News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Iran Protest Map by Esophagus4 on Thursday January 08, 2026 @06:13PM (#46547861)
I have so much admiration for anyone who protests a regime as oppressive and brutal as theirs.

Just by being involved, I imagine they’re in serious danger. So far, more than 550 people have been killed and 20k detained by security forces.[1]

Godspeed.

Edit: these death numbers are from an older protest and are inaccurate. Please see article / comments below :)

[1]https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/ce3kl56z2l4o

Re:Iran Protest Map by quietbritishjim on Thursday January 08, 2026 @06:21PM (#46547929)
That article says "at least 19 protesters and one member of the security forces have been killed", although that was as of a few days ago.

The numbers you quoted are from the end of the article, which is about the previous demonstrations in 2022.

(In fairness, it's confusing because BBC News articles put almost every sentence into its own paragraph, which I think is intended to help low literacy people read them. But it does make it hard to follow the connections between sentences that really ought to be together in a paragraph, like in this case.)

Re:Iran Protest Map by Esophagus4 on Thursday January 08, 2026 @06:34PM (#46548057)
Oh, oops… thanks for the correction. Must’ve skimmed it too quickly.
Re:Iran Protest Map by Alupis on Thursday January 08, 2026 @06:30PM (#46548026)
Unfortunately we've seen protests like this before in Iran (perhaps not this widespread, however).

Shouting in the streets won't end the regime. The regime will either just wait it out, or clamp down with violence. The people will need to take more direct action if they hope for any change to come out of this - which unfortunately likely means more death.

Without weapons, the people of Iran will have a difficult time overthrowing the regime. This may highlight to some folks abroad the importance of the US's 2nd Amendment, and an armed civilian population - things we take for granted in the US, and some wish to abolish.

It's a nasty, depressing situation. The regime needs to end. The people of Iran, and the people of the world will be far better off without this regime.

I hope the best for the people of Iran.

Re:Iran Protest Map by mmasu on Thursday January 08, 2026 @06:49PM (#46548185)
I disagree with this - there have been overthrowings that did not require weapons in the field (i.e. Egypt, Tunisia), while widespread weapons were likely to cause civil wars (Lybia, Syria). In these cases however the role of the army was key in forcing the rulers out (and in Egypt to replace them), which might be unlikely in the case of Iran.
Re:Iran Protest Map by embedding-shape on Thursday January 08, 2026 @06:39PM (#46548100)
> This may highlight to some folks abroad the importance of the US's 2nd Amendment, and an armed civilian population

I don't think this highlight that at all. Judging by what has happened so far, the people who have the guns join the tyranny rather than oppose it. Why would it be any different in Iran?

Re:Iran Protest Map by Alupis on Thursday January 08, 2026 @06:41PM (#46548116)
You can look at historical revolutions - going back to the beginning of time - to see your statement is obviously false. An armed civilian population is one that can enact revolution. A disarmed population is one that gets killed, beaten and controlled.
Re:Iran Protest Map by hannasanarion on Thursday January 08, 2026 @06:51PM (#46548206)
No rebellion or revolt had ever been successful without arms supplied from outside sponsors.

Random personal small arms that a bunch of people just happen to have at home are not enough to win a revolutionary war against a professional military.

Self defense pistols and hunting rifles don't win wars, artillery does.

Re:Iran Protest Map by zozbot234 on Thursday January 08, 2026 @07:04PM (#46548318)
> Random personal small arms that a bunch of people just happen to have at home are not enough to win a revolutionary war against a professional military.

They're absolutely enough to tip the scales in favor of those within that professional military who would rather support the prospective revolution. Such people will definitely exist given a widespread revolt against a violently oppressive regime.

Re:Iran Protest Map by keketi on Thursday January 08, 2026 @07:31PM (#46548561)
How about this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2025_Nepalese_Gen_Z_protests#9...

September 9, 2025 - Protesters storm the Nepalese parliament, ransacking it and setting it on fire. Homes of leading politicians are also torched and the politicians themselves attacked.

Soon thereafter, the prime minister resigned along with other ministers and the president dissolved the parliament and scheduled a new election.

I think that counts as a successful rebellion or revolt.

