https://pages.nist.gov/800-63-4/sp800-63b.html#passwordver
> Verifiers and CSPs SHALL NOT require subscribers to change passwords periodically. However, verifiers SHALL force a change if there is evidence that the authenticator has been compromised.
One of the nice cases where it can be helpful that standards themselves, which you can point to, have said to stop doing that.
I wrote an authentication platform used by a few govt agencies. The irony is all my defaults match NIST guidelines (including haveibeenpwned lookup on password set/change), but needed to support the typical overrides for other hard requirements that tend to come from such agencies in practice.
> though not strictly matching NIST, some ops find a never require change hard to swallow.
I think they're right about that. A scheduled change just represents the accumulating probability that there's been a compromise somewhere that didn't come to your attention.
It seems like it would make more sense for a scheduled change to affect all passwords at once, though.
This only works if that's the only standard they're adhering to. At my employer, the password changes are mandated by their "cyber insurance" policy which hasn't caught up with the times.
That did not leave me a strong impression of "cyber insurance policies". I suppose it also did leave me wondering how much we've left very small businesses behind in security as a culture.
Every now and again I ponder if I'm happy where I'm at careerwise, and then something like this reminds me that I have the authority to make these decisions, and I decide that yeah, I like being me.
I think this is more the realm of using windows hello or apple touchid (AFAIK no good, simple, standard built-in way exists for linux distros) to get the first OS login and then you can use your password manager when you are logged into the OS.
Everytime I've tried its been finicky and had to use non-standard tools to get it working.
Windows Hello serves the same purpose for Windows, though I'm sure there are caveats/differences.
1. It must be hard for a computer to guess.
2. It must be easy for a human to remember. If you can not set a secure password and then remember it a week later it is a bad password.
This is why I really hate overly strict password requirements that make it hard to remember. These cause people to write it down or do things that appease the password checker but don't make it harder to guess.
There are cases where a password manager may not solve the problem, though. It doesn't help if I forget my disk encryption or work AD password and I need to be able to login before I can get to the password manager in the first place. Enterprise IT is also where you find some of those frustrating password policies, such as long and complex passwords with mandated changes every month or two, and where you usually can't choose your management tools.
Of course those particular passwords usually get typed so often that remembering them isn't much of a problem. And password managers work well for pretty much all secrets that aren't needed that often.
Although: be careful of cloud solutions
Aside: still hate working in orgs where you have a password reset multiple times a year... I tend to use some relatively long passphrases, if not the strongest possible... (ex: "ThisHasMyNewPassphrase%#23") I just need to be able to remember it through the first weekend each time I change without forgetting the phrase I used.