News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rivian Unveils Custom Silicon, R2 Lidar Roadmap, and Univ... by bjord on Thursday December 11, 2025 @01:34PM (#46235138)
is everyone designing their own silicon getting so much additional them-specific utility out of it that it's actually worth it?
Re:Rivian Unveils Custom Silicon, R2 Lidar Roadmap, and Univ... by darth_avocado on Thursday December 11, 2025 @01:40PM (#46235215)
Rivian has a huge interest in being the outsourcer for legacy automakers. They’re not able to sell $100k cars enough and even with the promised R2, they probably will only be a small-ish player in the EV market. Their CEO recognizes how crazy good Chinese EVs are and currently they’re not even a competitor for Tesla.

But, VW is willing to pay $5B for their software platform. I think they want to extend that to being able to sell custom chips and “AI” capabilities, whatever that means.

Re:Rivian Unveils Custom Silicon, R2 Lidar Roadmap, and Univ... by igor47 on Thursday December 11, 2025 @01:52PM (#46235424)
Which honestly is crazy to me. I have a Rivian, and to say the software is disappointing would be an understatement. There are heisenbugs galore; some examples:

* Doors refuse to open

* Lose the ability to control media playback using any controls

* Any button in the UI just opens and closes the windows

Granted, I'm a server side/backend engineer mostly, and I don't know much about writing software/firmware for a very hostile emf environment. But if any project I worked on had bugs like this, fixed at the rate they're fixed on Rivian, I would assume a badly flawed architecture or non existent technical leadership

Yet VW paid billions for this very software. I can't imagine how bad it must've been on their own stack that they gave up and bought this other seemingly broken stack

Re:Rivian Unveils Custom Silicon, R2 Lidar Roadmap, and Univ... by WaxProlix on Thursday December 11, 2025 @01:56PM (#46235507)
This sounds nothing like my experience, you should get that vehicle serviced.
Re:Rivian Unveils Custom Silicon, R2 Lidar Roadmap, and Univ... by Hovertruck on Thursday December 11, 2025 @03:22PM (#46236624)
Same, I've had mine for a couple of years now with no notable software issues at all.
Re:Rivian Unveils Custom Silicon, R2 Lidar Roadmap, and Univ... by amluto on Thursday December 11, 2025 @07:33PM (#46239416)
Service can’t do anything about the state machine being wrong.

The Rivian app does not permit you to send a command to the car while the app thinks the car is processing a command. Trunk opening? You can’t unlock the door. On top of this, if you try to open the trunk while outside Bluetooth range and then Bluetooth connects, you are still stuck waiting for the pending command to complete.

Oh, and the ridiculous “hey let’s always remind you that you own a Rivian” Live Activity seems to synchronize on a schedule that involves being hours and hours out of date.

The Rivian app sucks.

Re:Rivian Unveils Custom Silicon, R2 Lidar Roadmap, and Univ... by WaxProlix on Thursday December 11, 2025 @09:51PM (#46240340)
I agree that the app leaves something to be desired - my personal pet peeve is that it shows stale or cached data while waiting to do some async update, leading to just outright fabricated charge or lock state. Never had those kinds of problems with the truck's software proper though
Re:Rivian Unveils Custom Silicon, R2 Lidar Roadmap, and Univ... by cryptoegorophy on Friday December 12, 2025 @11:19AM (#46245584)
Why can’t they just copy Tesla? Chinese manufacturers do just that and skip the hard steps
Re:Rivian Unveils Custom Silicon, R2 Lidar Roadmap, and Univ... by Robdel12 on Friday December 12, 2025 @09:12AM (#46244310)
This comment is pretty funny to me, as a car guy. What’s there to service? It’s a software issue.
Re:Rivian Unveils Custom Silicon, R2 Lidar Roadmap, and Univ... by zamadatix on Friday December 12, 2025 @09:48AM (#46244643)
Presumably, but you don't really known until you pay to take it in for service and they tell you there is nothing wrong but they don't have a fix (gee, great experience). On the "know it's software" side e.g. I had what appeared to be random issues with audio crackling on my PC I assumed was software/driver related, it turned out there was a faulty USB hub causing an issues for the whole bus but it was just most apparent in the audio device.

