News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Where did all the starships go? by bot403 on Saturday February 07, 2026 @01:08PM (#46926045)
Not sure your point. It's fiction. Are we closer to finding dragons, faeries, or magic?

Visiting remote planets is as unlikely as riding a dragon. But both make for great stories.

Re:Where did all the starships go? by squeaky-clean on Saturday February 07, 2026 @02:54PM (#46927133)
Science Fiction doesn't have to be fantasy, it can be speculative. But if your setting or plot relies on something we know to be scientifically untrue, and you don't put some effort into explaining why it somehow works in your setting, it's fantasy and not speculative.

Someone like Asimov never considered his books to be fantasy and that he could just insert whatever he wanted with no justification. In fact, he never considered sci-fi to be a genre, he always argued it was a setting and that his most famous stories were detective stories in a sci-fi setting. But detective stories don't work if your world isn't grounded in something real. Otherwise the reader can't reasonably build their own theory or deduce the answer because it's based on what the author thought was cool and not what logically connects.

The appeal of something like The Expanse just falls apart if you introduce a FTL engine just because it makes for a more dramatic story moment somewhere in the plot unless there is some serious justification as to why the author didn't just break all the rules of their world (which is supposed to be our world, but in the future).

Re:Where did all the starships go? by Recurecur on Saturday February 07, 2026 @03:19PM (#46927497)
FTL starships in an SF story don’t need a detailed explanation, just a new invention.

It’s the exact same thing as a speculative story in the 1920s discussing supersonic flight, even though the jet engine hadn’t been invented yet.

For instance “Tunnel in the Sky” bypassed the whole issue in the 50’s, later imitated by “Stargate”…

Re:Where did all the starships go? by wolvoleo on Saturday February 07, 2026 @05:23PM (#46928796)
True but at that point objects travelling faster than sound had been demonstrated.

It was just hard to engineer a manned plane that could do it. For example during WWII the V2 rockets travelled much faster than sound. They were just unmanned. Or more simple, bullets were supersonic for longer too.

What I mean is, nobody thought the sound barrier was a hard limit we could never break.

Re:Where did all the starships go? by direwolf20 on Saturday February 07, 2026 @08:51PM (#46930550)
Just specify an Alcubierre drive. Job done.
Re:Where did all the starships go? by hdgvhicv on Sunday February 08, 2026 @07:39AM (#46933735)
Massive implications from that

A magic unobtainium drive which works in a consistent way is fine, just call it “hyperspace” or whatever

There’s a difference between hard sci-fi and soft sci-fi, but they are both still sci-fi, you can tell optimistic stories of the future with a “battle drive”, as long as you keep it consistent. If the drive cancels relativity effects and allows travel at 5000c that’s fine. Just ensure you travel at 5000c, no hoping across the galaxy in a few days, but travelling to another star in a few days or even hours is fine.

Re:Where did all the starships go? by Dylan16807 on Saturday February 07, 2026 @07:59PM (#46930191)
> But if your setting or plot relies on something we know to be scientifically untrue, and you don't put some effort into explaining why it somehow works in your setting, it's fantasy and not speculative.

Agreed but only because "some effort" could be as little as a single paragraph.

> But detective stories don't work if your world isn't grounded in something real. Otherwise the reader can't reasonably build their own theory or deduce the answer because it's based on what the author thought was cool and not what logically connects.

If you only change a tiny bit, this isn't a major issue.

> The appeal of something like The Expanse just falls apart if you introduce a FTL engine just because it makes for a more dramatic story moment somewhere in the plot unless there is some serious justification as to why the author didn't just break all the rules of their world (which is supposed to be our world, but in the future).

That specific story falls apart but you could have lots of thematically similar stories with FTL. No need for "serious justification" unless you're trying to pull it out of nowhere halfway through the plot. If it's there from the start, there's no problem.

Re:Where did all the starships go? by Frotag on Saturday February 07, 2026 @08:34PM (#46930440)
> No need for "serious justification" unless you're trying to pull it out of nowhere halfway through the plot. If it's there from the start, there's no problem.

Yeah I think most readers care more about consistency than realism. Being completely realistic makes consistency easy but a harder sell in terms of entertainment.

