News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AeroFS is x87 faster than Dropbox in LAN syncing [video] by sepbot on Sunday October 07, 2012 @10:33AM (#4623388)
People often misunderstand what the Dropbox LAN Sync does. The file needs to be already in the cloud before it can be synced over LAN. This means that when you add a new file, it will first get uploaded to Dropbox servers then transferred to other computers over LAN. Considering that most home connections are asynchronous (slow up, fast down) the entire processes gets bottle-necked by that slow upload rate.
Re:AeroFS is x87 faster than Dropbox in LAN syncing [video] by rarrrrrr on Sunday October 07, 2012 @10:54AM (#4623431)
This is also how SpiderOak's LAN sync works. Both Dropbox and SpiderOak guarantee that the single point of truth is the cloud, for good reason.

Making exceptions to that approach (like allowing individual machines to sync with eachother directly before transferring to the cloud) creates opportunities for conflicts and inconsistencies that are very difficult to resolve because all the information might not be available.

Re:AeroFS is x87 faster than Dropbox in LAN syncing [video] by dfc on Sunday October 07, 2012 @12:45PM (#4623664)
Your second paragraph reads like a defense of CVS. git-annex handles this fine for me on my network at home with multiple machines and multiple copies of the repository/archive/drop-box-folder on each machine.
Re:AeroFS is x87 faster than Dropbox in LAN syncing [video] by lucian1900 on Sunday October 07, 2012 @01:03PM (#4623713)
With any VCS, commits are explicit. Dropbox and the like need implicit sync.
Re:AeroFS is x87 faster than Dropbox in LAN syncing [video] by dfc on Sunday October 07, 2012 @01:12PM (#4623742)
Are you familiar with git-annex and its helpful assistant?
Re:AeroFS is x87 faster than Dropbox in LAN syncing [video] by lucian1900 on Monday October 08, 2012 @05:02AM (#4626052)
While it looks cool, it seems to me that it isn't entirely automatic. Sadly the vast majority of people will not go for anything less automatic than Dropbox.
Re:AeroFS is x87 faster than Dropbox in LAN syncing [video] by dfc on Monday October 08, 2012 @05:23PM (#4628800)
"any changes you make to its folder will automatically be committed to git, and synced to repositories on other computers." [1]

I guess its not automatic in the sense that it does not install itself, but then again neither does dropbox...

[1] http://git-annex.branchable.com/assistant/

Re:AeroFS is x87 faster than Dropbox in LAN syncing [video] by gvb on Sunday October 07, 2012 @11:51AM (#4623542)
Nitpicky, but you meant the typical home internet service is asymmetrical, not asynchronous.
Re:AeroFS is x87 faster than Dropbox in LAN syncing [video] by cool-RR on Sunday October 07, 2012 @10:47AM (#4623415)
You've given an excellent answer to the question Why is Dropbox's LAN Sync so slow? but the more interesting question is Why don't the Dropbox engineers change how LAN Sync works so it won't be so slow anymore?
Re:AeroFS is x87 faster than Dropbox in LAN syncing [video] by yskchu on Sunday October 07, 2012 @12:11PM (#4623582)
+1

Also, uploading the data to Dropbox server, and then downloading again, wastes valuable quota for those under a data cap.

Re:AeroFS is x87 faster than Dropbox in LAN syncing [video] by Dylan16807 on Sunday October 07, 2012 @02:36PM (#4623956)
No, it doesn't download it from the master server. It transfers directly between the computers on the LAN. The only thing that has to go through the Dropbox servers is the master file list.
Re:AeroFS is x87 faster than Dropbox in LAN syncing [video] by CJefferson on Sunday October 07, 2012 @12:16PM (#4623587)
I can understand why, particularly given Dropbox's aim of being as simple as it can possibly be. At the moment the rule is simple. At the moment the cloud can be relied on as the authorative copy which everyone syncs with. If I have 3 or more local clients, all talking and sharing over LAN, many issues get very complicated.
Re:AeroFS is x87 faster than Dropbox in LAN syncing [video] by mnutt on Sunday October 07, 2012 @12:33PM (#4623626)
It seems like it could be mitigated by having the client hash the file and notify the cloud of the hash of the file it intends to upload first. But I think your explanation for why they don't currently do LAN-only sharing is correct.
Re:AeroFS is x87 faster than Dropbox in LAN syncing [video] by Dylan16807 on Sunday October 07, 2012 @02:39PM (#4623962)
It does do that; I don't understand what you think it'll fix when it comes to multiple clients.

Do you want Dropbox to make a ghost entry with the contents and the hash, then start transferring it over LAN right away? That's going to be confusing when a ghosted file doesn't behave the same as a normal unsynced file. Especially if you start doing collaborative work and the version history is broken because that's cloud-based.

Re:AeroFS is x87 faster than Dropbox in LAN syncing [video] by rogerbinns on Sunday October 07, 2012 @01:33PM (#4623803)
Note that technically the file contents don't need to be in the cloud, but rather the metadata and indexing do. I'm guessing that the indexing is how Dropbox breaks the file into blocks, checksums them and does some form of duplicate detection to save on storage costs.