News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by ericfrenkiel on Saturday October 27, 2012 @12:47AM (#4705386)
this is such a biased article with strawman arguments ("can you replace the sound card on the surface?") and silly comparisons(the author actually writes he could buy 2 ipad minis for 1 surface).

the criticisms about the store experience and salesmen notwithstanding, this is apple fanboism at its best.

It's far better to keep an open mind and experience new ways of interaction than to deride/scoff at alternative UI and UX.

I switch between Android, Windows, and Mac OSX; it's far more interesting to enjoy more platforms than forgo trying new experiences.

Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by picklefish on Saturday October 27, 2012 @02:13AM (#4705533)
I came here to post this. This article is so grossly biased by someone who made up their mind a long time ago. The writing is so poor and clearly attacks the silliest stuff that is unrelated to the product itself. This person is clearly jealous? of microsoft copying the apple store approach. It's such a weird article to make it to the top of hacker news. I guess that's a late Friday night for you.
Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by ghshephard on Saturday October 27, 2012 @03:07AM (#4705624)
Biased? It's written by Marco Arment, well known author of Instapaper and now "The Magazine" - recent speaker at Cingleton. Of course he's biased. It's like complaining that Anne Coultier is being conservative.

But, I disagree with you on the writing - he clearly put a lot of work into that essay, and it's less egregious than what I would expect from the other pundits.

Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by ghshephard on Saturday October 27, 2012 @01:02AM (#4705416)
The sound card comment was because the salesman was suggesting one advantage being a "PC Guy" was that he could upgrade his sound card. My response, btw, would have been identical to Marco's here.
Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by Jare on Saturday October 27, 2012 @01:52AM (#4705499)
Arguing quick examples and metaphors has never been useful to anyone except the arguer's ego. The salesdude actually tried to address Marco's underlying question (in what ways can you expand this thing?), even though it was clear Marco was there just for trolling. Surface love or hate nonwithstanding, this is an embarrassing post from start to finish.
Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by 27182818284 on Saturday October 27, 2012 @02:20AM (#4705548)
It was important for the overall motif he repeated throughout the piece that the salespeople seemed to be forcing the issue too much and weren't personally invested. (How could they be? The store has been open for less than a month.)
Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by lostlogin on Saturday October 27, 2012 @02:46AM (#4705597)
On the subject of trolling, isn't the very store he went into some kind of meta-troll. Built to be encountered before the Apple store is reached, copying layout and staffing concepts, trying to divert people from buying iPads, coyly calling the competition (iPad) a tablet, rather than name it. I think that there is a reasonable augment to be made that Microsoft is trolling Apple. The smart cover keyboard though, that's a definite win however I look at it.
Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by deong on Saturday October 27, 2012 @10:43AM (#4706212)
> coyly calling the competition (iPad) a tablet, rather than name it

Kind of like putting a picture of a Nexus 7 on the screen and calling it "a competitor's tablet"? This isn't trolling, it's the way advertising has worked throughout the history of people trying to get other people to buy stuff.

Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by corporalagumbo on Saturday October 27, 2012 @07:55AM (#4705974)
Please, they're not trolling anyone, they're just embarassing themselves. Even if they can sell a bundle of Surfaces it's not worth it.
Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by Jare on Saturday October 27, 2012 @02:36AM (#4705579)
Marco was asking a Microsoft store employee if he applied to Apple store first. In what world...? It's hard to compete with that level of personal investment.
Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by cooldeal on Saturday October 27, 2012 @02:52AM (#4705602)
I presume he did that so that if he got an affirmative answer he could've declared that Microsoft was hiring Apple Store rejects.
Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by joenathan on Saturday October 27, 2012 @02:27AM (#4705564)
Actually with all the USB support the Surface has, you probably can change the sound "card".

http://www.amazon.com/Syba-SD-CM-UAUD-Adapter-C-Media-Chipse...

Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by sageikosa on Saturday October 27, 2012 @06:18AM (#4705870)
Took me 15 seconds to find multiple USB sounds cards on the Interweb as well.
Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by lalwat on Saturday October 27, 2012 @01:07AM (#4705420)
agreed, Toronto's largest mall (Eaton C) featured the Surface today. It was packed. Everybody was exited and the product looked great.
Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by snambi on Saturday October 27, 2012 @01:52AM (#4705498)
yes, the farther and farther you travel from silicon valley, microsoft products look more and more appealing. :)
Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by WalterBright on Saturday October 27, 2012 @02:26AM (#4705561)
I was at Bellevue mall this evening, and the Microsoft store was packed solid with a long line outside. The nearby Apple store was empty.

Interestingly, all the laptops in the MS store had a touchscreen. The Apple laptops did not. I think MS has changed the game here, with my playing around with the MS store laptops I found the touchscreen interface to be a welcome addition (not a replacement, the touchpad mouse works the same as always).

Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by chipotle_coyote on Saturday October 27, 2012 @03:56AM (#4705691)
Um, Bellevue, as in Bellevue, Washington? Bellevue, as in just over three miles away from Microsoft HQ as the crow flies? A mall in Bellevue has people flocking to the Microsoft Store and eschewing the Apple Store? Huh!
Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by jmelloy on Saturday October 27, 2012 @03:50PM (#4707039)
The apple store in that mall does just fine. It recently moved into a spot with double the floor space.