Maybe one way to view consistency is modelling the story world as a network of criss-crossing character threads. Where one axis is time and the other(s) are uh something? Anyways, consistency is how predictable (smooth / linear) the thread is. We follow the main character's thread pretty closely so that thread is allowed to suddenly curve (plot twist) without risk of losing the reader. We only catch glimpses of the supporting cast / antagonist so those have to be either predictable or the narrator has to backtrack and reveal any twists where necessary. And maybe how intricate yet well-behaved this network appears is what gives the feeling of stories coming alive. Or maybe I'm just on too much caffeine and ranting.

Re:Where did all the starships go? by hdgvhicv on Sunday February 08, 2026 @07:42AM (#46933753)
Start trek transporters work because of a Heisenberg compensator. Great, no idea how it could possible work but it’s enough to know it does.

The typical poorly received uses aren’t when the cre beams down from orbit, or even when they can’t beam down, it’s when they de age people and retrieve their pattern from the buffer to cure an illness, and never do it again, or when they beam light years away for a throw away story element.

Re:Where did all the starships go? by lukan on Sunday February 08, 2026 @03:12AM (#46932369)
"But detective stories don't work if your world isn't grounded in something real."

No, it just has to be grounded in something consistent and if the book starts by explaining the mechanics of the world(or is in a world with known mechanics), a detective story very well can work.

Re:Where did all the starships go? by rdtsc on Sunday February 08, 2026 @10:16AM (#46934951)
It can’t be too different from what people are familiar with. So it has to be consistent with itself and with reality.”It’s like our reality except …” but the except part (faster than light travel, mind reading, time travel, dragons, magic, etc) can’t get arbitrarily complex or unreasonable or the reader will be lost or confused.
Re:Where did all the starships go? by lukan on Sunday February 08, 2026 @03:08PM (#46938016)
"can’t get arbitrarily complex or unreasonable or the reader will be lost or confused."

Indeed, but that is always the challenge of a writer. But if you introduce magic in your story, and you do it in a way to show the limitations and what is roughly possible, then you can give hints later, if there was a murder with the help of a magic trick. But I actually think I only ever read one detective fantasy story

https://www.der-spurenfinder.de/

(just in german as far as I know)

It mostly works, but in one instance there was a surprise fantasy ability, that I could have not guessed before. But the actual murderer in the end, there were enough hints that gave them away despite magic, as the skills were explained and then you could combine.

Re:Where did all the starships go? by dboreham on Saturday February 07, 2026 @02:39PM (#46926932)
Presumably these are equally likely because you could build a DNA-printer and thereby create a dragon of some sort (not sure if it could have fully functional fire breathing though)?
Re:Where did all the starships go? by WJW on Saturday February 07, 2026 @03:09PM (#46927369)
Dragons are physically impossible in many more ways than the firebreathing. For one, things that large would probably struggle to fly. We can make larger things fly, but have to cheat using jet (or rocket!) engines to generate incredible thrust in ways not typically accessible to living beings.
Re:Where did all the starships go? by boothby on Saturday February 07, 2026 @03:27PM (#46927586)
And now I'm picturing a dragon with bombardier-beetle style pulsed jet boosters. And while I'd typically question your assumptions of how big dragons need to be in order to deserve the name, I'll assert that quetzocoatlus nothropi[1] was big enough.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quetzalcoatlus

Re:Where did all the starships go? by krapp on Saturday February 07, 2026 @04:45PM (#46928434)
"Dragon" as a classification is odd, because when you look at every kind of mythological creature that gets classified as such nowadays, sometimes from cultures that wouldn't have recognized the concept, you find that they have little in common beyond some vaguely reptilian vibe and being scary.

And I'm sorry but that thing is too goofy looking to be considered a dragon.

Re:Where did all the starships go? by coldtea on Saturday February 07, 2026 @07:50PM (#46930104)
That's begging the question. We don't need to look "at every kind of mythological creature that gets classified as such nowadays" from "cultures that wouldn't have recognized the concept".

One could stick on those classified as such in western culture - which is where the fantasy novel about dragons and knights and spells and the rest are based on.

And in there, dragons have quite specific characteristic and vibes, as evidenced from medieval iconography of St George to countless fantasy book covers and illustrations.

Re:Where did all the starships go? by fc417fc802 on Sunday February 08, 2026 @05:58AM (#46933211)
But if we do expand the set under consideration then I'd suggest they do in fact have specific things in common. Large flying carnivorous reptiles. That won't cover all the various edge cases but I think it describes the vast majority of the popular usage of the term.

