less underpaid than most of the poor saps out there.

Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by icelancer on Saturday October 27, 2012 @08:57PM (#4707767)
It's not a mutually exclusive situation. Executives and developers are both overpaid. Now, one may be more overpaid than the other...
Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by jshen on Saturday October 27, 2012 @11:44AM (#4706361)
"C'mon lets be frank not all programmers are well paid, You really have to be working at Google or other big place or make it big in the start up area"

I don't think this is true. I live in Los Angeles and every place I've worked has paid something close to google/facebook dollars, and all the programmers I know have had a similar experience.

Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by mgkimsal on Saturday October 27, 2012 @02:24PM (#4706813)
LA is still in California, one of the world's biggest economies. Rural Tennessee, North Dakota or Alabama locations with 'on site' jobs might not pay close to Goog/FB money.
Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by jshen on Wednesday October 31, 2012 @01:27AM (#4721368)
Here is what the op said, "You really have to be working at Google or other big place or make it big in the start up area"

I refuted that, then you are now making a different point than the OP. My advice, don't live in those places. I say this as someone who was born and raised in Virginia.

Re:How Long Will Programmers Be So Well-Paid? by kux on Saturday October 27, 2012 @11:33AM (#4706329)
engineers solve problems too