News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Frontier AI agents violate ethical constraints 30–50% of ... by jayd16 on Tuesday February 10, 2026 @01:31AM (#46956090)
It's pretty wild. People are punching into a calculator and hand-wringing about the morals of the output.

Obviously it's amoral. Why are we even considering it could be ethical?

Re:Frontier AI agents violate ethical constraints 30–50% of ... by coldtea on Tuesday February 10, 2026 @03:43AM (#46956928)
Obviously, why? Because it makes calculations?

You think that ultimately your brain doesn't also make calculations as its fundamental mechanism?

The architecture and substrate might be different, but they are calculations all the same.

Re:Frontier AI agents violate ethical constraints 30–50% of ... by mrguyorama on Tuesday February 10, 2026 @12:16PM (#46963207)
Brains do not "make calculations". Biological neurons do not "make calculations"

What they do is well described by a bunch of math. You've got the direction of the arrow backwards. Map, territory, etc.

Re:Frontier AI agents violate ethical constraints 30–50% of ... by pixl97 on Tuesday February 10, 2026 @12:38PM (#46963661)
So what does a chemical based computer do?
Re:Frontier AI agents violate ethical constraints 30–50% of ... by coldtea on Tuesday February 10, 2026 @06:18PM (#46968446)
If what they do is "well described by a bunch of math", they're making calculations.

Unless the substrate is essential and irreducible to get the output (whic is not if what they do is "well described by a bunch of math"), then the material or process (neurons or water pipes or billiard balls or 0s and 1s in a cpu) doesn't matter.

>You've got the direction of the arrow backwards. Map, territory, etc.

The whole point is that at the level we're interested in regarding "what is the process that creates thought/consciousness", the territory is not important: the mechanism is, not the material of the mechanism.

Re:Frontier AI agents violate ethical constraints 30–50% of ... by optimalsolver on Tuesday February 10, 2026 @09:06PM (#46969877)
The coming years are gonna be rough for the human exceptionalism crowd.
Re:Frontier AI agents violate ethical constraints 30–50% of ... by p-e-w on Tuesday February 10, 2026 @02:11AM (#46956331)
> Obviously it's amoral.

That morality requires consciousness is a popular belief today, but not universal. Read Konrad Lorenz (Das sogenannte Böse) for an alternative perspective.

Re:Frontier AI agents violate ethical constraints 30–50% of ... by coldtea on Tuesday February 10, 2026 @03:45AM (#46956943)
That we have consciousness as some kind of special property, and it's not just an artifact of our brain basic lower-level calculations, is also not very convincing to begin with.
Re:Frontier AI agents violate ethical constraints 30–50% of ... by paltor on Tuesday February 10, 2026 @08:38AM (#46959569)
In a trivial sense, any special property can be incorporated into a more comprehensive rule set, which one may choose to call "physics" is one so desires; but that's just Hempel's dilemma.

To object more directly, I would say that people who call the hard problem of consciousness hard would disagree with your statement.

Re:Frontier AI agents violate ethical constraints 30–50% of ... by coldtea on Tuesday February 10, 2026 @10:18AM (#46960852)
People who call "the hard problem of consciousness hard" use circular logic (notice the two "hards" in the phrase).

People who merely call "the problem of consciousness hard" don't have some special mechanism to justify that over what we know, which is as emergent property of meat-algorithmic calcuations.

Except Penrose, who hand-waves some special physics.

Re:Frontier AI agents violate ethical constraints 30–50% of ... by pixl97 on Tuesday February 10, 2026 @09:15AM (#46959979)
Luckily there are a fair number of people that reject the hard problem as an artifact of running a simulation on a chemical meat computer.
Re:Frontier AI agents violate ethical constraints 30–50% of ... by jayd16 on Tuesday February 10, 2026 @09:50AM (#46960404)
You'd be hard pressed to convince me, for example, a police dog has morals. The bar is much higher than consciousness.
Re:Frontier AI agents violate ethical constraints 30–50% of ... by Quarrelsome on Tuesday February 10, 2026 @07:09AM (#46958638)
Have you tried "kill all the poor?" [0]

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s_4J4uor3JE