News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by Semaphor on Monday December 29, 2025 @01:48PM (#46423928)
For those wondering: it's DNS blocks, so only affecting those using ISP DNS.
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by Reason077 on Monday December 29, 2025 @03:35PM (#46425266)
Interesting. UK ISPs have had a similar block/filter list for many years (mostly covering copyright-infringing torrent websites and the like). But it’s more robust than a simple DNS block. A VPN can bypass the block, but changing DNS providers will not.
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by hsbauauvhabzb on Monday December 29, 2025 @04:28PM (#46425930)
What / how do they do it then? SNI inspection?
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by lategloriousgnu on Monday December 29, 2025 @05:26PM (#46426560)
The ISP's blackhole the IP for some blocked domains. So changing your DNS to 8.8.8.8 will resolve the domain, but the IP won't work. A VPN avoids this, since the traffic goes via the VPN IP.
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by nebezb on Monday December 29, 2025 @06:02PM (#46427075)
Wow that’s intense.

I remember hearing someone complain on HN of their site getting blocked because it shared an IP with an illegal soccer livestream. I can’t imagine they’re doing this to IP blocks owned by CDNs like Fastly, CloudFlare, or CloudFront though. Or are they? Does this regularly break most of the internet for UK customers?

Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by xuki on Monday December 29, 2025 @06:20PM (#46427278)
Spain ISPs block CloudFlare IPs during La Liga matches.
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by uncletammy on Monday December 29, 2025 @08:41PM (#46428500)
Do you have a source for this claim?
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by jesuslop on Monday December 29, 2025 @09:23PM (#46428767)
TBH it is not ALL cloudFlare IPs but a significant quantity of sites using and not using CF CDNs. You cannot imagine what a pest that is even for legit users of legit collateral damage pages. CloudFlare is in the courts appealing/countering initial court allowance to blockade and ISPs are bound to comply to blackout requests. You can look at https://hayahora.futbol (traslation: is there soccer match now?) to see affected domains.
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by lategloriousgnu on Monday December 29, 2025 @09:24PM (#46428772)
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by snvzz on Tuesday December 30, 2025 @09:04AM (#46433415)
While I am not some reputable source per-se, I have some tailscale presence over there and can corroborate my exit nodes find cloudflare sites blanket blocked on weekends.
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by ollybee on Monday December 29, 2025 @07:20PM (#46427893)
In that case it like someone controlling the DNS records for a banned site could cause some mischief
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by hsbauauvhabzb on Monday December 29, 2025 @05:38PM (#46426726)
How would that work with cloudflare and similar though?
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by lategloriousgnu on Monday December 29, 2025 @09:19PM (#46428745)
Cloudflare works with the UK government to facilitate blocks within their infra, I assume in exchange for being allowed to access UK network infrastructure.

In the case that a blocked site resolved to a Cloudflare IP, it would likely be kicked off of Cloudflare, or geo-blocked for UK users (by Cloudflare).

https://www.ispreview.co.uk/index.php/2025/07/cloudflare-blo...

Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by hsbauauvhabzb on Tuesday December 30, 2025 @05:11PM (#46438629)
Ironically that url is forbidden for me, I was under the impression that CF were fairly anti censorship, or at least they inferred that they should not be the one calling the shots (in reference to kiwifarms)
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by flir on Monday December 29, 2025 @09:30PM (#46428831)
I've never hit one. Flipping DNS works for (for example) Anna's Archive. Have you got an example?
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by Aldipower on Monday December 29, 2025 @09:07PM (#46428675)
Transparent DNS proxies on ISP side. Easy thing for them.
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by hsbauauvhabzb on Tuesday December 30, 2025 @05:11PM (#46438633)
DNS over HTTP is a thing also, though.
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by wrboyce on Monday December 29, 2025 @02:47PM (#46424672)
Worth mentioning NextDNS and ControlD under this! I migrated from the former to the latter about six months ago, but both are a solid choice.
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by mctt on Monday December 29, 2025 @04:18PM (#46425829)
Free trial then $20USD per year for ControlD. Is that what you use? If so, why do you use this over another service?
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by silisili on Monday December 29, 2025 @04:47PM (#46426147)
Not OP but I also use ControlD. I admittedly like NextDNS interface better, but honestly, I rarely need to login anyways.

So why ControlD? Because I don't want to run my own piHole, basically. They maintain ad block lists that you can edit as you see fit to add things or relax things that may cause issues(which you can't do easily with public ad blocking dns servers).

Why ControlD then and not NextDNS? First, because their support was awesome when I had an issue. AFAICT it was the founder actually emailing me back and forth, and it ended up being my ISP's fault, but I only knew that based on research provided to me by support. Secondly, I got a good deal on a 5-year subscription at one point.