Re:Iran Protest Map by hannasanarion on Monday January 19, 2026 @11:02AM (#46680473)
The Gen Z revolution would have gone nowhere had the Nepalese Military not launched a coup, removed the existing government from power at gunpoint, and asked the protesters who to replace them with.

So, fine, there's a third condition: when the entire military mutinies, leaving the regime with no armed defenders.

Re:Iran Protest Map by runlaszlorun on Thursday January 08, 2026 @07:41PM (#46548649)
IoT and clean comms do.

Yes random small arms make quite a difference in many scenarios. I can say this with zero commentary on whether one feels society broadly should have more guns.

Re:Iran Protest Map by WillPostForFood on Thursday January 08, 2026 @07:12PM (#46548393)
Russian Revolution? French Revolution?
Re:Iran Protest Map by hannasanarion on Monday January 19, 2026 @11:00AM (#46680441)
* or mass-scale mutinies from the military itself giving the revolutionaries access to artillery, tanks, planes, and ships while the regime has none.
Re:Iran Protest Map by esseph on Thursday January 08, 2026 @10:41PM (#46549803)
Ehhhh.

I know a LOT of folks in the US that are regular citizens with plate carriers, night vision, thermals, suppressors, and forced-reset triggers.

A lot of them have better training that most leg infantry, and many are veterans.

Re:Iran Protest Map by actionfromafar on Friday January 09, 2026 @05:16AM (#46552174)
Besides, if you start to turn random American cities into Gaza style rubble with artillery, the military will also break into factions.
Re:Iran Protest Map by rfrey on Thursday January 08, 2026 @07:24PM (#46548507)
But what do you do when the most vocal proponents of an armed populace support the tyrant?
Re:Iran Protest Map by esseph on Thursday January 08, 2026 @10:43PM (#46549813)
Then it's good to be a Gray Man/Woman.
Re:Iran Protest Map by Esophagus4 on Thursday January 08, 2026 @06:40PM (#46548110)
I worry the same - a weak regime is a dangerous one, and I fear this will involve a lot of suffering either way for the people of Iran.
Re:Iran Protest Map by avar on Thursday January 08, 2026 @06:48PM (#46548175)

    > This may highlight to some folks abroad
    > the importance of the US's 2nd Amendment,
    > and an armed civilian population
British India, the USSR, East Germany, Francoist Spain, Apartheid South Africa, Communist Romania etc. etc. The 20th century is full of repressive regimes with even more repressive gun laws that fell due to protests etc.

The idea that everyone can show up at the protest with their AR-15, somehow defeat the state's security forces in armed combat, and that the result will be some enlightened republic is an American fantasy, informed by what's at best a selective reading of American history.

If it comes to that you're much more likely to end up under some warlord. Afghanistan and especially Africa are full of people who are well armed and where exactly that's happened more often than not.

Re:Iran Protest Map by zozbot234 on Thursday January 08, 2026 @06:54PM (#46548230)
The actual idea is that this will give individual members of the "security forces" a plausible excuse to not repress the protests violently - which can be very helpful in shifting the overall incentives towards a peaceful transition of power.
Re:Iran Protest Map by blell on Thursday January 08, 2026 @06:55PM (#46548234)
Francoist Spain never fell, fyi. It was a much more popular regime than the rest you mentioned though.
Re:Iran Protest Map by delfinom on Thursday January 08, 2026 @07:02PM (#46548296)
Except authoritarians can only clamp down in protests so much, working against them is economic and even regional social collapse due to running out of water. There's a lot building against them.

I actually hope western countries stay out, lest it gives support for nationalists to rally

Re:Iran Protest Map by the_gipsy on Thursday January 08, 2026 @07:06PM (#46548329)
How is that working out for America? Some lady got shot the other day by some out-of-control cosplay militia.
Re:Iran Protest Map by stavros on Thursday January 08, 2026 @08:45PM (#46549149)
But Americans have guns! They can overthrow a tyrannical government whenever they want! They just don't feel like it right now.
Re:Iran Protest Map by lbrito on Thursday January 08, 2026 @09:17PM (#46549379)
Bizarre that this is downvoted into gray. This comment is simply stating a fact