But I don't think that's what this article was about.
Actually, he isn't. The only institutional care he mentions in the What I realize now section is "supportive short-term and long-term community housing and treatment", which doesn't sound like institutional care, in the sense of "When he was in jail, with its regular routines and meals, Tim usually stabilized". There was a reason why total institutions were, well, total.
In fact, his "if I were a legislator today" comments are essentially the same as the "I jumped at the opportunity to" do actions in the 1980's.
But it is. The housing/treatment he is referring to covers a range of facilities from supported housing to crisis centers to residential and secure residential treatment facilities based in the community. The goal of these facilities is to provide the stability necessary for a person to compensate and, ideally, re-enter society.
Some folks need to enter a crisis center for a short stay during a time of instability. Some simply need a place to live (supported housing) with just a little more structure. There are also people who are chronically ill and do well (some not so well) in a residential or secure residential treatment program, but will never leave because they are unable to function without the stability of an institution.
Mental illness is a spectrum, hence the array of different support tools. The programs the OP was if'ing about exist, and are progressing. For instance, there is new legislature in my state that expands these programs to include general medical and dental care.
Part of my job includes tracking (arguably) quantifiable data on how clients respond to community-based residential treatment. I have not been in this space long, and I'm still learning about the underlying process/politics that our business model exploits. But I do have the data to show that residential treatment works, sorry I can't share.
There are many community-based mental health providers. They are private-sector companies, usually nonprofits, that provide treatment paid for by state funding (medicaid, etc.).
The "humane reforms" may not have been just for the good. More details in http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4662700
Upvote for using the word 'promulgating' though. Good show :o)
I say it's a good point because it may be worth making a distinction between early-mid 20th century institutional care in an asylum and early 21st century institutional care through a variety of assistance programs. You have presented a good case that the distinction is either meaningless or that there is a direct relationship between the former and the latter, but either way, the article doesn't spell out the link between the two.
These residential programs are providing the type of solid routines that allows a client to stabilize and are actually doing a better job than the large institutions (according to my data). Think of the difference between how well most students do in a large impersonal lecture hall vs. 1 on 1's with teachers who take a real interest in their education.
It saves money on a small scale because no one's trying to defraud it yet.
The constant bed bug invasions, bunking right next to a paranoid schizophrenic, living in constant fear of rape (yes, even for men)? Treated like a social pariah on a good day, non-existent the next? This isn't even the tip of the iceberg, I assure you.
Life inside the system is not nearly as rosy as you might think.
Often I feel like people should be made to work directly with the homeless before letting them spout off on this particular topic.
What I said was that the conditions in these institutions is so inhumanly bad, that no one in their right mind would voluntarily do it. So what kind of fraud are you thinking of?
I envision this to be a lot like crime. You'll never get rid of it completely, so you put into place some (ostensibly) cost-effective measures to mitigate the worst of it.
based on no data, what-so-ever? I believe the parent claiming that there would be no monetary savings at-scale or in the long term
Right now, we spend a lot of money and get very little. If we chose to spend more rather than passively leak money, we'd at least be able to exercise some control over how it's spent, benefit from economies of scale, and so on.
To be explicit, I'm drawing a distinction between efficiency of dollars and raw quantity of dollars. Given the choice between spending $250 and getting nothing versus spending $500 and receiving something of substantial value, I'd opt for the latter. And that's what the qualifier about "benefits to society overall" is about; there's more value to be had from this than some dollar amount.
But if all we're thinking about is a) how many dollars it costs (and not how we're wasting money now), and b) that some small subset of people might game the system (which will always happen, regardless of counter-measures), I think that's self-defeating.
Without calculating the expense spread between the criminal justice system and the mental health system, I'd wager that the savings will be great enough that we can afford fraud prevention too.
I make no claims about how common this kind of fraud would actually be.
You would think that this kind of operation would get cheaper at scale. You might not need 2X wrecked-apartment-repairmen for 2X people housed.
Furthermore one of the stated issues is his unwillingness to take antipsychotic medication, and one of the characteristic traits is that in a structured jail environment, where he's presumably receiving those medications, he is able to function well. That indicates that with a proper support system that includes support to make sure that he takes the required medication, he might have a shot at being a contributing member of society.
He needs these medications. But it has definitely changed him.
However when he's left to drift around homeless and without medication, his odds of success are currently 0. "Somewhat unlikely" is a significant improvement on that present reality.
The drugs are no better. I have done a couple stints in a private mental health (inpatient and outpatient) facilities when dealing with what was diagnosed as Schizo-affective disorder (which is basically the presence of schizophrenia and a mood disorder) and there was a teen there who was schizophrenic. He was a large dose of Risperdal (one of the major anti-psychotics) to treat the schizophrenia. I don't think I will ever forget the few weeks the doctor took him off his Risperdal. He was completely different. When on the drug, he was slow and almost catatonic at times. After been weened off, he actually had personality.Also, this is a bit tangential, but I don't really perceive schizophrenia as changing one's personality. I have a close friend who is schizophrenic, and when she has episodes, hardly a bit of her real self remains. It's not a personality shift, it's more like a personality stroke/seizure.
http://psychcentral.com/news/2010/12/17/drug-‘ecstasy’-may-h...
I didn't think the author was stating that his son wouldn't have schizophrenia if the schools had done better. I think he was saying that his son would have a better outcome with his chronic severe mental illness if various government agencies and actors were better organizing to identify and treat the illness.
Perhaps it's fair to say that Tim is where he is today because of his mental illness and a host of public policy decisions we've made in this country around how we treat mental illness.
I have met very many people with a diagnosis of schizophrenia. Some of those people were drug users (or had been drug users); some of those people were "forensic" patients and were being held in secure hospitals; some of those people were in the community, on medication, with full time work.
