Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs
by dilyevsky on Monday December 29, 2025 @05:11PM
(#46426390)
I ready the FortiGate link and this is the gist:
So basically they mess with DoH ECH config and trigger fallback behavior in the clients. I don't think any browsers do this yet but I think this loophole is not gonna last.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I'm surprised that works. Doesn't TLS1.3 do the thing where it crosschecks (a hash of) the setup parameters after key-agreement to protect against exactly this kind of downgrade attack?
(My phone screen is too small to look through the RFCs right now.)
Re:List of domains censored by German ISPs
by dilyevsky on Monday December 29, 2025 @11:19PM
(#46429498)
I think what you're describing is TLS1.3 Finished verification so that happens after DoH response during the actual handshake. Basically this works because ECH is fairly new and there's no HSTS-style "always use ECH for this site" configuration yet. And ofc this only works if you configured FortiGate as your DNS (corp network) or if it's doing MITM (though I'd expect browser would verify cert fingerprint for DoH connections as well).