News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cecot – 60 Minutes by blell on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @09:49AM (#46365708)
Why did you remove the quotes around the word "innocent" that implied sarcasm? You can't quote things and modify the contents.
Re:Cecot – 60 Minutes by estearum on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @10:01AM (#46365782)
In our country, someone who hasn't been convicted or otherwise adjudicated of a crime is called innocent. There are thousands of innocent people being deported.

Perhaps these people committed crimes or administrative violations, perhaps not, but until they've been determined as such, they're correctly called innocent with no quotes.

GP is speaking specifically about that subset of people when they use the word innocent.

Re:Cecot – 60 Minutes by constantcrying on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @10:44AM (#46366216)
>In our country, someone who hasn't been convicted or otherwise adjudicated of a crime is called innocent.

Total nonsense. This only applies to the state. Individuals are totally free to believe that a person not convicted of a crime or even proclaimed innocent by the state, is in fact not innocent.

If your legalistic fiction of innocence was correct, then individuals would have to believe that the law is the infallible representation of morality, which is an abhorrent claim. What I meant by the quotes around innocent is that the state has not yet deemed them criminal, but I disagree with the state on that assessment.

Re:Cecot – 60 Minutes by estearum on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @10:49AM (#46366261)
Is deportation a state action or no?
Re:Cecot – 60 Minutes by constantcrying on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @02:09PM (#46368290)
That is a pretty strange question. A deportation can be performed by practically anyone. It could be the state, and almost always is, but it could also be performed by an individual or a corporation.

But I think what you wanted to ask is whether the determination of immigration status is a state action, which it (obviously) is. You are correct that it is a legal contradiction to deport people whose immigration status has not yet been determined (this is after all something a court may have to decide). My point is that I am in favor of that contradiction not being resolved, because it effectively bypasses the legal system and makes immigration, in any capacity, unappealing, as any immigrant has to be aware that they have to be, at some point, confronted with an extra legal deportation.

Re:Cecot – 60 Minutes by estearum on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @02:15PM (#46368360)
I just cannot imagine how gobsmackingly dumb one has to be to consciously advocate for a government unrestrained by laws.

Just true mud-farmer level intellect.

Re:Cecot – 60 Minutes by constantcrying on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @02:54PM (#46368762)
I am sorry, but "you are dumb" is not an argument. I just do not care about the law at all+. Far too often have I seen justice abused in the name of the law. Any appeal to some supposed legality just rings entirely hollow.

Either the government acts justly and I support their actions or it acts unjustly and I will oppose that action. Whatever some piece of paper says or does not say I do not mind.

+ Of course I care about it in so far I have to understand how getting into conflict with the prevalent interpretation of it will have consequence for me or my family or my friends. I pay my taxes, after all.

Re:Cecot – 60 Minutes by estearum on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @03:08PM (#46368932)
Yeah, this is the opinion of a very stupid person. Have a good day :)
Re:Cecot – 60 Minutes by doganugurlu on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @05:35PM (#46370286)
You disagree in a “none of us are innocent” kind of way?

I struggle to see how you might know so much about these people - whose names we don’t even know - that you can have an opinion about their innocence.

No need to respond if you don’t think you need information to form an opinion. I will assume that.

Re:Cecot – 60 Minutes by SV_BubbleTime on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @01:09PM (#46367586)
> There are thousands of innocent people being deported.

Right, the only crime they committed was entering and remaining in the country illegally. And now they’re facing deportation by this unjust administration.

Re:Cecot – 60 Minutes by estearum on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @01:35PM (#46367905)
There are plenty of people the administration is trying to deport who neither entered nor remained in the country illegally.

For example, Rumeysa Ozturk who was arrested for engaging in 1st Amendment protected speech and put into deportation proceedings despite entering the country legally, staying in the country legally, and breaking none of our country's laws.

