Re:Are You Caught Up in Apple’s Reality Distortion Field?
by yen223 on Monday October 22, 2012 @04:59AM
(#4682324)
I'm not quite sure what to take away from this infographic.
1. Are they assuming that everyone who bought an Apple device is caught in the reality distortion field?
2. Is it really significant that people who used to own Apple devices, but now don't, are more likely to be dissatisfied with Apple products? I mean, that's the reason they are former Apple customers no?
3. For that matter, is it really surprising that more people who own Apple products, have entered an Apple store? How else would they buy one otherwise??
4. People who own expensive electronic equipment are more likely to be richer and younger? Really, I couldn't have guessed that.
Re:Are You Caught Up in Apple’s Reality Distortion Field?
by bunderbunder on Monday October 22, 2012 @02:01PM
(#4684394)
What was really interesting about that figure was that among Apple users, about half still think they're overpriced.
That's not a figure that I'd think is consistent with the "fanboy" and "reality distortion field" memes. To the extent that you can glean an image from a single survey result, this one does more to suggest a sober, perhaps even skeptical customer base. Folks who think their brand of choice is overpriced aren't slavish devotees; they're people who are presumably ready, willing, even eager to switch brands the moment they see a better value proposition.
And it suggests that perhaps the failure of other brands to eat further into Apple's market share isn't something that can easily be waved away with frantic pleas about fanboys and reality distortion fields.
Re:Are You Caught Up in Apple’s Reality Distortion Field?
by kennysabarese on Tuesday October 23, 2012 @04:42AM
(#4687135)
My guess is that anyone filling out a survey and asked if they want what they will likely buy again to be cheaper, they will agree with it. So this may not be an accurate question.
Re:Are You Caught Up in Apple’s Reality Distortion Field?
by rdl on Monday October 22, 2012 @04:52AM
(#4682308)
I didn't expect the slight bump to non-white ownership of Apple products. I suspect it's related to the huge bias (2-3x) for younger people owning Apple products, and there being a much higher percentage of non-white people in 0-18 and 18-34 brackets than in 35-death.
Re:Are You Caught Up in Apple’s Reality Distortion Field?
by terhechte on Monday October 22, 2012 @04:54AM
(#4682311)
Yeah, I figured the same. So it's more a cause of the age bias and less anything about the Apple brand. Might just as well not have it included in the infographic then.
Re:Are You Caught Up in Apple’s Reality Distortion Field?
by okamiueru on Monday October 22, 2012 @05:15AM
(#4682355)
Come up with a conclusion already in the title seems like such a horrible thing to do, especially when the numbers presented form a lousy argument for it's validity.
Instead of reading it as a comparison (which it was), it was portrayed as arguments suggested being relevant to having a distorted reality. To me, the author just wanted a catchy title. I'm sure it worked.
People who own Apple products are three times more likely to have been in an Apple store? How does that relate to a distortion field?
Re:Are You Caught Up in Apple’s Reality Distortion Field?
by aaronbrethorst on Monday October 22, 2012 @05:01AM
(#4682328)
I voted you up, but this really isn't an infographic[1]. Mashable and most other websites that produce these are really just making the fast food equivalent of infographics: cheap, fast, and not particularly nutritious.
My rule of thumb for good vs. bad infographics is whether or not a paragraph of text could better capture the data presented. See, for example, the graph depicting Napoleon's army in the Russian campaign: http://www.edwardtufte.com/tufte/posters
[1] Wikipedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Infographic): "These graphics present complex information quickly and clearly, such as in signs, maps, journalism, technical writing, and education."
Re:Are You Caught Up in Apple’s Reality Distortion Field?
by Toshio on Monday October 22, 2012 @05:09AM
(#4682343)
I don't own anything made by Apple, but I have to admit, I kind of enjoy watching how the BYOD movement is beginning to prove wrong microsoft's long held creed "enterprise software is our birthright".
Enterprise software is fair game to everyone and it is noone's birthright.
1. Are they assuming that everyone who bought an Apple device is caught in the reality distortion field?
2. Is it really significant that people who used to own Apple devices, but now don't, are more likely to be dissatisfied with Apple products? I mean, that's the reason they are former Apple customers no?
3. For that matter, is it really surprising that more people who own Apple products, have entered an Apple store? How else would they buy one otherwise??
4. People who own expensive electronic equipment are more likely to be richer and younger? Really, I couldn't have guessed that.
That's not a figure that I'd think is consistent with the "fanboy" and "reality distortion field" memes. To the extent that you can glean an image from a single survey result, this one does more to suggest a sober, perhaps even skeptical customer base. Folks who think their brand of choice is overpriced aren't slavish devotees; they're people who are presumably ready, willing, even eager to switch brands the moment they see a better value proposition.
And it suggests that perhaps the failure of other brands to eat further into Apple's market share isn't something that can easily be waved away with frantic pleas about fanboys and reality distortion fields.
Instead of reading it as a comparison (which it was), it was portrayed as arguments suggested being relevant to having a distorted reality. To me, the author just wanted a catchy title. I'm sure it worked.
People who own Apple products are three times more likely to have been in an Apple store? How does that relate to a distortion field?
My rule of thumb for good vs. bad infographics is whether or not a paragraph of text could better capture the data presented. See, for example, the graph depicting Napoleon's army in the Russian campaign: http://www.edwardtufte.com/tufte/posters
[1] Wikipedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Infographic): "These graphics present complex information quickly and clearly, such as in signs, maps, journalism, technical writing, and education."
I had a really hard time understanding some parts of it. The writing feels chopped and bad.
Enterprise software is fair game to everyone and it is noone's birthright.