News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by giraffe_lady on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @10:46AM (#46219072)
All of the arguments I've seen supporting this attack focus on the idea that it's fine to kill and maim civilians including children as long as you will probably get some combatants. It's a little bit open to interpretation, I guess, and I'm not a legal expert so fine, ok.

But booby trapping mundane daily objects accessible to non-combatants is a clear violation of international law. No real room for leeway or interpretation on that one either.

[dead]
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by giraffe_lady on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @11:03AM (#46219353)
> the person with the pager was exercising poor operational security and letting someone else handle their pager.

So? You aren't off the hook because someone did something unexpected or "was exercising poor operational security."

You can do this to anything lol this logic goes wherever you need it to. A car bomb is simply an attack on hezbollah movement capabilities. Anything used by a hezbollah member is no longer a mundane object and so can be booby trapped. A terrorist is a person we treat like a terrorist, our killing you is proof of your guilt.

[dead]
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by scarecrowbob on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @11:54AM (#46220104)
I believe that folks write things like you're writing because they cannot imagine a world where they would be subject to the violence they are describing.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by wasabi991011 on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @02:21PM (#46222271)
> So? You aren't off the hook because someone did something unexpected or "was exercising poor operational security."

You might be. If it was Hezbollah's guns that exploded and not their pagers, I would expect most people to agree that you would be "off the hook" if someone else was handling that gun.

Not saying pagers = guns, but it's a spectrum surely.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by ok_dad on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @01:53PM (#46221843)
> letting someone else handle their pager

I guess you've never given your phone to your toddler for 2 minutes to watch a video while you pooped in a public bathroom, huh?

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by dralley on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @01:56PM (#46221891)
A pager is not a phone. Pagers and portable radios are not multi-purpose devices. You can't watch Frozen on a pager.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by ok_dad on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @02:29PM (#46222396)
Kids love to grab anything that is interesting to them.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by breppp on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @02:54PM (#46222801)
you are right, however I was never a member of an organization that killed and kidnapped journalists/politicians/diplomats/ordinary civilians, is a regular part of the international drug trade, killed hundreds of american and french soldiers and just started a war with its very pissed technologically advanced neighbor

If I would choose a career in an international terror organization, I'd might quit it once I had children

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by ok_dad on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @03:16PM (#46223125)
Well, I guess we disagree on this, but I think it's a shit move to blow up a bunch of any object that is normally benign and which could logically be sitting next to or in the hands of an innocent. I'll die on that hill. I know it goes against most people's opinions on HN but I don't mind that. As you can see, I have some points to spare so feel free to downvote me to oblivion, even though that downvote button is meant for people who go against the rules; I don't believe I have in any of my posts in this thread, but I am willing to apologize if so.

Also, I have a thought for you: what would you call it if a foreign nation which your country had poor relations with, possibly open hostility, had blown up the work laptops (which they might take home) of a bunch of high ranking military members in your country? Would that be terrorism or a legal attack to you? What would you think of the innocent lives lost to such an attack?

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by apical_dendrite on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @04:23PM (#46224062)
This incident did not occur in a vacuum. If this had been a surprise attack during peacetime, the calculus would be different, but it wasn't.

Hezbollah began firing rockets at Israeli civilian populations more or less indiscriminately very soon after the October 7th terrorist attack. Just a few months before the pager incident, a Hezbollah rocket killed 12 children in a Druze town in the Golan Heights.

Israel was justified in defending itself against an aggressor. Not to do so would mean continuing to let their civilians be killed. Once you start from that premise, then blowing up pagers that only belong to Hezbollah members is a much better option than any alternative.

The standard can't just be "you aren't allowed to take any action that could kill innocent people". To have that as the standard is the same as to have no standard at all, because it's so unrealistic that nobody would follow it. The standard has to take into account whether the action is offensive or defensive, what the relative risk of killing innocent people is, and what the alternatives are.