Re:Cecot – 60 Minutes by constantcrying on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @02:11PM (#46368317)
Do you think that such a deportation would make the US more or less appealing for immigration? After all, every immigrant has to suspect that they might become a target of such an enforcement action as well.
Re:Cecot – 60 Minutes by estearum on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @02:13PM (#46368336)
Of course it would make the US less appealing, which means the immigrants with the most optionality of where to go (like researchers, engineers, and high value contributors in general) are disproportionately likely to seek other destinations.

It would have the least deterrent force on those who are already criminal and otherwise lawless or desperate.

Back to your claim about this being an "effective" immigration policy: no it's not.

Re:Cecot – 60 Minutes by constantcrying on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @02:44PM (#46368649)
I think it is pretty dishonest how you are asserting that I am making arguments, which I never made.

>which means the immigrants with the most optionality of where to go (like researchers, engineers, and high value contributors in general) are disproportionately likely to seek other destinations.

>It would have the least deterrent force on those who are already criminal and otherwise lawless or desperate.

Completely agree. But I want the "researchers, engineers, and high value contributors" even less than the rest. Those groups are actually harder to remove, they often have institutional support in the form of corporations and other associations and might feasibly be positive fiscal contributors. With "the rest" the argument for deportation is far simpler and has far more support in the population. Also my labor competes with the "researchers, engineers, and high value contributors", while "the rest" only depresses the wages of the proletariat who now have to compete with black market labor.

Re:Cecot – 60 Minutes by estearum on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @02:47PM (#46368684)
Huh? Your original comment was stating that the Trump admin has demonstrated what an effective immigration policy looks like.

As for the rest of your comment: lol, lmao even

As mentioned in the other thread: mud-farmer zero sum thinking.

Re:Cecot – 60 Minutes by fzeroracer on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @02:39PM (#46368593)
Notably, deporting US citizens would also make the US less appealing for immigration. Would you agree with that? Since fewer people would want to travel to a country where even its own citizens are not safe living there.

Considering your other arguments above, I assume you are also volunteering to be one of the people deported from the EU for the sake of making it less appealing for immigration?

Re:Cecot – 60 Minutes by constantcrying on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @05:50PM (#46370421)
I am sure that my vitriol against immigration more than makes up for me (having no "immigration background" at all) continuing to stay in the EU :P
Re:Cecot – 60 Minutes by doganugurlu on Tuesday December 23, 2025 @05:30PM (#46370239)
Right leaning Cato Institute’s report states that many had entered legally and had no criminal records in US or in their home countries.

In fact, some were granted asylum.

Re:Cecot – 60 Minutes by SV_BubbleTime on Wednesday December 24, 2025 @10:56AM (#46376634)
A VISA overstay is entering legally. Most deportations per year have always been because of overstay, IDK if that is true this year.
Re:Cecot – 60 Minutes by estearum on Wednesday December 24, 2025 @03:12PM (#46378816)
The Cato article says specifically that nearly half the people they were able to get in touch with didn’t seem to enter illegally OR otherwise violate their immigration status
Re:Cecot – 60 Minutes by SV_BubbleTime on Wednesday December 24, 2025 @05:35PM (#46380004)
If your claim is that American citizens are being deported - say that. Don’t hide behind a source you would never use with a vague non-cited claim.

If you think this is an issue you should easily be able to find dozens of cases.

Re:Cecot – 60 Minutes by estearum on Thursday December 25, 2025 @12:03PM (#46385615)
Huh? Do you think the possible legal statuses of people in the US is either “here illegally” or “US citizen?”

My claim is quite clear: legal immigrants who have not committed any crime or administrative violations have 1) been deported, 2) without due process, and 3) to a foreign torture camp.

Any ONE of those elements is illegal with regard to legal immigrants, and items 2 and 3 are illegal even with regard solely to illegal immigrants.

Btw this is not including people whose TPS was canceled and were “made illegal” overnight, of which there are hundreds of thousands now.

https://www.cato.org/blog/50-venezuelans-imprisoned-el-salva...