News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Are consumers just tech debt to Microsoft? by qgin on Sunday November 23, 2025 @01:33PM (#46026066)
Nobody seems to want to use Copilot, but Microsoft is in a great position when AGI "drop-in office workers" become a thing. They can just provision however many virtual coworkers to a Microsoft Teams instance and you'll be handing off documents and chatting with the AGI workers pretty much as you would any other remote worker.

Microsoft doesn't have to be first or best here. Just owning the plumbing of so many present-day workplaces with Teams and Office will make it hard to beat them.

Re:Are consumers just tech debt to Microsoft? by TheCraiggers on Sunday November 23, 2025 @01:49PM (#46026203)
> Microsoft is in a great position when AGI "drop-in office workers" become a thing

While I don't disagree with you here, that's a helluva big bet. It'll have to happen soon enough that other companies aren't able to pivot in time, and despite what Altman says, I just don't see it happening at that timescale.

Re:Are consumers just tech debt to Microsoft? by mschuster91 on Sunday November 23, 2025 @01:54PM (#46026238)
> While I don't disagree with you here, that's a helluva big bet.

And yet, one that Microsoft has the best chances. Apple has all but zero presence in BigCorp outside of social media and creative teams. Google has its Workspaces thing plus its web wannabe-equivalents to Office, but that's it. And AWS is an infrastructure provider.

Microsoft in contrast? They're everywhere and most importantly, whatever is in Office 365 automatically has the "compliant" checkboxes ticked for auditors. And MS can easily ride the time until AGI or something coming reasonably close to it is marketable on that moat.

Re:Are consumers just tech debt to Microsoft? by mouth on Sunday November 23, 2025 @02:26PM (#46026484)
> Apple has all but zero presence in BigCorp outside of social media and creative teams.

Not from my experience. I see product managers/owners and software engineers using Macs more than Windows where I work, and it’s in healthcare, not SV. This move to Mac was gradual, starting ~10 years ago, and I believe a part of this was moving away from native apps to web apps.

Re:Are consumers just tech debt to Microsoft? by ukuina on Sunday November 23, 2025 @03:13PM (#46026908)
To the sibling comments: Apple holds <10% of the worldwide PC market: https://www.gartner.com/en/newsroom/press-releases/2025-01-1...
Re:Are consumers just tech debt to Microsoft? by bikotreats on Sunday November 23, 2025 @02:21PM (#46026449)
"Apple has all but zero presence in BigCorp outside of social media and creative teams"

Bad take. Apple has a strong presence within the tech and digital agency world. At every company i've worked for (3 tech companies, 1 digital agency), the Macbook is the default issued workstation unless you formally request a Windows laptop.

Some roles, like finance, tax, 3D design, favor Windows but that is generally because certain software they depend on only exists in the Windows world.

Microsoft totally dominates non-tech companies though.

Re:Are consumers just tech debt to Microsoft? by chirau on Sunday November 23, 2025 @02:27PM (#46026500)
Apple's footprint in BigCorp is a drop in the ocean compared to MS. You said it yourself, "certain software they depend on only exists in the Windows world". That is intentional and the reason is because of MS dominance in BigCorp. Most makers don't find it worthwhile to spend so much time and resources building software for Apple when it has so few users at that level.
Re:Are consumers just tech debt to Microsoft? by mschuster91 on Sunday November 23, 2025 @02:36PM (#46026568)
> Bad take. Apple has a strong presence within the tech and digital agency world.

Oh I'm aware, working at a digital agency myself. But that's not the "bigco" world aka S&P 500, DAX and the likes.

Re:Are consumers just tech debt to Microsoft? by sofixa on Sunday November 23, 2025 @02:50PM (#46026698)
> Apple has all but zero presence in BigCorp outside of social media and creative teams

Depends on the BigCorp. One of the most quentessential BigCorps out there, IBM, is deep into Apple stuff. As far as publicly shilling for Macs with extremely questionablly extrapolated data - they did a pilot with power users for a year, and came out saying Macs cost less in hardware and support than equivalent Windows Lenovos over the full lifecycle of the machine; which is literally impossible to know a year in a pilot with power users compared to the 4 year lifecycle for all sorts of people.

Re:Are consumers just tech debt to Microsoft? by raw_anon_1111 on Sunday November 23, 2025 @05:26PM (#46027971)
I worked at the second largest employer in the US. It was mostly Macs. You could choose whether you wanted a Mac or Windows computer.
Re:Are consumers just tech debt to Microsoft? by pulse7 on Sunday November 23, 2025 @01:47PM (#46026183)
I'm very happy that "AGI office workers" will use Microsoft products - so I don't have to do it anymore... But: they will not pay a dime for the licenses...
Re:Are consumers just tech debt to Microsoft? by zombot on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @05:06AM (#46044294)
Don't panic, you will still do the paying for the licenses.
Re:Are consumers just tech debt to Microsoft? by robotswantdata on Sunday November 23, 2025 @01:48PM (#46026190)
For the average office task they don’t seem far off being competent, at least to the average workers quality.

Ai builder with gpt5 + workflow triggers is very capable already. 1-2 more model generation hops needed plus a bit more “agent” plumbing before its game over for the excel and word jobs.

Re:Are consumers just tech debt to Microsoft? by sevensor on Sunday November 23, 2025 @02:11PM (#46026365)
Which average office tasks would those be? Writing project proposals? Putting budget numbers into a shared spreadsheet? Composing a progress report? Preparing presentation slides for an executive status update meeting? Writing performance reviews? Taking mandatory compliance training? Going to planning meetings?