That definition would imply that sufficiently large flying dinosaurs qualify as dragons. And at least personally I think I agree with that conclusion. Dragons aren't purely fantasy, they're merely extinct (and never breathed fire IRL).

Re:Where did all the starships go? by PaulHoule on Saturday February 07, 2026 @07:29PM (#46929941)
Dragons are dinosaurs, that is, closer to birds then contemporary reptiles.
Re:Where did all the starships go? by Dylan16807 on Saturday February 07, 2026 @08:01PM (#46930211)
You can make a setting with denser air and less gravity too.
Re:Where did all the starships go? by andrewflnr on Saturday February 07, 2026 @08:15PM (#46930326)
That's ok, we just need to put them on the moon or somewhere else with lighter gravity.
Re:Where did all the starships go? by onraglanroad on Sunday February 08, 2026 @08:10AM (#46933891)
Less gravity has its own issues. Nothing can fly on the moon :)
Re:Where did all the starships go? by andrewflnr on Monday February 09, 2026 @01:58AM (#46942365)
Obviously you put them under a big dome. That's the easy part.
Re:Where did all the starships go? by jacquesm on Saturday February 07, 2026 @04:58PM (#46928549)
These two examples are not equally unlikely. They are of different orders of unlikelihood, the one is extremely unlikely, the other simply impossible.
Re:Where did all the starships go? by vanviegen on Sunday February 08, 2026 @02:26AM (#46932116)
Genetically engineering and then riding a dragon actually sounds easy in comparison to creating FTL travel.
Re:Where did all the starships go? by jacquesm on Sunday February 08, 2026 @02:48AM (#46932237)
It's not FTL that will get you to the stars. It's patience, eco systems, hibernation and radiation shielding.
Re:Where did all the starships go? by lukan on Sunday February 08, 2026 @03:15AM (#46932386)
Or building a very big spaceship and have generations live on it until they reach the end of the journey.
Re:Where did all the starships go? by jacquesm on Sunday February 08, 2026 @03:36AM (#46932506)
Hence eco-systems, yes. But that's probably a harder problem than radiation shielding + hybernation. You'd still need the radiation shielding but it would be far, far more of it (because non-local).

These are interesting problems to think about, right now they are solidly SF but dragons are and always will be fantasy because physics says they can't exist in the way they are described. But you can't 100% rule out that one day descendants of humanity will visit the stars in person, assuming we don't blow ourselves up first.

That's one of the main reasons I dislike Musk so much: he takes people motivated by positive dreams (a clean planet, off-world travel and living) and then subverts their energy for grift. But 'DOGE' has shown the world who he really is, the mask is off now and anybody still empowering that asshole is co-responsible.

Re:Where did all the starships go? by imtringued on Sunday February 08, 2026 @05:39AM (#46933121)
Dragons are fantasy but drakes are real. The thorny devil looks super cool.
Re:Where did all the starships go? by fc417fc802 on Sunday February 08, 2026 @05:43AM (#46933139)
Slap some wings on that and you have a legitimate dragon. I don't know about riding it though.
Re:Where did all the starships go? by jacquesm on Sunday February 08, 2026 @05:41AM (#46933129)
There's one creature that knows how to dress sharply.
Re:Where did all the starships go? by fc417fc802 on Sunday February 08, 2026 @05:42AM (#46933134)
> physics says they can't exist in the way they are described

If we assume advanced genetic as well as bio engineering that admits the possibility of self reproducing cybernetic organisms that closely match many or all of the key characteristics. I'm not sure it's actually a cyborg if the lineage is fully independent without involving any technology external to the species but I use the term there because that's the easiest way to communicate the idea.

Re:Where did all the starships go? by jacquesm on Sunday February 08, 2026 @07:10AM (#46933592)
No, then it still wouldn't work. Not until you use that other thing to get you to a planet where gravity is low enough that a dragon would be able to take off. The whole power-to-weight and wing-surface-area-to-weight ratio simply does not work. It (barely) works for bats though some of them can be of impressive size. The idea that something the size of a dragon can fly with that size wings on Terra is something that I do not believe is supported (hah!) by physics.
Re:Where did all the starships go? by fc417fc802 on Sunday February 08, 2026 @08:05AM (#46933867)
I think you're making an awful lot of assumptions there and have failed to provide even ballpark specifications for the thing you're supposedly refuting. Weight seems to be a secondary characteristic related only to size. There are also plenty of examples of "small" dragons in fantasy literature.

