But I think what you wanted to ask is whether the determination of immigration status is a state action, which it (obviously) is. You are correct that it is a legal contradiction to deport people whose immigration status has not yet been determined (this is after all something a court may have to decide). My point is that I am in favor of that contradiction not being resolved, because it effectively bypasses the legal system and makes immigration, in any capacity, unappealing, as any immigrant has to be aware that they have to be, at some point, confronted with an extra legal deportation.
Just true mud-farmer level intellect.
Either the government acts justly and I support their actions or it acts unjustly and I will oppose that action. Whatever some piece of paper says or does not say I do not mind.
+ Of course I care about it in so far I have to understand how getting into conflict with the prevalent interpretation of it will have consequence for me or my family or my friends. I pay my taxes, after all.
I struggle to see how you might know so much about these people - whose names we don’t even know - that you can have an opinion about their innocence.
No need to respond if you don’t think you need information to form an opinion. I will assume that.
Total nonsense. This only applies to the state. Individuals are totally free to believe that a person not convicted of a crime or even proclaimed innocent by the state, is in fact not innocent.
If your legalistic fiction of innocence was correct, then individuals would have to believe that the law is the infallible representation of morality, which is an abhorrent claim. What I meant by the quotes around innocent is that the state has not yet deemed them criminal, but I disagree with the state on that assessment.