News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Project Cybersyn, a 1971-73 Chilean Experiment in Compute... by JVIDEL on Monday October 22, 2012 @12:15PM (#4683826)
The biggest problem every communist country had was indeed coordination. The USSR was famous for this, in fact the Nazi invasion was a success at first partly because of Soviet disarray: you had spies warning about the impending attack for months while factories churned tanks but not supply trucks, and the army trained soldiers but didn't make enough rifles for all of them.

And this happened on a day-to-day basis: you had factories making 10,000 units when only 1,000 were needed, or worse when the demand was of 100,000. Food supply was always a problem and still is in countries like Cuba and NK. I have friends a bit older than me that lived under such conditions and still remember having to wake up at 4AM to grab a nice spot at the store line. "Show up late and there was no food left" they said.

This Chilean system was without a doubt the right solution for the problem, too bad that it was destroyed before it could do what it was meant to do.

Re:Project Cybersyn, a 1971-73 Chilean Experiment in Compute... by demian on Monday October 22, 2012 @02:15PM (#4684502)
But Chile was not a communist country.

The dream of a "mechanical centralized control" was shared by a lot of people in the XX century. It's strongly featured in positivistic SciFi literature of the time, for example I, Robot from Asimov.

Re:Project Cybersyn, a 1971-73 Chilean Experiment in Compute... by Kadin on Monday October 22, 2012 @06:15PM (#4685831)
While Allende's formal affiliation was with the Socialist party, he was also endorsed by the Communist party at the time of his election. (WP says it was as an alternate, their primary choice being Pablo Neruda, but he then turned around and supported Allende.) And Allende's government was apparently perceived by some as being to the left of the Socialist party after the election.

Exactly where the government was on the spectrum is open to debate, but I don't think you can say that they "weren't Communist" as though that's a boolean flag that's either true or false.

But I think arguing over where exactly they were politically misses the point; you can have varying political philosophies alongside different economic ones. I'd argue that the two are basically orthogonal. Regardless of where the Allende government falls on the political-philosophy spectrum, they certainly had a fascination with national industries, economies of scale, and central planning.

Re:Project Cybersyn, a 1971-73 Chilean Experiment in Compute... by demian on Monday October 22, 2012 @10:00PM (#4686431)
> Exactly where the government was on the spectrum is open to debate, but I don't think you can say that they "weren't Communist" as though that's a boolean flag that's either true or false.

Of course I can't.

My comment was a reply. My point was that Chile was not a "communist country" as in "USSR's brand of Communism".

Re:Project Cybersyn, a 1971-73 Chilean Experiment in Compute... by wmf on Monday October 22, 2012 @01:44PM (#4684298)
Some people have looked into this and concluded that even modern computers and algorithms are not sufficient for central planning at a national scale. http://crookedtimber.org/2012/05/30/in-soviet-union-optimiza... (Edit: I see this has already been linked below.)
Re:Project Cybersyn, a 1971-73 Chilean Experiment in Compute... by ataggart on Monday October 22, 2012 @04:11PM (#4685259)
>This Chilean system was without a doubt the right solution for the problem

This presumes one can input all the relevant data, the preferences of millions of individuals as expressed by billions of choices every day. It also presumes the people sitting in those funny chairs won't be inclined to "adjust" things.

Re:Project Cybersyn, a 1971-73 Chilean Experiment in Compute... by jorgeleo on Monday October 22, 2012 @12:52PM (#4684068)
I don't understand how communism is related to the article. Allende was socialist, not communist. They are different political systems.
Re:Project Cybersyn, a 1971-73 Chilean Experiment in Compute... by Retric on Monday October 22, 2012 @01:20PM (#4684218)
One of the S's in USSR the 'classic' communist country stood for socialist. Granted the Communist party in the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics is probably what really confused most people.
Re:Project Cybersyn, a 1971-73 Chilean Experiment in Compute... by jorgeleo on Monday October 22, 2012 @02:38PM (#4684673)
Then I guess 7 = 11 because the store 711 puts the together...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communist http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socialism

They can put whatever they want in their name, and even mix and match the terms in their propaganda... reality remains that they are different political doctrines.

Re:Project Cybersyn, a 1971-73 Chilean Experiment in Compute... by demian on Monday October 22, 2012 @02:09PM (#4684461)
What they "said" they were was not what they became (by current definitions).

There are a lot of European countries ruled by socialist parties, and they are not communist by any stretch of the imagination.