News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by milfot on Monday October 15, 2012 @12:52AM (#4653826)
Quick question, do you actually think it is the 'militant' or the 'islam' that scares the west?

And once you figure out the (right) answer to that question, please rewrite your post to replace 'islamists' with 'militants'.

The real lesson here is what better way to mobilise a generation of a nation into militancy than occupy their country, sell off their assets, kill 5% of the population and then insult their religion.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by coolestuk on Monday October 15, 2012 @01:16AM (#4653872)
Almost the whole world that is islamic became muslim through military occupation, the mass slaughter of the males who fought or would not convert, the looting of property and the selling off into slavery of their women and children. This was all based on emulating the behaviour of Mohammed (known as sunnah in islamic practice); Mohammed took 20% of the spoils from his army of warriors. (Some describe him as the profit of 20% because of this). This can be verified in The Life of Mohammed, the first biography of Mohammed (and written by a muslim 100 years after the death of Mohammed). The author, Ibn Ishaq, was a christian who was taken as a slave to Medina, and converted to islam for a better life (one of the inducements used in the spread of islam).

The real lesson is that christianity endured 300 years of this aggression, before Pope Urban made christianity do an about turn, and began the (very minimal) Crusades against islam. They were a failure, and islamic violence against European christendom continued until the Siege of Vienna (when Jan Sobieski defeated the muslim army on September 11, 1683).

Watch just 1 minute of this video to see what happened: http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v...

The muslim attack against Europe continued beyond this. The white slave trade continued for hundreds of years (it was stopped by a joint British/US naval bombardment of Algeria in 1815). In 1951 the UN report on slavery calculated that 5% of the population of Saudi Arabia and Yemen were still slaves.

Buddhism did not respond in the same way as christianity to islamic aggression. Many experts on the history of buddhism say that buddhism died about 1000 years ago (e.g. Conze). And they explicitly attribute this death of buddhism to the onslaught of the islamic invasion & destruction in India.

The real lesson is that some religions are actually militant political movements wrapped up in religion. Islam is one such religion. Islamic militancy was going on for hundreds of years before christianity responded in kind.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by milfot on Monday October 15, 2012 @01:55AM (#4653944)
"Almost the whole world that is islamic became muslim through military occupation."

This is just plain bullshit! The introduction of islam to much of the world was through trade, just the same as the christians. And if you take slavery, trade and military occupations to be evidence that "The real lesson is that some religions are actually militant political movements wrapped up in religion." then I am afraid you will have to say the same of christianity.

Once again, the point is that extremists / militants use religion (or any other reason) to justify occupation, oppression and murder. To fight militant-ism you have to do just two things. 1.resist. 2.not become one.

ps: were you serious about that video you linked? seems like dumb paranoid aryan propaganda to me..

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by coolestuk on Monday October 15, 2012 @02:14AM (#4653982)
"The introduction of islam to much of the world was through trade, just the same as the christians. "

Would you care to provide evidence for that assertion about trade rather than jihad? There is evidence that for areas like Indonesia & Malaysia, trade was the route. For almost everywhere else, it was by war. Next you'll be telling me that the hundreds of years in which islam used violence to dominate Spain was a Golden Age of tolerance and multi-culturalism.

Ibn Ishaq's book "The Life of Mohammed" was known by muslims for hundreds of years as "The Book of Battles". Muslims must emulate Mohammed. In the 13 years he was in Mecca, he attained 150 followers. In Medina he embraced war, assassination, slave-taking and robbery. By the time he died, all of Arabia was muslim.

Essentially, Islam was spread by the sword.

Attacking that video as "dumb paranoid aryan propaganda" is an ad hominem fallacy. Deal with the facts.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by chumma on Monday October 15, 2012 @03:13AM (#4654064)
> In the 13 years he was in Mecca, he attained 150 followers. In Medina he embraced war, assassination, slave-taking and robbery. By the time he died, all of Arabia was muslim.

So would you please care to provide evidence to this assertion? How someone with a mere 150 followers could control a whole nation ?

