If Steam convinces more people to install GNU/Linux I'd say that's a net win. People are going to be using nonfree software anyway, so they might as well do it on a free operating system.
Just yesterday I was reminded of this, when reformatting my computer and reinstalling everything. I forgot to deactivate keys on some of my work software before doing so, and spent hours emailing to get them back. Meanwhile, the whole license/ownership concept of all my games on Steam was completely abstracted away through their install-anywhere-as-many-times policy and Steam Cloud.
Regardless of horror stories about banned accounts, the steam model is one I find infinitely more attractive than even itunes.
PayPal, as it sometimes does, reversed the transaction due to its fraud detection systems, through no fault or instruction of my cofounder.
So Steam locked the entire account, permanently and irreversibly. It wasn't even an option to pay the $50 by another method.
I still buy Steam games, but only on sale.
They were basically assuming fraud; which is what buying a game, receiving the goods, then issuing a chargeback (or PayPal equivalent) would be.
He patiently explained to them that it wasn't initiated by him, but they pretty much stonewalled him.
Apparently having done a thousand dollars worth of business already without incident wasn't enough to get the benefit of the doubt.
Developers and publishers are allowed to add any DRM they want on top of Steam, and frequently do. So you can purchase something through Steam, which can have Securom, Tages, Windows LIVE or any other DRM scheme. This includes limited machine installations which sometimes offer deactivation, but only if you specifically uninstall and deactivate them. So in your reformatting use-case, depending on what games you have purchased, you may end up in the same situation.
Basically, you incorrectly assumed Steam is an alternative to other DRM measures, when in fact it's quite often[1] used on top of other DRM schemes. If you don't believe me, simply check the store pages of most major Ubisoft[2] titles. I just picked Anno 2070 (because I know it has it) and in the infobox on the right hand side:
3rd-party DRM: Solidshield Tages SAS 3 machine activation limit
[1]Among AAA titles that is, I have yet to see it in any indie titles. [2]Pretty much the worst player in the industry when it comes to DRM.
As an indie developer on Steam, I can't see any non-AAA games ever using additional DRM. We're just in it for the convenience of distribution.
But for at least a few years, you've been able to launch steam without an internet connection.
There are plenty of Steam packages that use the Steam infrastructure in a much more integral manner, however. These packages (like TF2 or Half-Life 2) are stored in compressed and encrypted cache files, and install only some components into a directory like `$STEAM/steamapps/$USERNAME/`. These packages can only be removed using the Steam application. While package stubs may be placed for the Control Panel to manage, the "uninstall" action will just call the Steam "Delete Local Content" action.
Don't get me wrong, I don't like cloud licensing or DRM either, and I won't be using Steam for anything but games. But there is a place for such "software vending machines" as Steam and the Mac App Store, particularly at the low end of the market.
Actually, you'll find that not everyone agrees. (Personally, I don't have a strong opinion either way)
Steam on linux is, I think, a big problem for us. There will be dpkg (or whatever your distro chose). This one will install apps in a way that is consistent with the system, and with POSIX. Then, there will be steam. Steam is used because it is the only way to get apps people want. I do not own a game I paid for on Steam. Not even in the way I own non-free apps like Alfred or Ableton Live. I don't have a right to use them, I am merely allowed to do so.
I understand that it is in Valves interest to lock us down like this. But in this case, their interest is against ours, the users.