News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The risk of a hothouse Earth trajectory by timschmidt on Wednesday February 11, 2026 @03:56PM (#46980807)
> it’s not like companies are making a bunch of product just to throw them in the trash

Sure they do. You even mention one in the venerable plastic bag. Is it the best bag? No, of course not. Is it a good bag? Absolutely not. Is it the cheapest bag to produce? You betcha.

Consumers are often presented the least expensive option with the worst outcomes. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boots_theory

Re:The risk of a hothouse Earth trajectory by rtpg on Wednesday February 11, 2026 @04:15PM (#46981093)
The plastic bag is sold to businesses! If every supermarket in the world decided to never buy another plastic bag then they would no longer be produced!

There can be a futility to it all in that the “ideal option” simply isn’t produced of course.

I find boots theory is often a bit too convenient in this topic though. There is unlikely to be magic structural solutions that allow every part of your life to remain as convenient. At one point our lives will have to change in structure.

Re:The risk of a hothouse Earth trajectory by usrnm on Wednesday February 11, 2026 @04:16PM (#46981099)
> Is it the best bag? No, of course not. Is it a good bag? Absolutely not

Plastic is absolutely the best packaging material ever created, it's so good, it feels like magic. It's light, it's cheap, it's waterproof, it's durable and doesn't just decompose, it comes in a miriad shapes and forms and so on. There is a reason it's everywhere

Re:The risk of a hothouse Earth trajectory by timschmidt on Wednesday February 11, 2026 @04:19PM (#46981178)
> it's cheap, it's waterproof, it's durable

One of those adjectives describes the plastic bag I'm familiar with. Sometimes it lasts long enough to get the food in the house without spilling through a hole which spontaneously appeared in the bag.

Re:The risk of a hothouse Earth trajectory by throw310822 on Wednesday February 11, 2026 @04:14PM (#46981073)
Why don't you pay for a more expensive bag and bring it to the store?
Re:The risk of a hothouse Earth trajectory by timschmidt on Wednesday February 11, 2026 @04:22PM (#46981223)
Why do you assume I don't? Opinionated defaults matter, as that's what most users will end up using.
Re:The risk of a hothouse Earth trajectory by throw310822 on Wednesday February 11, 2026 @04:36PM (#46981420)
Would you be ok if stores offered the option between a cheap plastic bag and a more expensive non-plastic one? (All the stores here already do it, btw).
Re:The risk of a hothouse Earth trajectory by timschmidt on Wednesday February 11, 2026 @04:56PM (#46981708)
I think the externalities of plastic recycling must be internalized economically by requiring all manufacturers of items to pre-pay for the recycling of said items up front, as part of the manufacturing cost. Similar to how bottle returns are managed, which has been very successful. Items which are provably biodegradable or designed to facilitate repair may be exempt.
Re:The risk of a hothouse Earth trajectory by throw310822 on Wednesday February 11, 2026 @04:59PM (#46981747)
Plastic bags are already taxed where I live. Consumers pay that tax, obviously. Other costs imposed on producers of plastic items will just be passed down to consumers.
Re:The risk of a hothouse Earth trajectory by timschmidt on Wednesday February 11, 2026 @04:59PM (#46981757)
That's lovely, but it's not what I described. Bottles aren't just taxed. They have a refundable deposit. This ensures they don't end up in a landfill.
Re:The risk of a hothouse Earth trajectory by matthewdgreen on Wednesday February 11, 2026 @05:31PM (#46982170)
Exactly. The point of this sort of tax should not be to collect revenue, it should be to ensure that non-biodegradable bags are being disposed of correctly. To the extent that this is not happening, any bag tax is malfunctioning. Such a tax is either insufficient or poorly-designed. (Our city just banned chain stores from giving out plastic bags under 4 mils thick, and stores now give out paper and sell re-usable bags.)
Re:The risk of a hothouse Earth trajectory by myrmidon on Thursday February 12, 2026 @09:11AM (#46989055)
Hard disagree on this.

Even if that state is just straight up burning all the tax income from single-use plastic bags, by taxing them you incentivize consumers and distributors towards untaxed, ideally more sustainable alternatives, like single use paper bags or robust multi-use bags.

> Our city just banned chain stores from giving out plastic bags under 4 mils thick, and stores now give out paper and sell re-usable bags

I don't see how this is not a massive win? Paper bags are significantly more sustainable, and multi-use bags are more durable and thrown aways less simply from being more expensive alone.

People are much more wasteful with things they didn't pay for, regardless of "inherent" value.

Re:The risk of a hothouse Earth trajectory by matthewdgreen on Thursday February 12, 2026 @11:03AM (#46990479)
We’re not disagreeing. I’m saying that the tax should be set high enough that it creates the desired behavior, which is to disincentivize the widespread use of polluting plastic bags AND/OR ensure that they’re recycled and don’t wind up in the environment. If you’re charging $.05 per bag and people are just eating the tax and the bags are winding up in wetlands in similar amounts, that means your tax regime isn’t effective. You should either increase the tax or improve the system. My city’s absolute ban is equivalent to setting the tax to infinity, which is one solution that seems to work well.
Re:The risk of a hothouse Earth trajectory by M95D on Thursday February 12, 2026 @05:54AM (#46987197)
That ain't working. A plastic bag discarded in a ditch by the side of the road, or blown by the wind from the landfill, is still going to end up into the ocean. No amount of prepay recycling is going to take back that plastic from the ocean.
Re:The risk of a hothouse Earth trajectory by timschmidt on Thursday February 12, 2026 @09:33AM (#46989333)
Re:The risk of a hothouse Earth trajectory by matthewdgreen on Wednesday February 11, 2026 @05:27PM (#46982125)
Many cities have banned plastic bags, and the results have been miraculous for waterways and wetlands. It turns out that shore animals don't benefit as much from "hope a few customers choose the better thing, but otherwise let them take home single-use crap that immediately blows off into natural settings."

https://www.nytimes.com/2025/06/19/climate/plastic-bag-bans-...

Re:The risk of a hothouse Earth trajectory by filoeleven on Wednesday February 11, 2026 @04:01PM (#46980890)
I remember when that switch at grocers from paper to plastic was taking hold, and you could choose. "Paper or plastic?" was the question asked. Some comedian (probably) had a good one liner: "That'll be 42.39. Kill a tree or choke a fish?"
Re:The risk of a hothouse Earth trajectory by XorNot on Wednesday February 11, 2026 @05:02PM (#46981800)
It's mostly a good example of why comedians aren't a source of information.

Plantation lumber is a very sustainable industry, and plastic's environmental impact is highly context dependent.