Stuff like "Doors refuse to open" is vague enough it could be a similar kind of issue which needs physical service/replacement rather than just a software update, especially if other buttons are triggering completely separate actions with the windows. Or it could very well be 100% software issues, which could be more apparent with additional details like "only does it after transitioning from this screen or pressing things in this order" type problems.

Re:Rivian Unveils Custom Silicon, R2 Lidar Roadmap, and Univ... by WaxProlix on Friday December 12, 2025 @04:26PM (#46249173)
As a car guy you should know that there's tech in cars these days. Or do you calibrate everything from tpms monitors to re pointing/tunes in your garage?

If something's wrong with your car's head unit firmware or android auto connection or whatever, of course you'd have a technician look at it?

Re:Rivian Unveils Custom Silicon, R2 Lidar Roadmap, and Univ... by Robdel12 on Saturday December 13, 2025 @08:58AM (#46254535)
> Or do you calibrate everything from tpms monitors to re pointing/tunes in your garage?

Pretty much, yeah. I race SCCA and build race cars. Exactly why I want nothing to do with these, you don’t own it. You’re leasing the hardware that’s hogtied to the software.

Re:Rivian Unveils Custom Silicon, R2 Lidar Roadmap, and Univ... by WaxProlix on Saturday December 13, 2025 @11:55AM (#46255961)
Oh man, you're in for a bad time then, as pretty much everything - yes even amateur racing cars - has software in it now, and you don't own any of it.

As a car guy, it surprises me you weren't aware of this trend yet but I guess we all find out sooner or later. But hey - maybe that '89 Carrera will keep on trucking for a few more decades though - good luck!

Re:Rivian Unveils Custom Silicon, R2 Lidar Roadmap, and Univ... by igor47 on Friday December 19, 2025 @03:27PM (#46330488)
You're not wrong, but I am still sad about this trend. Especially the "you don't own any of it" part. I always think about this:

https://theoutline.com/post/1398/why-can-t-karen-sandler-get...

Re:Rivian Unveils Custom Silicon, R2 Lidar Roadmap, and Univ... by Robdel12 on Thursday December 25, 2025 @11:46AM (#46385476)
I love these replies, hahah. You really think I’m not aware of the software that’s running my 2017 Shelby? The difference is (you know this, I think you’re being purposely obtuse) it’s never connected to the internet, it’s never getting updates, and it’s not a complete car OS that locks you out of doing anything.

I think you might be the one needing the luck

Re:Rivian Unveils Custom Silicon, R2 Lidar Roadmap, and Univ... by roguecoder on Monday December 15, 2025 @11:10AM (#46276366)
I have seen issues like that. Rebooting has always fixed it, but it is notable.

I really wish they would hire a strong frontend team. I can almost always figure out what happened just from the signal, and it's usually a state machine getting stuck. Which I have some sympathy for, but also you just can't have that happen in something that is going to feel polished and responsive.

Re:Rivian Unveils Custom Silicon, R2 Lidar Roadmap, and Univ... by mbesto on Thursday December 11, 2025 @08:02PM (#46239649)
I own a Rivian too, and previously owned a Tesla. While I too have my gripes about the UX on the Rivian, it still beats the cr*p out of a Tesla.
Re:Rivian Unveils Custom Silicon, R2 Lidar Roadmap, and Univ... by Rover222 on Friday December 12, 2025 @10:31AM (#46245064)
Just curious in what ways, since you've actually owned both. I've only had Teslas, but I like the looks of Rivians.
Re:Rivian Unveils Custom Silicon, R2 Lidar Roadmap, and Univ... by mbesto on Monday December 15, 2025 @10:39AM (#46275889)
Tesla UX gripes (may be specific to Model S 2020):

- Yolk steering is terrible

- Lack of physical knobs. Haptics are nice but haptics don't work well for cars.

- Tesla menus are getting stuffed more and more with options, making affordance and UI crowding much worse

- The horn is a button press...no one in a emergency situation is looking for a button press..