Happy to answer any questions, not affiliated but a fan of the service.

Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by cyberpunk on Monday December 29, 2025 @04:41PM (#46426068)
Not GP, but I just run my own dns inside the network (unbound on a little openbsd sbc) with a cronjob that pipes oisd.nl into it every night, works great..
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by maxloh on Monday December 29, 2025 @03:07PM (#46424923)
I am curious why SNI-based block isn't used.
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by trinix912 on Monday December 29, 2025 @03:09PM (#46424950)
Shhh, don’t give them ideas
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by ronsor on Monday December 29, 2025 @03:51PM (#46425481)
It won't be relevant in a couple years when 90% of sites will be using ECH, meaning the SNI will be encrypted as well.
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by hypeatei on Monday December 29, 2025 @04:04PM (#46425646)
Just enabling ECH doesn't stop this, firewalls can see it and mangle the data to force a downgrade because most servers need to support older protocols. It's more accurate to say that once sites only support ECH, then they'll be forced to stop downgrading or deal with angry users.
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by ronsor on Monday December 29, 2025 @04:33PM (#46425997)
TLS 1.3, including the ECH extension, does not permit downgrading, unless your implementation is broken.

Trying to downgrade or strip extensions from any TLS 1.3 connection will simply break the connection.

Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by hypeatei on Monday December 29, 2025 @04:50PM (#46426175)
In the wild, that's not true at all[0][1]. The corporate firewall at my employer actually wasn't able to block ECH until they updated it then it was able to block sites as usual.

0: https://community.fortinet.com/t5/FortiGate/Technical-Tip-Ho...

1: https://docs.broadcom.com/doc/symantec-ech-whitepaper (see page 8)

Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by dilyevsky on Monday December 29, 2025 @05:11PM (#46426390)
I ready the FortiGate link and this is the gist:

  The DNS filter setting on the FortiGate analyzes the DoH traffic and strips out the ECH parameters sent by the DNS server in the DoH response. If the client does not receive those parameters, it cannot encrypt the inner SNI, so it will send it in clear text.
So basically they mess with DoH ECH config and trigger fallback behavior in the clients. I don't think any browsers do this yet but I think this loophole is not gonna last.
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by wiml on Monday December 29, 2025 @10:04PM (#46429078)
I'm surprised that works. Doesn't TLS1.3 do the thing where it crosschecks (a hash of) the setup parameters after key-agreement to protect against exactly this kind of downgrade attack?

(My phone screen is too small to look through the RFCs right now.)

Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by dilyevsky on Monday December 29, 2025 @11:19PM (#46429498)
I think what you're describing is TLS1.3 Finished verification so that happens after DoH response during the actual handshake. Basically this works because ECH is fairly new and there's no HSTS-style "always use ECH for this site" configuration yet. And ofc this only works if you configured FortiGate as your DNS (corp network) or if it's doing MITM (though I'd expect browser would verify cert fingerprint for DoH connections as well).
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by dilyevsky on Monday December 29, 2025 @05:01PM (#46426298)
This is literally impossible. What your corp fw likely does is mitm outer SNI because your IT department installed your company CA in every client's trust store. So unless you do that at national level your only other option is to block ECH entirely.

Edit: actually totally possible but you need build quantum computer with sufficient cubits first =)

Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by bigiain on Monday December 29, 2025 @09:58PM (#46429039)
Last I heard, the QCbros were still trying to find the prime factors of 15.

(I remember using quantum algorithms to find prime factors 25 years or more ago, using the Quantum::Suppositions Perl module.)

Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by hsbauauvhabzb on Monday December 29, 2025 @05:00PM (#46426292)
Is there even a push for ECH? I don’t imagine big tech and other powerful players particularly want it.
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by ls612 on Monday December 29, 2025 @08:00PM (#46428209)
Cloudflare and all the major browsers have supported it for a couple years now.
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by hsbauauvhabzb on Tuesday December 30, 2025 @12:40AM (#46429926)
Computers have supported dnssec for years and it’s barely in use. Support != a push for.
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by peter_d_sherman on Monday December 29, 2025 @03:35PM (#46425270)
An excellent point!

Yes, any given domain name (or as non-technical people would think about it, "website" -- any website) could be "blocked" (re-routed to a non-functioning IP, claimed to not exist, other DNS error or malfunction, ?, ???) at any level of DNS (ISP, Local, Regional, Country, ?, ???)

A question your statement so excellently potentially suggests, is:

What's the true extent of the block?

Is it merely a DNS failure -- or are inbound/outbound packets to an IP address actively suppressed and/or modified to prevent TCP/IP connections? (i.e., The Great Firewall Of China, etc.)

