There is certainly no guarantee that with a "solid" team you'll get in. At the end of the day, it's all a matter of serendipity.
Typewire - disqus for liveblogging
Attend.me - conference management software
Prospector - medical chart review
and finally LightTable. Oddly enough we had/have domain expertise for all of them :D
I think it's way more than serendipity. I think the YC staff is extremely good at identifying where good teams and good products meet.
While I agree that they've gotten very good at identifying potential good team/product pairings, that just means they have relatively few false positives. It makes no claim to how many people they pass over who may in fact have an amazing team and product. As the noise in the process increases, you're bound to end up with more and more people who for completely random reasons didn't end up being what they wanted that day. This isn't a purely objective process (thank goodness).
All other things being equal, anything that relies on the judgement of a few people has an element of serendipity to it.
"All other things being equal, anything that relies on the judgement of a few people has an element of serendipity to it."
Also recall that the judgement is made on the basis of a 10minute interview. Ask any of these startups if they'd ever hire a group of strangers into their company based on a 10 minute interview. (I'm aware that's not really a fair comparison, but it should still make people think).
I started filling out our application 2 hours before the deadline, and I am a slow writer. It worked out for us, but I wouldn't recommend this approach. Correlation is not causation.
Best applications consistently keep the video under 1 minute. Given the culture of conciseness in YC I wouldn't recommend intentionally going longer.
Instead of building that application for a whole month, he should have been building his product and landing customers.
Interestingly enough also many alumnus I know thought they failed the interview once walking out of the room. I sure did.
Edit: With the second comment I was referring to section "Once we got the Interview, we knew we were in"
I think many of the posters who spent relatively little time on their second, third, fourth, etc. applications are underestimating how much time they spent preparing the application. Unless you could have written that application from scratch the first time, at least some of the time spent on your failed applications counts as "writing the application." I'm pretty sure the author didn't mean 1 month of 12 hour days sitting in front of a word processor (and I think has said as much).
Our application process helped hone and focus our business in ways that nothing else has. I would argue that working hard on your YC application is working hard on your company.
As you've pointed out twice (#2,#3), there are always exceptions to rules.
If a company does not make it past a YC interview, then there was something that YC didn't like... it can only help that company to try to extract that issue and deal with it early on.
This is exactly wrong. There are two types of questions on the YC application:
1) the ones about you as founders, and 2) the ones about your business
Spending time thinking about the first type of question (e.g. "Please tell us about the time you most successfully hacked some (non-computer) system to your advantage.") does not help you build your business -- not in the least.
And if you spend time building your business (i.e. talking to customers and building your product), then you'll be well prepared to answer the second kind of question.
You have it backwards. Working on your YC app != working on your business. Working hard on your business, however, is the best thing you can do make your YC application successful.
Spending time thinking about our business for us included talking to customers and asking hard questions. Only after understanding our customers could we build anything at all--for an enterprise product like ours, it's impossible to iterate in a vacuum.
Working on your company should always be the answer, but before we could ship code, we needed to know where we were going.
As PG points out, "The biggest mistake founders make when applying is to confuse us. Half the time when I'm reading an application I'm thinking 'I have no idea what this person is even talking about.' I suspect this often the writer's own confusion showing through."¹
Trying to explain our very-difficult model helped us to both understand it and define for ourselves.
Admittedly, it was a bit weird to just start making money without knowing where the future of the company was going. The YC app itself forced us to talk through these things; but maybe this problem is unique to our company.
nice product, so!
EDIT: And site, just because I forgot...
One of the most valuable pieces of advice YC offers is that there are lots of things that are a waste of time, but feel like they're productive, and that these things are especially dangerous to spend time on.
I live in Silicon Valley so everyone here is either going YC crazy right now, or absolutely clueless. It would be awesome to get feedback from someone objective but experienced.
I apologize if this wasn't the right place to ask, but with 4 YC alums in the same thread I had to give it a shot!
Thank you in advance.
1) "If you’re writing your Y Comb application and it takes you less than a month of work, you’re not trying hard enough."
No. You should not be spending that much effort on your application to YC -- or any accelerator. Should you have a few people read it over? Yes. Should you spellcheck? Yes. But not much more than that. Focus on building your product and building your business.
2) "no one’s video is under a minute."
Ours was. 50 seconds, to be exact.
3) "But my point is, if your company and team is solid, than you will get in."
This is the most dangerous statement in the post. This is simply not the case. Every successful entrepreneur was told "no" and turned down time and time again on their path to greatness. Facebook got "no's" from VCs. Airbnb's founders were told they were crazy. Many people outright laughed at Elon Musk's dream to build rocket ships. SendGrid was rejected from YC. If you believe in your team, and you believe in your idea, trek on. The YC partners are some of the smartest people I've ever met, but they're not infallible.
YC has been absolutely amazing for my team and my company, and we're very grateful for having gone through the program. But we likely wouldn't have been accepted and wouldn't have benefitted so much from the program if we weren't focused intensely on what matters -- building our product, talking to our customers, and staying healthy. Apply, hope you get in, but if you don't, carry on.