News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by wolvoleo on Wednesday December 31, 2025 @11:17PM (#46451246)
I kinda see the opposite, all sites seem to be going to subscription models. Obviously it doesn't work because I'm not going to subscribe to every news site I see a link from on HN.

So I tend to use archive.ph . I wish there was a plugin to open a page in that more easily though. Luckily most HN posts have a reader contributing a link in the comments.

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by rrradical on Thursday January 01, 2026 @01:38AM (#46451861)
I've always wondered why I can't pay some small fee (20 cents? $1?) to read an article. Why it have to be an entire subscription? If I put $20 / month into an account and then spend that bit by bit on high quality articles from different sites I'd gladly do that.
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by Yiin on Thursday January 01, 2026 @02:33AM (#46452084)
because payment processors hate small payments and punish accordingly (with flat fee +%)
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by wolvoleo on Thursday January 01, 2026 @02:59AM (#46452174)
That shouldn't really be a problem if there's an intermediary that takes the payment and distributes it.
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by Freak_NL on Thursday January 01, 2026 @04:59AM (#46452788)
We had a service that did this in the Netherlands (Blendle). They had a lot of the big Dutch media titles on-board. It failed and they pivoted to a crappy subscription service.

The model just doesn't work at this point.

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by klez on Thursday January 01, 2026 @06:12AM (#46453175)
Inkl, on the other hand, is still alive and kicking. If you're ok with their selection of sources it's 9.99 per month o 99.99 per year. I still have a pay-per-read subscription, which I prefer to the subscription model, but I'm afraid they don't offer that anymore.
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by wolvoleo on Thursday January 01, 2026 @08:52AM (#46454114)
Yes I know blendle but this was decades ago. In a market that was completely different, where paywalls weren't yet a thing and they would just display ads. It was "ads vs paying a bit". Not really a big incentive.

I think in this day and age where most news outlets simply give you a paywall I think this will work just fine. Because now the alternative is just not reading the content (or paying a sub which is ridiculous for a site you view a couple times a month)

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by Marsymars on Thursday January 01, 2026 @10:49AM (#46454973)
Their hope with subscriptions is that there's value to you visiting more than a couple times per month.

Anecdotally, this works for me - I pay for a handful of subs, and I don't use any news aggregators or feeds - the sites with subs I pay for cover everything of interest to me.

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by tonyedgecombe on Thursday January 01, 2026 @02:51AM (#46452149)
It would be cheaper for you but not very profitable for them.
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by prmoustache on Thursday January 01, 2026 @06:44AM (#46453352)
It really depends, there are so many peoole who just don't want more than a couple subscriptions.

The subscriptiin model only favor the giants like netflix, spotify and NYTimes but not necessarily the smaller players.

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by wolvoleo on Thursday January 01, 2026 @08:56AM (#46454141)
It's only extra money for them because I'm never ever going to subscribe a monthly sub to a site I read one or two articles a month from. So they're not losing anything from me, only gaining. It's basically free money.

Right now I use archive.ph because I can but if I couldn't (if they make it a hard block) I would just ignore links to said outlet.

I sub to a few outlets which I read daily. But I couldn't possibly sub to every single outlet I see a link from. And I wouldn't anyway.

However if I could click '€0.50 to read this article' then yeah I would if it seemed interesting. Especially real journalism, not reuters copy/paste.

And for a regular reader who reads said site daily, it still makes sense to take out a 10-20 bucks a month sub. Still cheaper than paying per read.

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by g947o on Thursday January 01, 2026 @09:08AM (#46454241)
1. You can be sure that most people still won't pay to read the article, so it might not be worth doing at all

2. "Number of subscribers" is a real, meaningful metric used across the industry for various purposes, including informing advertisers and calculating recurring revenue. Your proposal, on the other hand, is somewhat odd and questionable that people probably don't know how to make use of.

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by afavour on Thursday January 01, 2026 @09:56AM (#46454613)
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by ecosystem on Thursday January 01, 2026 @10:21AM (#46454778)
Throwing up hands and saying: internalizing the externalized cost is "ridiculously expensive" is not proof it doesn't work.

The examples of the a la carte exercise brands referenced (SoulCycle, etc) are quite ineffective arguments -- those are successful businesses with loyal, high retention users because they provide specific, high value products to the users.

Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by afavour on Thursday January 01, 2026 @03:54PM (#46457922)
If you’re looking for concrete examples of why it doesn’t work why not study the various companies that have tried this and failed?
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by ctippett on Thursday January 01, 2026 @02:35AM (#46452092)
Re:Web Browsers have stopped blocking pop-ups by wolvoleo on Thursday January 01, 2026 @08:57AM (#46454150)
Thanks!!