You have "Bad Faith Actors" (let's not call them "governments", "countries", "nation states" or even "deep states" -- those terms are so 2024-ish, and as I write this, it's almost 2026! :-) )

Observation: Let's suppose a "Bad Faith Actor" (local or nationwide, foreign or domestic) attempts to block a website. They can accomplish this in one of 3 ways:

1) DNS Block

2) TCP/IP Block, i.e., block TCP/IP4/6 address(es), address ranges, etc.

3) Combination of 1 and 2.

#3 is what would be used if a "Bad Faith Actor" absolutely had to block the "offending" website, no ifs ands or buts!

But... unfortunately for them (and fortunately for us "wee folk"! :-) ), each of these types of blocks comes with problems, problems for them, which I shall heretofore enumerate!

From the perspective of a "Bad Faith Actor":

1) DNS Block -- a mere DNS block of a single domain name is great for granularity that is, it targets that domain name and that domain name alone, and something like this works great when a given company's products and services are directly tied to their website as their brand name (i.e., google.com being blocked in China), but it doesn't work well for fly-by-night websites -- that's because a new domain name pointing to the old IP address can simply be registered...

2) TCP/IP Address / Address Range Block -- The problem with this approach is that while it is more thorough than a simple DNS block, it may also (illegally and unlawfully, I might add!) block legitimate other users, websites and services and businesses which share the same IP or IP address range!

Think about it like this... A long time ago, all of the mail traffic for AOL (America Online), about 600,000 users or so, was coming from a single IP address. Block that IP address, and yes, you've stopped spam from the single user who is annoying you, but you've also (equal-and-oppositely!) blocked 599,999 legitimate users!

So "Bad Faith Actors" -- are "damned if they use the first method, and really damned if they use the second or third methods"... the first method is easily circumventable for non-brand name dependent websites and web services, while the second and third methods risk causing harm to legitimate users, sometimes huge amounts of them... which should be illegal and unlawful by any country's legal standards...

In other words, Countries should read their own sets of laws(!) before contemplating Internet blocks on their Citizens... :-) And not just one country either, all of them!!! :-)

Anyway, an excellent point!

Very thought stimulating -- as you can see by my ramblings! :-)

Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by drnick1 on Monday December 29, 2025 @05:21PM (#46426489)
If this is the case, someone running their own recursive DNS server (like Bind9 or Unbound) can trivially bypass these restrictions. Doing this is a sensible step towards more privacy, regardless of censorship.
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by layer8 on Monday December 29, 2025 @05:25PM (#46426549)
They don’t need to run their own DNS server, just configure a DNS server other than the ISP-provided one, like Quad9 or Google.
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by hdgvhicv on Tuesday December 30, 2025 @03:49AM (#46431019)
Using Google - one of the largest data mining companies out there - rather than my trusted ISP doesn’t sound d like a step towards privacy
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by password4321 on Monday December 29, 2025 @08:28PM (#46428409)
Maybe this is a good place to ask: what is the easiest way to use my own DNS entirely in user mode (not a server when I can't change which DNS is pointed to, since not an admin), a SOCKSv5 proxy?

It looks like this is possible with Chrome-based browsers using a command line flag (--host-resolver-rules) or in Firefox settings. Is there a better way?

Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by pabs3 on Monday December 29, 2025 @11:20PM (#46429499)
If you are on Linux, install unbound and set your DNS server to localhost, done.
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by subscribed on Monday December 29, 2025 @10:06PM (#46429086)
"private DNS". Configure your own (with ad blocking) on nextdns.
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by JohnLocke4 on Monday December 29, 2025 @05:35PM (#46426691)
As a reward for freeing yourself from the de facto government DNS, you will now be gifted free movies for eternity
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by progbits on Monday December 29, 2025 @06:09PM (#46427154)
Regardless of censorship, I don't recommend anyone to use ISP DNS servers. They are often slow, flaky and don't respect record TTLs.

Quad 1/8/9 isn't optimal alternative (too much centralization if everyone uses those by default) but running your own is easy.

Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by SoftTalker on Monday December 29, 2025 @10:17PM (#46429150)
some ISPs make it difficult to use other DNS servers
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by yrand on Tuesday December 30, 2025 @03:15AM (#46430788)
There's DNS over HTTPS they can't viably block, so thankfully they get the short end of the stick here.

edit: Thinking of it, anyone knows if it's possible to use that for OS-wide DNS resolves, not just for the browser?

Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by gmac on Tuesday December 30, 2025 @04:03AM (#46431120)
Yes, on both macOS and Windows 11. On Mac you have to create/use a simple .mobileconfig profile. On Windows you have to separately provide both IPv4 and IPv6 addresses.
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs by snvzz on Tuesday December 30, 2025 @09:00AM (#46433396)
Or set up a forwarder such as unbound(8) in the LAN and set up the network to use it as the DNS server.