One or two of these, I could see. Automated progress reports would be nice. But a lot of them aren’t about document generation, but about human accountability, about being a person who commits to something in writing. Automating away paper pushers means all the accountability lands on their bosses, leaving them nowhere to hide. It will be quite something if we manage to rewrite the corporate social context like this.

Re:Are consumers just tech debt to Microsoft? by nitwit005 on Sunday November 23, 2025 @03:28PM (#46027036)
People will just have the thing open in another window, and move the result over, rather than pay for a bunch of Teams licenses.

In general, we should expect more AI use to decrease the value of human oriented products. A word document is just some XML collection to a computer program. An AI won't need Word to create or edit the files.

Re:Are consumers just tech debt to Microsoft? by d3Xt3r on Sunday November 23, 2025 @02:58PM (#46026779)
Re:Are consumers just tech debt to Microsoft? by otabdeveloper4 on Sunday November 23, 2025 @01:44PM (#46026150)
> when AGI "drop-in office workers" become a thing

How many more weeks? Also, is this before or after flying cars?

Re:Are consumers just tech debt to Microsoft? by qgin on Sunday November 23, 2025 @01:51PM (#46026217)
Looking like 2028-2030 but it's a moving target.

Since we're basically getting flying cars next year at the World Cup, I guess it's going to be after flying cars.

Re:Are consumers just tech debt to Microsoft? by chongli on Sunday November 23, 2025 @02:02PM (#46026295)
I prefer fusion power as the go-to vapourware technology. It’s been “10-20 years out” for 70 years and counting.

I don’t see any reason to believe that “AGI office workers” will be ready to go by 2030. All signs right now are pointing to a looming plateau in their capabilities.

Re:Are consumers just tech debt to Microsoft? by marcosdumay on Sunday November 23, 2025 @02:17PM (#46026402)
Fusion has halved the "interval until we get it" on those 50 years. AGI has doubled the "interval until we get it" twice already since 2022.

Those things are not the same kind of vaporware.

Re:Are consumers just tech debt to Microsoft? by gjm11 on Sunday November 23, 2025 @04:15PM (#46027401)
Could you name a specific person whose estimate of when we might get AGI has doubled twice since 2022? Or do you mean you found one person with a really short estimate in 2022, another person with a longer one in 2024, and another with a longer one now?

Also, if you compare with 50 years ago, AGI has also (better than) halved the interval experts are commonly predicting since then.

(Of course the experts could turn out to be hilariously wrong, for fusion or AI or both. I just don't think your comparison is anything like apples-to-apples.)

Re:Are consumers just tech debt to Microsoft? by thfuran on Sunday November 23, 2025 @02:57PM (#46026762)
Fusion is always years away because funding has been at or below the minimal "fusion never" levels since the '70s: https://fire.pppl.gov/us_fusion_plan_1976.pdf
Re:Are consumers just tech debt to Microsoft? by otabdeveloper4 on Monday November 24, 2025 @02:47AM (#46031414)
> pointing to a looming plateau

Latest LLM's have already been declining in performance. It's not a plateau and it's not looming.

We don't know what the hell we are doing. Adding more training data and parameters only degrades LLMs after a certain threshold.

Re:Are consumers just tech debt to Microsoft? by solumunus on Sunday November 23, 2025 @02:55PM (#46026739)
Ok Elon.
Re:Are consumers just tech debt to Microsoft? by qgin on Monday November 24, 2025 @01:10PM (#46037081)
Re:Are consumers just tech debt to Microsoft? by sofixa on Sunday November 23, 2025 @02:53PM (#46026724)
> Since we're basically getting flying cars next year at the World Cup

That's so funny. Regular people can't hahndle regular cars. Self-driving cars barely handle 2 dimensional space within very specific confines and rules, in good weather. Existing airspace is congested to the point of being problematic in most metro areas around the world.

"Flying cars" might be replacing some private heliopters, maybe. But they aren't going mainstream any time soon.

Re:Are consumers just tech debt to Microsoft? by BobaFloutist on Sunday November 23, 2025 @05:16PM (#46027893)
I also don't really understand what's supposed to be the line between flying car and helicopter.

Does the flying car need to also be street legal on the ground? Does it just not have to look too much like a helicopter?

Re:Are consumers just tech debt to Microsoft? by qgin on Sunday November 23, 2025 @08:44PM (#46029419)
I think it’s anything in the category of “way more common than a helicopter to the point where normal people use them”.
Re:Are consumers just tech debt to Microsoft? by bluGill on Sunday November 23, 2025 @09:07PM (#46029582)
It needs to get through dense downtowns where there isn't much space between buildings, and wires and skyways to dodge as well. A skilled pilot could do it - but they wouldn't try because while space physically exists there isn't enough margin for error.
Re:Are consumers just tech debt to Microsoft? by candiddevmike on Sunday November 23, 2025 @02:20PM (#46026442)
Why don't we see companies adopting this setup with offshore workers if it's that "seamless" and easy to get started?
Re:Are consumers just tech debt to Microsoft? by jen20 on Sunday November 23, 2025 @01:44PM (#46026146)
A new Turing test: when all the AGI worker bots would rather gargle razor blades than use Microsoft Teams, we might be close.
Re:Are consumers just tech debt to Microsoft? by aeve890 on Sunday November 23, 2025 @01:49PM (#46026196)
>use Microsoft Teams

Shit like this make rogue AI scenarios totally plausible. I won't wish that on my worst enemy