- Native apps (for example Spotify) are inferior to just using my phone via bluetooth

- Calendar integration / notification is too chatty

Re:Rivian Unveils Custom Silicon, R2 Lidar Roadmap, and Univ... by m463 on Friday December 12, 2025 @03:58AM (#46242211)
stuff like that happens with tesla.

one funny one is that periodically you can trigger the "more cowbell" rainbow road easter egg. You can cancel the road animation, but you can't cancel the easter egg music or control the volume.

Re:Rivian Unveils Custom Silicon, R2 Lidar Roadmap, and Univ... by thomasjb on Thursday December 11, 2025 @02:30PM (#46236036)
Possibly. Realistically this is replacing the expensive category of FPGA (Zynqs or similar with strong hardware CPU cores), this means they get all the peripherals they desire in hardware, and they can pick the core variant in order to optimise for their workloads (all the different vector extensions for example). There's an interesting market for that kind of thing, either full FPGA to ASIC replacement, or drop in replacement FPGAs of lower cost (The Rigol MHO98 replaced the Xilinx FPGA of the previous generation with a substitute from Fudan). If you're shipping a lot of hardware, that sort of thing becomes worthwhile.
Re:Rivian Unveils Custom Silicon, R2 Lidar Roadmap, and Univ... by wmf on Thursday December 11, 2025 @10:58PM (#46240740)
Nope, it's replacing Orin.
Re:Rivian Unveils Custom Silicon, R2 Lidar Roadmap, and Univ... by potatolicious on Thursday December 11, 2025 @02:03PM (#46235625)
I share your skepticism. This feels like an attempt to tap the trainloads of money piling into "AI", for a company that is in pretty desperate need of more cash to stay alive.

In a vacuum there are potentially some advantages to doing your own silicon, especially if your goal is to sell the platform to other automakers as an OEM.

But custom silicon is pricey as hell (if you're doing anything non-trivial, at least), and the payoffs have a long lead time. For a company that's bleeding cash aggressively, with a short runway, to engage in this seems iffy. This sort of move makes a lot more sense if Rivian was an established maker that's cash-flow positive and is looking to cement their long-term lead with free cash flow. Buuuuut they aren't that.

Re:Rivian Unveils Custom Silicon, R2 Lidar Roadmap, and Univ... by bickfordb on Thursday December 11, 2025 @01:53PM (#46235434)
I have the same question. It makes sense that they might need bespoke software, but how could they possibly be more efficient at creating chips than an AMD/Nvidia?
Re:Rivian Unveils Custom Silicon, R2 Lidar Roadmap, and Univ... by slashdave on Thursday December 11, 2025 @01:57PM (#46235518)
Well, if AMD and/or Nvidia were to invest on a chip for an auto, maybe you might have a point.
Re:Rivian Unveils Custom Silicon, R2 Lidar Roadmap, and Univ... by riotnrrd on Thursday December 11, 2025 @02:04PM (#46235636)
NVIDIA has been selling automotive-specific silicon for a decade.
Re:Rivian Unveils Custom Silicon, R2 Lidar Roadmap, and Univ... by AlotOfReading on Thursday December 11, 2025 @02:16PM (#46235821)
Both AMD and Nvidia have strong automotive offerings.
Re:Rivian Unveils Custom Silicon, R2 Lidar Roadmap, and Univ... by ShakataGaNai on Thursday December 11, 2025 @04:30PM (#46237423)
I would wager that's because there isn't a lot of existing silicon that fits the bill. What COTS equipment is there that has all the CPU/Tensor horsepower these systems need... AND is reasonably power efficient AND is rated for a vehicle (wild temp extremes like -20F to 150F+, constant vibration, slams and impacts... and will keep working for 15 years).

Yea, Tesla has some. But they aren't sharing their secret sauce. You can't just throw a desktop computer in a car and expect it to survive for the duration. Ford et all aren't anywhere close to having "premium silicon".

So you're only option right now is to build your own. And hope maybe that you can sell/license your designs to others later and make bucks.

Re:Rivian Unveils Custom Silicon, R2 Lidar Roadmap, and Univ... by typewithrhythm on Thursday December 11, 2025 @04:42PM (#46237582)
NVIDIA orin series is the big one for tensor horsepower. Horizon robotics and Qualcomm also have competitive automotive packages.