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by westicle on Monday October 15, 2012 @03:44AM (#4654134)
Voldemort managed.

(http://hpmor.com/chapter/34)

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by chumma on Monday October 15, 2012 @04:07AM (#4654176)
Yea maybe history and fiction are much correlated by the way they are created and explained.
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by jlgreco on Monday October 15, 2012 @02:14AM (#4653981)
I think it is fair to say that both Islam and Christianity were spread with more or less the same mix of techniques. The two religions have a great deal in common.

However that should not be interpreted as praise of Islam. In fact, I think that comparison is extraordinary damming.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by tlear on Monday October 15, 2012 @08:49AM (#4654810)
Not really, big coup for Christianity was conversion of the Roman empire and that was most definitely peaceful. Contrast that with how Middle east, and North Africa became Muslim
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by Volpe on Monday October 15, 2012 @09:35AM (#4654958)
erm.. but the 'spread' of the roman empire, was not peaceful. So you are really arguing the semantics of the order in which things were done.

Large group takes over world, then spreads religion. vs Large group spreads religion, and takes over world.

Yeah, REAL moral high ground there.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by jlgreco on Monday October 15, 2012 @10:52AM (#4655290)
That is pretty much when the religious violence started...
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by ucee054 on Monday October 15, 2012 @09:43AM (#4654987)
No the conversion of the Emperor was peaceful.

As for the pagan citizens of the Empire who didn't convert after that, the Parabalani made short work of them...

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by simonh on Monday October 15, 2012 @03:50AM (#4654144)
"Almost the whole world that is islamic became muslim through military occupation, the mass slaughter of the males who fought or would not convert, the looting of property and the selling off into slavery of their women and children."

s/is islamic became muslim/was colonial became christian/

"Islamic militancy was going on for hundreds of years before christianity responded in kind."

Try a search for the word "crusade" on wikipedia. You might find it enlightening.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by cousin_it on Monday October 15, 2012 @10:09AM (#4655096)
What specifically should I find enlightening?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusades

== Middle Eastern situation ==

In 636 CE, Muslim forces led by the Arab Rashidun Caliphs defeated the Eastern Roman/Byzantines at the Battle of Yarmouk, conquering Palestine...

== Western European situation ==

The western European idea of the Crusades came in response to the deterioration of the Byzantine Empire caused by a new wave of Turkish Muslim attacks...

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by simonh on Tuesday October 16, 2012 @04:38AM (#4658889)
How did the Romans/Byzantines get into Palestine in the first place? "They started it" as a historical excuse is a pretty poor rationalisation. The point is right now, in the current generation and given the current situation what is the best way to proceed.
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by _delirium on Monday October 15, 2012 @09:20AM (#4654896)
How does this differ from the violent history of Christianization? From Theodosius I declaring Christianity mandatory and destroying the pagan temples, to Icelanders being held hostage to put pressure on them to convert (which they eventually voted to do, under that pressure), to colonial militias spreading Christianity in Africa and Asia, the religion basically spread by the sword. And it was maintained for hundreds of years thereafter through state violence: in most of Europe, if you attempted to convert to another religion, or declare yourself an atheist, you'd be executed as an apostate or a heretic. Even the Jews were expelled from many parts of Europe, where they had been tolerated by the Muslim empires (and prospered in Ottoman Istanbul and Salonica).
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by ucee054 on Monday October 15, 2012 @07:48AM (#4654654)
Next you'll be telling me that the hundreds of years in which islam used violence to dominate Spain was a Golden Age of tolerance and multi-culturalism.

I'll take moslem Spain over Torquemada any day.

It is complete stupidity to assert Islamic violence over European Christendom, when Europe became Christian because of the violence of the Roman Empire.

So what if Europe had been conquered by Genghis Khan and subsequently turned moslem? The Albigensians were exterminated by Catholics. Do you find that somehow better than if they had been exterminated by Sunnis? Do you think the Albigensians enjoyed being slaughtered by Catholics more?