I'm sure it's considered a flagship Microsoft store, but when I was computer shoppin last year the sales staff did not unde rstand the difference between "small form factor to watch tv and DVDs" and "tablet". Even when I said, "no, like a Mac mini".

Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by snambi on Monday October 29, 2012 @01:59AM (#4711267)
I have a laptop, desktop, tablet and phone. Honestly a mouse or track pad is easier to with a desktop or laptop. Especially for desktops which are having bigger and more screens, using the hand to reach the screen is tougher and tiring. btw, with touch you can have only one click. the mouse can have two or three clicks. Anyway, microsoft mouse is the best out there, it is simple, it works on all surfaces, imho it is better than the apple mouse. Why would microsoft want to kill the best product they ever invented, the microsoft mouse?
Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by randomchars on Saturday October 27, 2012 @10:40AM (#4706207)

    >all the laptops in the MS store had a touchscreen. The Apple laptops did not.
Because Apple doesn't want it's users to get gorilla arms.
Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by WalterBright on Saturday October 27, 2012 @06:24PM (#4707432)
Followup: I went back and bought the ASUS X202E laptop with the touchscreen. It's $499 at the Microsoft store, and $599 elsewhere. So far, it seems nice.
Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by jopt on Saturday October 27, 2012 @03:59AM (#4705693)
> strawman arguments

This is a blog post, not a research paper. That's not a strawman argument, it's a joke.

Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by andrewljohnson on Saturday October 27, 2012 @12:58AM (#4705408)
Have you tried a Microsoft Surface? I think he can scoff at the UI since he tried it.
Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by ericfrenkiel on Saturday October 27, 2012 @12:59AM (#4705411)
Yes, I'm typing on one right now =)

It certainly has some flaws as a first generation product, but on the whole it's a breath of fresh air in the tablet space.

Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by koeselitz on Saturday October 27, 2012 @02:03AM (#4705519)
If you don't mind saying - in what way do you find it a breath of fresh air? I ask because I am very much a Linux guy, not a Microsoft and definitely not an Apple guy - but my iPad has completely revolutionized the way I use computers. I guess the main draw is filesystem access, right?
Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by mirsadm on Saturday October 27, 2012 @02:18AM (#4705545)
I'm more interested in knowing how the iPad revolutionized the way you use computers. I find it more hassle to keep mine charged then find a use for it besides reading news sites on the toiler.
Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by koeselitz on Saturday October 27, 2012 @04:28PM (#4707144)
Well, I'm happy to respond, I guess.

A few years ago, I was given an iPad 1 by the company I work for as a x-mas bonus. It took me a little while, but over time I've found it taking up so very many functions in my life, and doing so with more ease than I thought possible.

To start with, I use a stylus (a Pogo Sketch Pro) constantly with my iPad. I journal daily - I now have about 300 pages of hand-written journaling done, two years worth, that I did in the Penultimate app. I also do a lot of reading on my iPad; I generally read PDFs inside Goodreader, which allows me to underline and take notes with my stylus; last month I read almost all of Kurt Vonnegut's novels, and now I'm working on Moby-Dick (an old favorite of mine.) Being able to take notes, save those notes, print out or email a single page - these things are very useful.

In fact, I use my iPad to fill in every form I find myself having to fill in. These days, lots of places (the DMV, insurance companies, etc) will send you a link to a PDF and ask you to fill it in - which, of course, seems utterly ridiculous in this era. But that's no problem for me; in fact, I prefer it, because I can fill it in pretty easily on my iPad (by hand with my stylus, or typing the data in if I want it to look pretty) and then print it out. That way, I can keep a copy of every form that I am forced to fill in. I do this with leases, with insurance cards, with applications for things, etc. It's a great way to keep track of those things when I find I need them later, too (since that seems to happen often.)

Just in general, it's allowed me to simplify my life immensely. Huge stacks of paper and file folders filled with old receipts and crumpled-up forms have been replaced by a tiny device with a few Goodreader folders. And of course, I'm the type of (ADD) person who is benefited immensely just by having a calendar app handy all the time.

Another thing - I am a jazz pianist. My iPad has become pretty much indispensable for my music. Most jazz musicians lug around three phone books' worth of music books called "Real books;" I have all three of the standard volumes in PDFs on my iPad, and several other more obscure ones too. I have hundreds of pages of other sheet music that's instantly accessible, no filing necessary. I can take notes on anything I like - my iPad saves all of it.

Also - lots of musicians like me find it really useful to practice along to a prerecorded background at home; once upon a time people used pre-recorded tapes, and in the past few years there's been a desktop program called "Band In A Box." Last I checked, a Band In A Box license costs $300; that's how it often is with these niche pieces of software. But there's a fantastic little $8 iPad app called "iReal B" that does everything Band In A Box does, and more - it gives you simple chord sheets for 1200 songs, and easily plays backgrounds for you if you need it. And in addition, I have apps that help me format sheet music for people and transpose it for other instruments when I want other musicians to be able to play along with me.