They are all expensive, but less than the risk adjusted cost of developing a chip.

Re:Rivian Unveils Custom Silicon, R2 Lidar Roadmap, and Univ... by pstuart on Thursday December 11, 2025 @05:34PM (#46238253)
Isn't that risk balanced by a healthy reward of controlling their verticals and possible secret sauce?

And their chips give "1600 sparse INT8 TOPS" vs the Orin's "more than 1,000 INT8 TOPS" -- so comparable enough? And going forward they can tailor it to exactly what they want?

Re:Rivian Unveils Custom Silicon, R2 Lidar Roadmap, and Univ... by AlotOfReading on Thursday December 11, 2025 @07:59PM (#46239625)
Orin is Nvidia's last generation. Current gen is Thor at 1k TOPS. Rivian's announcement specifies TOPS at the module level. The actual chip is more like 800 and probably doubled. Throw two Thors on a similar board and you're looking at 2000 sparse int8 TOPS.

I've been involved with similar efforts on both sides before. Making your own hardware is not a clear cut win even if you hit timelines and performance. I wish them luck (not least because I might need a new job someday), but this is an incredibly difficult space.

Re:Rivian Unveils Custom Silicon, R2 Lidar Roadmap, and Univ... by typewithrhythm on Thursday December 11, 2025 @07:15PM (#46239282)
Mostly it costs hundreds of millions to develop a chip; it relies on volume to recover the cost.

NVIDIA also tailor their chips to customers. It's a more scalable platform than their marketing hints at... Not to mention that they also iterate fairly quickly.

So far anyway, being on a specialised architecture is a disadvantage; it's much easier to use the advances that come from research and competitors. Unless you really think that you are ahead of the completion, and can sell some fairly inflexible solution for a while.

Re:Rivian Unveils Custom Silicon, R2 Lidar Roadmap, and Univ... by rangestransform on Thursday December 11, 2025 @08:32PM (#46239842)
Having to work with Qualcomm is enough reason to not buy Qualcomm
Re:Rivian Unveils Custom Silicon, R2 Lidar Roadmap, and Univ... by ChuckMcM on Thursday December 11, 2025 @04:54PM (#46237737)
I was just in a discussion on this very topic. It's the build vs buy equation applied to silicon. Early in the tech boom the entire silicon stack was proprietary and required a lot of time and investment to train up people who could design the circuitry, we got our first "ASICS" which was basically a bunch of circuitry on a die and you then added your own metal layer so it was like having a bunch of components glued to a board and you could "customize" it by putting wires between the parts. Then we had fabs that needed more wafer starts so they started doing other peoples designs which required they standardize their cells and provide integration services (you brought a design and they mapped it to their standard cells and process). And as the density kept going up they kept having loots of free space they needed to fill up. The 'fabless' chip companies continued to invest in making new parts until the pipeline was pretty smooth. And at that point the level of training you needed a the origin to get it into silicon dropped to nearly zero, you just needed the designs. And into that space people who were neither 'chip' companies, nor were they 'fabless' OEMs, realized they could get their integration needs met by asking a company to make them a chip that did exactly what they wanted.

One the business side, the economics are fabulous, your competitors can't "clone" your product if they don't have your special sauce components. So in many ways it becomes a strategic advantage to maintaining your market position.

But all of that because the all up cost to go from specification to parts meeting the specification dropped into the range where you could build special parts and still price at the market for your finished product.

A really interesting illustration is to look at disk drive controller boards from the Shugart Associates ST-506 (5MB) drive, to Seagate's current offerings. It is illustrative because disk drives are a product that has been ruthlessly economized because of low margins. The ST-506 is all TTL logic and standard analog parts, and yet current products have semiconductor parts that are made exactly to Seagate's design specs and aren't sold to anyone else.

So to answer your question; apparently the economics work out. The costs associated with designing, testing, and packaging your own silicon appears to be cost effective even on products with exceptionally tight margins, it is likely a clear winner on a product that enjoys the margins that electric vehicles offer.

Re:Rivian Unveils Custom Silicon, R2 Lidar Roadmap, and Univ... by bjord on Friday December 12, 2025 @02:50AM (#46241843)
very interesting. thanks for sharing!