We've already got examples of dinosaurs that come fairly close to qualifying so I'm sure something vaguely in the ballpark is within the realm of possibility. Exactly how close to the mark though I have no idea.

For example, what would you make of something visually resembling a massive western dragon but with a largely hollow body? I don't think that would disqualify it in most people's eyes. Pushing the concept a bit farther could yield something vaguely like a living cross between a hot air balloon and a deep-sea anglerfish with a weaponized tail.

Vaguely related to that hypothetical, we've got examples in the fossil record of 2 foot wide dragonflies estimated to have weighed in at under 150 grams. There's a pretty large solution space to explore here.

Re:Where did all the starships go? by jacquesm on Sunday February 08, 2026 @09:28AM (#46934476)
Sorry, not going there. The physics of the impossible are not for me to take apart but for you to show. I've postulated ways in which you could get to other solar systems, I don't see anything here that would lead to a dragon as it is commonly described in fiction. Fire spewing, heavier than air, intelligent and willing to let themselves be mounted and directed by humans, that's the bar.

Archaeopteryx would have you for lunch long before you realized that it doesn't spit fire.

Re:Where did all the starships go? by fc417fc802 on Sunday February 08, 2026 @11:20AM (#46935676)
Well you've decided that it's impossible but you certainly haven't convinced me of that fact (neither am I certain that it is possible though).

I'm not even clear what the criteria are. We've got examples in fiction that run the gamut. Even limited to fairly traditional post-Tolkien western high fantasy examples of creatures with a long neck, two wings, a distinct abdomen, and a tail we've still got concrete examples ranging in size from a small lap dog up to larger than a McMansion. Plenty of reasonably canonical examples don't spit fire (although being able to certainly furthers the general vibe). And weight? As I said earlier, that's (imo) solidly in the domain of secondary characteristics.

Semantic arguments aren't any fun (and are largely pointless). Is Pluto a planet or not? Unless it's a technical discussion where the distinction matters for some reason, who cares? What matters is if Pluto fits the pattern that you (ie the people conversing) care about.

Hence my posing the example of a particularly buoyant variety of dragon. I think most people would consider it to fit the pattern well enough but I'm sure there would be at least some disagreement.

Also as long as we're talking about wild far future sci-fi possibilities such as visiting other stars in person then you can't rule out dragons in the form of a wildly advanced, needlessly decadent military technology show piece. Something like a nuclear powered bio engineered cyborg for use as some sort of fighter jet. (Apologies if I just inadvertently ripped off some anime I've never heard of.)

Re:Where did all the starships go? by jacquesm on Sunday February 08, 2026 @11:48AM (#46936008)
Yes, if you change everything that would make a dragon a dragon then you can have a dragon.
Re:Where did all the starships go? by stevedonovan on Sunday February 08, 2026 @02:33AM (#46932160)
Except for the power-to-weight problem. Would need very big wings!
Re:Where did all the starships go? by coldtea on Saturday February 07, 2026 @07:46PM (#46930073)
30s to 60s, sci-fi wasn't just driven by the "makes for great stories", but by the optimism for scientific advacements and the idea that these could get within reach in the future.

It was "science fiction" and not merely "space fiction".

Re:Where did all the starships go? by danans on Saturday February 07, 2026 @10:31PM (#46931068)
> Not sure your point. It's fiction. Are we closer to finding dragons, faeries, or magic?

No, but we've become increasingly superstitious, and cultish. A lot of the day to day parts of sci-fi (screens everywhere , instant communication) have become reality so it's not as exciting anymore. Sci-fi no longer serves as escapism. Anymore, it reminds us of our limitations.

Re:Where did all the starships go? by satvikpendem on Sunday February 08, 2026 @03:19AM (#46932410)
> Visiting remote planets is as unlikely as riding a dragon

No, because one is theoretically impossible while the other is theoretically possible.

Re:Where did all the starships go? by bluescrn on Sunday February 08, 2026 @05:50AM (#46933175)
Creating some sort of genetically-engineered dinosaur-derived ‘dragon’ may be more plausible than actually reaching another star system. It’s not going to breathe fire though.
Re:Where did all the starships go? by hdgvhicv on Sunday February 08, 2026 @07:43AM (#46933762)
Stomach full of natural gas or oil of some sort. Surely nature has examples of creatures that can produce a spark?