My iPad is also a really good tool for actually creating music itself. There's a pretty fantastic sequencing / synthesizer app called Nano Studio that I use to create some electronic music (like this: http://soundcloud.com/koeselitz/the-end-of-the-beginning) just for fun. There are apps like Filtatron with filters and effects I can run sounds through if I want. And the iPad is good enough to work nicely for my own recordings of me playing my piano; the Soundcloud app lets me record directly and upload immediately if I want, or there's an app called Fourtrack that just acts as a simple four-track recorder if I want several parts in the recording.

The essential thing for me is that the iPad is miniscule when compared to all the things it's replaced. And at this point, I can pretty much do anything I need to on my iPad. I can download files and then open them in any app I want to; and I have players that work with any format under the sun no matter how obscure. There were days when having an iPad seemed to be limiting in that it was somewhat difficult to move files around and manipulate them, but as far as I can tell those days are mostly gone. It would be nice to have direct filesystem acccess - but I almost never miss it now.

Sorry this is so long, but you asked I guess. Really, there are things I never would have even thought to do if I hadn't had this device.

Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by mirsadm on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @11:29PM (#4721021)
Thanks for the response. It has clearly made an impact on your life. I play guitar and have recently started learning to play a keyboard. I do find it very useful in that scenario.
Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by stcredzero on Saturday October 27, 2012 @02:58AM (#4705612)
I had this experience of "revolution" before the iPad came out, when I bought my second-hand tc1100 stylus tablet PC. Pretty much, the use cases for the iPad are the same as the old tc1100. The only differences are much better battery life on the iPad and no need for a stylus and to pay attention to which GUI item has focus.

Tablets do change how you use computing, simply because they are more mobile than the PC. Instead of a stationary tool, you now have a portable version.

Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by ollysb on Saturday October 27, 2012 @03:27AM (#4705648)
I had a similar experience switching to a macbook air. It really does make a difference when you can walk around holding your laptop easily in one hand. It's a 13incher so I don't hold it for prolonged periods but I do find I move it around a lot more during skype conversations and I use it for things like radio when I'm cooking in the kitchen.
Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by lostlogin on Saturday October 27, 2012 @02:50AM (#4705600)
I'm surprised you use the battery up fast. I find charging mine annoying too - mainly because I so rarely have to do it that I don't have a set pace to do it (damn, I have to unplug the phone, wonder there I put the other charger). I seems to last an age on one charge. Its used pretty much 100% for reading and browsing.
Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by mirsadm on Saturday October 27, 2012 @05:48AM (#4705833)
The battery life is very good. It is just the lack of use and I forget about it. There is nothing technically wrong with it but I seem to struggle in finding a use for it to be honest. I just prefer being at a desk on my PC with a big screen.
Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by berntb on Saturday October 27, 2012 @05:34AM (#4705815)
The retina display made me a bit disappointed, until I realised how easy it is to read, compared to most any screen (my Linux portable has 15" 1920x1080, but even that is blown away).

I can read literature on a screen now! I have documentation in A4/letter size readable! That combination can't be matched, since larger eInk screens seems to become retired?

Arguably, this changed not only how I use computers but my life for better...

Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by snambi on Saturday October 27, 2012 @01:51AM (#4705495)
did you buy it?
Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by ericfrenkiel on Saturday October 27, 2012 @02:40AM (#4705583)
I did, I'm a bit of a gadget geek
Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by snambi on Monday October 29, 2012 @01:55AM (#4711260)
how do you like it?
Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by randartie on Saturday October 27, 2012 @02:25AM (#4705557)
or did he receive it today as a Microsoft employee?
Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by ericfrenkiel on Saturday October 27, 2012 @02:41AM (#4705585)
No lol, i work at MemSQL
Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by sam1799 on Saturday October 27, 2012 @06:11AM (#4705863)
I have tried the Surface, and been using Windows 8 and Windows Phone for over a year. On the other hand Marco tried it for a couple of minutes, and arrived at a hasty conclusion without even giving it a fair try.

It is a completely different approach to iOS and Mac. And it is better. I can safely say Windows 8's Metro UI is miles ahead of Apple's iOS in terms of UI and UX. Metro UI is prettier, easier to use and by far more productive. Apple's iOS looks static, dull, ancient and boring compared to this.

Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by JuDue on Saturday October 27, 2012 @11:06AM (#4706271)
"I have tried the Surface, and been using Windows 8 and Windows Phone for over a year. On the other hand Marco tried it for a couple of minutes, and arrived at a hasty conclusion without even giving it a fair try."

Yes but he us upfront about that. He isn't pretending it is a well researched review. He is writing about his experience.

ALSO - the UX issues he found are quite apparent on casual inspection.

Re:An Alternate Universe (Microsoft Surface) by corporalagumbo on Saturday October 27, 2012 @08:21AM (#4705997)
Microsoft might have a lot of good ideas, but they're wasted if they can't execute them as well as Apple. No amount of apologising can force the buying public to favour Microsoft.