At their basis, Islam, Christianity and Judaism are exactly the same horrid Old Testament garbage. If anything, Islam is less offensive because some of the worst bits of the Old Testament have been cut out, the same way Java is less offensive than C++.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by spindritf on Monday October 15, 2012 @01:02AM (#4653848)
> please rewrite your post to replace 'islamists' with 'militants'.

No need to rewrite anything, it's both their hostility and philosophical differences that scare us. Overcoming that fear and reaffirming our values is the basis for one of the most important texts in the European culture — The Song of Roland.

EDIT: I do know what you mean and I'm sorry but those are just feel-good platitudes. West quite obviously is not afraid of militant Christians or atheists. Mostly because there aren't really any left, and those who still hang around don't regularly erupt in violence, but also because they're much more like us and it's easier for us to understand their particular extremism.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by milfot on Monday October 15, 2012 @02:06AM (#4653966)
At this risk of getting this all out of order (since you edited rather than replying)..

The west is RUN by militant christians (and militant jews and militant atheists etc). They use armies to inflict their particular brand of extremism. They killed about a million iraquis. They murder people in cold blood by dropping missiles from drones from 50,000 ft up. Pretty fucking extreme if you ask me.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by kenbot on Monday October 15, 2012 @07:01AM (#4654511)
This is a commonly made argument, but it's silly. The wars in Iraq and Afghanistan were declared by the secular government of a secular state for geopolitical reasons. Most of the individuals are Christian, but the war and tactics have nothing whatsoever to do with Christian doctrine or motivations.

The "Muslim militants" under discussion launch attacks for specifically Muslim motives, with carefully constructed justifications cross-referenced to precise verses from the Koran and Hadiths.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by Evbn on Wednesday October 17, 2012 @04:33AM (#4663617)
Read up on the neo-conservative philosophy on Israel and its support from Armageddon Christians.
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by eli_gottlieb on Monday October 15, 2012 @05:50AM (#4654356)
Could you please show us the militant Jews and atheists running the West?
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by milfot on Monday October 15, 2012 @08:00AM (#4654689)
Yeah, you got me there, I actually have no idea.. I just assumed there would be some people with other beliefs in the armed forces in US, UK, Israel, Australia (ie. the west).
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by eli_gottlieb on Monday October 15, 2012 @10:09AM (#4655097)
I'd bet the UK and Australia have atheists in their armed forces, but they don't run the world. I've met militant Jews in Israel's armed forces, but they don't run the world either. The United States runs the world, but has a heavily Protestant tilt.
Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by milfot on Monday October 15, 2012 @10:57PM (#4658261)
Fair cop.. I was just trying to be inclusive ;)

Point I was trying to make is the militancy is an end in itself and the belief structures are simply bent to serve it.. in refutation of the idea that militancy in the muslim world is peculiarly religious.

They find religious justifications for operational killings in order not to abandon their religion, not because their religion demands it. US forces just abandon religion when it suits them and call themselves a secular nation. The British made themselves a whole new religion answerable to the head of state. These are all just ways of twisting religion to serve power.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by milfot on Monday October 15, 2012 @01:26AM (#4653888)
The hostility and philosophical differences of muslims or militants?

I think you also misunderstand. Militants are a small subset of society which also includes some muslims, some christians, hindus, atheists etc. Point is, vast majority of muslims are peaceful, just the same as christians or atheists.

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by ucee054 on Monday October 15, 2012 @09:52AM (#4655022)
hostility and philosophical differences that scare us. Overcoming that fear and reaffirming our values is the basis

The Wikipedia entry for "Song of Roland" ends with the actions of Roland's avengers:

"The traitor is torn limb from limb by galloping horses and thirty of his relatives are hung for good measure."

What differences in philosophy and hostility were you referring to again?

Re:Shut up and play nice: How the Western world is limiting ... by Evbn on Wednesday October 17, 2012 @04:31AM (#4663612)
The US spent 2001-2009 terrorized by militant Christians.