News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jakarta Is Now the Biggest City in the World by bugglebeetle on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @11:17PM (#46054152)
Japanese actually has a much smaller set of phonemes (~half as many as English), resulting in extensive homophones. When combined with its greater tendency toward ambiguity, correct use of pitch can actually have a larger impact on intelligibility, as compared to many other languages.
Re:Jakarta Is Now the Biggest City in the World by throwaway2037 on Wednesday November 26, 2025 @12:23AM (#46054439)
I swear there must an LLM that posts these types of replies. No matter what anyone says about Japan language or culture, someone will pop into the conversation with "acckkkshually...".

I can tell you from (thousands of) first hand experiences watching non-naive speakers of Japanese for many years: It doesn't matter nearly as much as locals want you to think it matters. Sure, the homophone thing is real, but Japanese people adapt their style of speaking depending upon the audience. (Japanese language and culture is highly context sensitive.) I hear it often when people pick and choose their words carefully in an attempt to reduce confusion around homophones. As a non-native speaker, when I am trying to use a relatively rare term that the speaker doesn't expect me to know, I slow down, use my hands a bit, and toss out some synonyms or brief explanation of the term I am trying to say. On the whole, Japanese people are excellent listeners, so it works pretty well.

What matters more: Japan has very little linguistic diversity for the size of its nation. Plus, it is an island. My theory (empirically observed): This makes them less able to adapt to non-native speakers. When you try to speak a type of Chinese (there are so many) to a native speaker from mainland China... their brain is automatically wired to heavy accents and different word choices, because their country is so linguistically diverse. As a result, when learning a Chinese language, it is pretty easy to speak with locals. In Japan: It is way harder. Mainland Chinese people really make an effort to understand you. It's no different than a tourist from a different region speaking to locals with a heavy accent ... or a different type of Chinese.

Re:Jakarta Is Now the Biggest City in the World by gosub100 on Wednesday November 26, 2025 @02:20AM (#46054970)
People are allowed to disagree with you. Your caricature of them doesn't add to the conversation.
Re:Jakarta Is Now the Biggest City in the World by bugglebeetle on Wednesday November 26, 2025 @12:47AM (#46054525)
I speak Japanese and am fully aware of the dynamic you describe, having experienced it many times, first hand. I’ve also been truly misunderstood as a result of the wrong use of accent, difference in dialect, etc.

This all being said, after this interaction, I imagine you would have trouble in any country, with any language, because you seem quite insufferable and boorish.

Re:Jakarta Is Now the Biggest City in the World by CorrectHorseBat on Wednesday November 26, 2025 @04:39AM (#46055791)
Nice theory, but my experience is exactly the other way around.

Even after several years of learning Chinese I still had trouble communicating with Chinese people, especially those who had no experience talking to foreigners. When I arrived in China and asked the way to the university I was going to (which was close by and very famous) they just didn't get what I was saying. In the end I had to show them the written word.

I don't speak Japanese, but when I arrived and said the name of the city and they immediately understood where I wanted to go. After my experience with Chinese I was flabbergasted that that went so smooth.

I blame the tones in Chinese (which I admit I'm not very good at)

Re:Jakarta Is Now the Biggest City in the World by adrian_b on Wednesday November 26, 2025 @06:23AM (#46056320)
I think that you are right that your problem must have been caused more by the Chinese tones than by any other characteristic of Chinese, and perhaps also from some of their consonants that do not have a straightforward English equivalent.

On the other hand, the Japanese pronunciation is one of the easiest in the world to learn, even taking into account the subtleties of pitch.

Re:Jakarta Is Now the Biggest City in the World by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday November 26, 2025 @11:38AM (#46059275)
You might have been trying too hard with tones and the stilted speech didn’t help with understanding. My first trip to China before I spoke Chinese well enough…the Beijing taxi drivers, you needed to speak more naturally for them to get you, not more correctly. You were better off talking like a farmer than trying to talk like a broadcaster.