Schizophrenia is a complex illness that expresses in a wide range of behaviours, and a broad depth of severities of behaviours. One person may hear a few voices, but be able to cope well with those voices, while another people may hear more voices which are very threatening and hard to cope with.
Please, I understand what you're saying. (Some people with schizophrenia are very ill, and will need extensive support just to avoid homelessness) but I find your comment a bit stigmatising. Many people with schizophrenia do work; not all of them work full time paid employment but it's certainly possible for someone with a diagnosis of schizophrenia to lead a full and productive life.
How about partially wrong? Maybe it's more accurate to say "Tim is where he is today partially because of a host of health policy decisions..."
absolutes often lead to unnecessary, counterproductive arguments.
In many less developed countries people with schizophrenia have better outcomes. It's only in the US where the condition is usually debilitating for life, because:
A) The US healthcare system relies on longterm use of anti-psychotic medication as the main form of treatment, which tends to lead to worse outcomes in the long run.
B) Family relationships in the US are generally not conducive to properly recovering from schizophrenia.
In other countries the people aren't completely normally, but they're also generally not completely unable to hold a job for their entire lives like in the US.
Schizophrenia is basically triggered & exacerbated by stress. If one becomes schizophrenic then it's possible to mostly recover from psychosis in low stress environments, but in higher stress environments it basically becomes permanent.
I think that Ethan Watters discusses why it is that people in poor countries do better due to social factors in his book Crazy Like Us, and Robert Whitaker discusses the role of anti-psychotics in Anatomy of an Epidemic.
In terms of social factors though, I vaguely remember that in poor countries families are more likely to let people with schizophrenia just hang out and work on recovering for years at a time, whereas in more developed countries this is less likely to happen. (Possibly because this isn't as possible due to the higher costs of living and the greater stresses of living in a society with a very unequal distribution of wealth, but I forget the exact mechanism.)
As for the basic data, here is one book that summarizes it:
http://ajp.psychiatryonline.org/article.aspx?articleid=98965
They provide evidence based advice. They've provided some advice about getting people with mental health problems who are claiming incapacity benefits off benefits and back into work.
The traditional response is a long slow curve; don't rush anything; work is stressful; start with a bit of part time voluntary work; build that up; there aren't enough jobs around anyway and no-ones going to employ mentally ill people and the stress of rejection is harmful. They also used to have a stock of low grade jobs (shelf filling at supermarkets) so when people turned up they'd get kludged into whatever was available.
The evidence shows that many people actually want to be much more active. We now have strong anti-discrimination laws. And "place then train" (get someone a job that they want, then support them to keep that job) is much more effective. If someone is a good employee an employer probably wants to keep them on, and if there's funding available to make reasonable adjustments then letting them know is good.
Here's a list of the Sainsbury Centre publications
(http://www.centreformentalhealth.org.uk/publications/publica...)
My experience with the school system (I have a daughter with autism) has been much better then his sounds (I hope so given it's 40 years later). We have no push back in getting our developmental pediatricians' input into our daughter's IEP. Our school provides speech and occupational therapy. But as you mentioned, schizophrenia is a whole other world (even from autism in my opinion). There is no cure. There are only lesser of many evils. You can't expect society to fix that.
One thing that really bothers me are these crazy statistics - "one in every five children and one in every four adults has a diagnosable mental illness. A quarter of all mental illnesses are considered serious." One in four? Come on. If the bar is so low that one in four have a mental diagnosis it makes the term meaningless. It drives my wife and I crazy when parents claim there kid had autism but after a month on this fad diet or other they are now cured. Guess what - your kid never had autism! Don't tell that to a parent who knows their daughter will likely never leave home, never marry, and probably never hold down a meaningful job. It's just insulting.
I'm having trouble getting past this comment. I don't wish to malign you debacle - I'm sure you're not being malicious - but it seems like a very unkind & privileged mindset. I hope this isn't representative of the community.
Paul Gionfriddo certainly doesn't consider his son to lack contribution.
You think being of sound mental health is a privilege? In Europe we think health is a right, which is why we have public health systems. It may sound a bit strange at first, but it works quite well.
25% of prisoners are there because of ADHD. In aggregate it probably causes much more harm than schizophrenia.
Source?
Source?
Schizophrenia is not the kind of disease you can treat with an IEP, and it sounds like the author's son fell out of the system from a very young age. Trying to blame anything but genetics and development for his son's state is disingenuous - treating schizophrenia is a complicated, involved, and ultimately very stressful process for everyone involved, and in the end it can only bring someone on the brink of homelessness or self-harm into a situation where they can be stable most of the time, but never all of the time, or even almost always.
> The word “disability,” for instance, should have covered Tim and children like him.
ADHD or blindness are not even in the same room a schizophrenia. It's like comparing having six toes on your left foot to being comatose.
> If I were a legislator today, I’d mandate — and provide funding to ensure — that every teacher receive training in recognizing symptoms of mental illnesses.
Teachers have enough on their plate, and more importantly, that's not what teachers are for. It sounds like the author took his son to plenty of mental health professionals, and he still wasn't properly diagnosed until he was nearly an adult.
> I’d see that pediatricians are trained to make screening for mental health concerns a regular part of well-child exams.
Many mental health diseases don't manifest to the levels for proper diagnosis until adulthood, and even then the process of diagnosis is not scientific.
> I’d put much more money into community mental health services...
All of that sounds great, but mental health services are one of the first things cut into in a down economy.
> Tim is where he is today because of a host of public policy decisions we’ve made in this country.
No, he isn't. The author is wrong, and I'm sorry for that, but it's very unlikely that his son would have ever been a contributing member of society. Schizophrenia is a severe mental disease that cannot be treated like a 'special need.'