That's why I talked about the allied bombings during WWII, which killed enormous numbers of German and Japanese civilians. To suggest that the allies should not have used bombers in, say, 1941 because they would inevitably kill many civilians is unreasonable. But you can distinguish between, say, the RAFs nighttime bombing campaigns, which were intended to strike civilian targets for the purposes of demoralizing and starving the population, and the USAAFs daytime bombing campaigns, which were intended to destroy factories. Both killed many, many innocent people, but there are clear moral differences.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by cholantesh on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @03:23PM (#46223228)
I too, wouldn't join the IDF.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by BobaFloutist on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @01:14PM (#46221252)
The prohibitions on booby-traps are that they're indiscriminant, not that they involve mundane objects.

I totally get the instinct to condemn the attack, since it's truly, deeply viscerally horrifying (not to mention terrifying!), but most of the rules about how you're supposed to conduct war basically boil down to 1. Make a reasonable effort to avoid disproportionately harming civilians 2. Don't go out of your way to inflict pain and suffering on your enemy beyond what's a necessary part of trying to kill or neutralize them 3. If your enemy is completely at your mercy, you have an extra duty to uphold 1 and 2.

Again, the pager attack is new, unusual, and just very upsetting. But it harmed civilians at a remarkably low rate, and the method of harm wasn't meaningfully more painful than just shooting someone. It compares very favorably with just bombing people on every metric other than maybe how scary it is if you're a combatant.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by phantasmish on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @03:43PM (#46223527)
Given the apparently-terrible injury-to-death ratio, another angle to attack the legality of the action might be that the weapons were first and foremost effective at maiming, not killing, which is generally frowned upon by the laws of war (if they were intended as lethal, their success on that front was so bad it might fall into "guilty through incompetence" sort of territory)

(I agree the targeting per se seems to have been remarkably good for the world of asynchronous warfare—or even conventional warfare)

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by BobaFloutist on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @07:18PM (#46226010)
>the weapons were first and foremost effective at maiming, not killing, which is generally frowned upon by the laws of war

Can you cite something for this? Most people would rather be (even permanently) injured than killed, so I'm not sure why using the minimum necessary force would be frowned upon, other than it typically being incredibly difficult and impractical.

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by FridayoLeary on Wednesday December 10, 2025 @05:58PM (#46225202)
What would you prefer? Israeli tanks blowing their way through families and bombing beirut to rubble to get at the Hezbolla terrorists? War was inevitable, the amazing actions of the mossad mitigated hundreds if not thousands of civilian casualties. What is your complaint, that they booby trapped the communications devices used exclusively by Hezbolla and not, i don't know, their kalashnikovs?

Don't hide behind technicalities of international law, tell me literally what else they could possibly have done with a better outcome. (please note in my world view, unlike many other people here, Israel rolling over and dying is not an acceptable solution)

Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by giraffe_lady on Friday December 12, 2025 @02:58PM (#46248118)
Probably most of the people who have done terrorism or war crimes would also claim they didn't have any alternatives. It's not my role to find alternatives to terrorism or war crimes, I am just a person on the internet pointing out that terrorism or war crimes have been done.
Re:Israel Used Palantir Technologies in Pager Terrorist Atta... by kyboren on Friday December 12, 2025 @07:46PM (#46250838)
You have that luxury. Israel doesn't.

With civilians under constant rocket and ATGM fire (actual, real war crimes BTW), under threat of Oct 7th-style infiltration and invasion, with tens of thousands of civilians displaced and numerous civilian casualties, Hezbollah had forced this war upon Israel. And they forced it on Oct 8th, in coordination with the IRGC and Iran's "Ring of Fire" proxies.

Israel had a legitimate right to self defense and any country in Israel's position would be obligated to defend their citizens from such aggression. And any objective observer would admit that Hezbollah's actions went beyond mere casus belli to just simply open war--including constant actual war crimes--against Israel.

So Israel had not just a right to wage war against Hezbollah, but a duty. The next question is: How best to prosecute the war?

The traditional prosecution of this war would have resulted in tens of thousands, if not hundreds of thousands of civilian casualties. These exquisitely targeted small (3g of PETN) explosions short-circuited that war and undoubtedly saved thousands of innocent lives.

Far from terrorism or war crimes, these attacks indirectly saved many innocent lives, spared hundreds of billions of dollars worth of Lebanese infrastructure, were highly targeted at combatants, and even direct civilian casualties were minimal.