News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Greenpeace pilot brings heat pumps and solar to Ukrainian... by newsclues on Monday January 19, 2026 @05:49AM (#46677452)
Solar seems vulnerable in a war.
Re:Greenpeace pilot brings heat pumps and solar to Ukrainian... by NicuCalcea on Monday January 19, 2026 @07:19AM (#46678168)
Compared to what? Gas, nuclear and hydro seem even more vulnerable.
Re:Greenpeace pilot brings heat pumps and solar to Ukrainian... by mothballed on Monday January 19, 2026 @07:33AM (#46678279)
Off grid people ~dont heat off solar. They use hydrocarbons for heat sources. Or wood.

Heat vastly increases solar generation and battery demand.

Re:Greenpeace pilot brings heat pumps and solar to Ukrainian... by NicuCalcea on Monday January 19, 2026 @08:02AM (#46678521)
Most of rural Ukraine already uses or can use solid fuel (firewood, coal) for heating. The article is about flats, not off-grid houses.
Re:Greenpeace pilot brings heat pumps and solar to Ukrainian... by mothballed on Monday January 19, 2026 @10:48AM (#46680281)
Adding some supplemental solar that will move the needle a drop in a brown-out isn't absolutely nothing I suppose, but really for immediate war-time resiliency you would be using solar for off-grid purposes (even if during grid blackouts only).

If your goal is to stay on grid the payoff on solar isn't really realized for 10+ years, when not only are the panels paid off but the accumulation factor of a country full of people with solar panels reduces the grid strain on the conventional sources you list. Adding them for war-time reasons is overall a net negative vs just buying diesel heaters, distributing solar for actual off-grid purposes so people have communications, etc. It is not going to meaningfully reduce dependency on those sources during the period of the war -- that's why I assumed it had to be for off-grid alternative because in that case it would achieve that goal.

Of course it is better than nothing, assuming they did not waste too many domestic resources doing this Greenpeace stunt. But this on-grid solar component is not a serious proposition for wartime demand, and you would be WAY better off donating to maintaining/defending the existing hydro/nuclear/coal generation than trying to deploy enough solar to move the needle for solar grid resiliency within the timespan of the war. I guess I just assumed they were acting rationally and that is why I thought it might be used in off-grid scenarios, but you've disillusioned me of that.

Re:Greenpeace pilot brings heat pumps and solar to Ukrainian... by newsclues on Monday January 19, 2026 @08:54AM (#46678993)
Fossil fuel generators, can be hidden in trees or underground and vented.

Solar panels are easy to spot from a drone, and fragile, so it's easy to damage them.

My friends in Ukraine charge their ecoflows with a generator, because if you put a solar panel outside your drone team bunker, you invite incoming artillery.

Re:Greenpeace pilot brings heat pumps and solar to Ukrainian... by NicuCalcea on Monday January 19, 2026 @09:32AM (#46679387)
Of course, I was talking about civilian use, not implying drone teams might spin up a nuclear reactor for a bit of warmth. Solar panels and heat pumps won't make a block of flats more of a target.
Re:Greenpeace pilot brings heat pumps and solar to Ukrainian... by theshrike79 on Tuesday January 20, 2026 @03:09AM (#46689163)
> Fossil fuel generators, can be hidden in trees or underground and vented.

And how do you plan to get the fossil fuels for these generators? Gas stations and oil pipelines are even easier and more centralised targets than solar panels.

I think you're thinking of massive gigantic centralised solar power plants, what if every single house has enough solar for the basic necessities, would Putin just carpet bomb every neighbourhood to rubble just to destroy the cheap Chinese solar panels?

Re:Greenpeace pilot brings heat pumps and solar to Ukrainian... by Mashimo on Monday January 19, 2026 @06:55AM (#46677968)
Solar + battery helps against shorter blackouts, to at least keep your freezer and fridge running. All while they repair the grid.
Re:Greenpeace pilot brings heat pumps and solar to Ukrainian... by iso1631 on Monday January 19, 2026 @06:14AM (#46677654)
If you have solar on your roof and a bomb hits it, you have no power. And no roof. Power is the least of your problems.

If you have a central power nuclear/gas/coal station and a bomb hits it, nobody has power.

Re:Greenpeace pilot brings heat pumps and solar to Ukrainian... by ekianjo on Monday January 19, 2026 @07:24AM (#46678204)
The grid never relies on a single source
Re:Greenpeace pilot brings heat pumps and solar to Ukrainian... by woodpanel on Monday January 19, 2026 @06:21AM (#46677716)
> If you have a central power nuclear/gas/coal station and a bomb hits it, nobody has power.

if that happens it can be repaired more economically and faster – as has been repeatedly shown in Ukraine.

Re:Greenpeace pilot brings heat pumps and solar to Ukrainian... by kilington on Monday January 19, 2026 @06:34AM (#46677811)
I think we need to look harder at the concept of survivor bias and what it doesn't mean for future chance if anyone believes Ukraine nuclear power stations suffering damage as routinely as any other physical asset would have been OK.
Re:Greenpeace pilot brings heat pumps and solar to Ukrainian... by iso1631 on Monday January 19, 2026 @08:22AM (#46678702)
If my roof has gone it doesn't matter, as I need to move elsewhere.

Chances are my roof won't be gone though.

Re:Greenpeace pilot brings heat pumps and solar to Ukrainian... by theshrike79 on Tuesday January 20, 2026 @03:10AM (#46689173)
But 99% of your neighbours will still have power and roofs.

If a central power plant is destroyed, 0% of the neighbourhood will have power, but 100% will have roofs.

Which is better in your opinion?

Re:Greenpeace pilot brings heat pumps and solar to Ukrainian... by watwut on Monday January 19, 2026 @08:57AM (#46679023)
Solar and wind can be distributed and thus more robust - Russia needs to attack more then one place. Which is, I suspect, why certain people object to this.