News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by sandblast on Sunday November 23, 2025 @05:52AM (#46022430)
Since a lot of people might not reach the conclusion at the bottom of the post:

Just use SimpleX.

Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by w1nt3rmut3 on Sunday November 23, 2025 @05:55AM (#46022448)
Simplex is developed by a person who has a rather difficult view of the world. I would not recommend using it as long as this person is responsible for it.
Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by guytv on Sunday November 23, 2025 @06:02AM (#46022496)
> Simplex is developed by a person who has a rather difficult view of the world. couldn't find it. what's his view of the world?
Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by auntiefah on Sunday November 23, 2025 @06:12AM (#46022578)
Antivax neo-Nazi.
Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by sandblast on Sunday November 23, 2025 @06:22AM (#46022643)
Source on the "neo-Nazism"?

And you might want to tell us how this affects the privacy or security of SimpleX why you're at it.

Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by auntiefah on Sunday November 23, 2025 @06:26AM (#46022673)
Holding and openly expressing these abhorrent views probably encourages him to focus on security and privacy more than others.

But it does risk his app being associated with that and therefore discouraging everyday users. I wouldn't be surprised if it ends up as the next EncroChat.

Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by sandblast on Sunday November 23, 2025 @06:30AM (#46022695)
Focusing on security and privacy is great, but I expected some downsides. I'm glad you decided to emphasize the dedication of the creator of SimpleX instead.

EncroChat was not open-source, so it was much easier to be infiltrated.

Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by johnisgood on Sunday November 23, 2025 @07:33AM (#46023068)
You can self-host SimpleX and it is open source, otherwise I have no idea what you mean by associated with his views. If the project is as promised, then why would you care about the views of the developer?
Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by Xiol on Sunday November 23, 2025 @06:06AM (#46022530)
At first I was like, how difficult?

That is quite the Twitter timeline.

Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by bjoli on Sunday November 23, 2025 @06:13AM (#46022580)
I came here to write just that. It is all over the place as well. I find it a bit disturbing with regard to how one defines struggle against power. What does those views mean with regards to the long term priorities of the software?
Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by sandblast on Sunday November 23, 2025 @06:21AM (#46022636)
Oh, it's very simple: those views mean nothing. Unless you can point to the part of the source code where they are expressed and explain us how this part undermines the project's technological goals.
Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by sandblast on Sunday November 23, 2025 @06:12AM (#46022577)
If you're so eager on encouraging cancel-culture, would you be so kind to elaborate on why exactly you want to cancel this programmer instead of just vaguely pointing in the direction of a closed platform?
Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by kamranjon on Sunday November 23, 2025 @08:40AM (#46023500)
Here is perhaps a simpler metric. If the creator of a security focused software is this awful at protecting their own anonymity- why would I trust them in the first place?

If they are revealing their identity so that we can vet their credentials, then it makes sense that they would want us to judge them based on their online persona.

If we believe all of this to be true - it’s not really cancel culture, it’s by design that the creator of SimpleX has implemented this filtering mechanism for their users.

Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by sandblast on Sunday November 23, 2025 @09:08AM (#46023672)
False dychotomy — there are more options than "protecting anonymity" and "revealing identity so that credentials can be vetted". He just writes what he believes under his own name, it doesn't necessarily have anything to do with establishing his authority.
Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by baxuz on Sunday November 23, 2025 @06:32AM (#46022701)
Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by sandblast on Sunday November 23, 2025 @06:02AM (#46022499)
I don't know what you're mentioning, but let's not forget that whatever view he might have, it changes nothing in the technology he creates. It's open source, it's auditable, and the code does not have worldviews of its own.

Your comment promotes cancel-culture, and as filthy as it is in general, it's even more so in the technology world. Don't do it. Please.

Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by jijijijij on Sunday November 23, 2025 @06:37AM (#46022741)
As long as you are not auditing every bit of code you run yourself AND are sufficiently knowledgeable to detect even obfuscated malicious code, you need some basis of trust.

Evident world views far off reason, reality, compassion and pragmatic self-regulation, don't speak for a stable, predictable and reasonable personality.

If a person thinks some humans deserve less rights than others, how could you trust any update to not reflect this world view?

Additionally you may be becoming technologically dependent on a person whose actions may be detrimental to your safety or wellbeing in other parts of your life.

You may also just don't like to promote this person's work.

It's fair to inform others about the person behind the software they are running. Everybody can make their own informed choices.

Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by sandblast on Sunday November 23, 2025 @06:40AM (#46022763)
And the appropriate basis of trust in the technology world would be source code audits, not scraping some individual's Twitter posts.

If the users' communications are encrypted — which they are — there is no way for the creator to "reflect his world view", whatever it might be, in the form of undermining the security or privacy for some part of the user base.

Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by jijijijij on Sunday November 23, 2025 @06:53AM (#46022838)
You want to audit every update? Are you going to pay for it? Is this relevant for the app discussed?

Because until there are other means of forming trust available, everyone only got the vibe check. Some perfect world scenario ain't gonna cut it.

Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by sandblast on Sunday November 23, 2025 @07:06AM (#46022907)
I'll try from another angle:

If I wanted to make a honeypot that undermines users' privacy and anonymity, I would make sure to be as nice to everyone as possible. The "vibe check" is irrelevant, the false positives are far too common.

Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by jijijijij on Sunday November 23, 2025 @07:14AM (#46022949)
Yes, the vibe check can fail too, but that's no argument to ignore crazy.

You do you. As I said, we all should be able to make informed choices as we please.

Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by jrflowers on Sunday November 23, 2025 @07:16AM (#46022959)
I like your point that if a developer is a vocal neo nazi then only people capable of regularly conducting their own thorough code reviews should rely on the products that they make. I agree with you that regular folks that can’t do code audits should not trust neo nazis with their private communications. It is good to know that we’re on the same page about not implicitly trusting the simplex code
Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by sandblast on Sunday November 23, 2025 @07:26AM (#46023018)
This is not my point. Trusting someone else's code audit is infinitely more valuable than trusting any "vibe check", since it touches the actual subject matter.
Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by jijijijij on Sunday November 23, 2025 @08:42AM (#46023521)
How do you derive trust for the auditing?

Anyway, since we're talking concrete software, could you point to such code reviews from vibe-independent auditors for continuous verifiable simplex builds targeting common communication platforms?

If not, your point is moot for the subject at hand. Decisions have to be made on the basis of reality not cozy fantasies.

I am not sure I run a single piece of software where this is done. Sporadic audits tend to bring evidence of soundness and security, not continuous absence of malicious functionality.

Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by sandblast on Sunday November 23, 2025 @09:10AM (#46023689)
> I am not sure I run a single piece of software where this is done.

And yet you run it. Have you vibe-checked every such software? Did that bring you enough information about individuals creating it? If not, if there are no readily available signs, have you vetted their own, private beliefs otherwise — in order to ensure they don't clash with your own?

What if Linus Torvalds turned out to be secretly a Nazi pedophile for the whole time? Would that make you stop using Linux?

Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by jijijijij on Sunday November 23, 2025 @09:35AM (#46023866)
You are moving the goalpost. There is no constructive discussion possible, if you can't concede weak arguments.

But yes, I vibe checked the software projects I use. They are mostly large enough, where single individual failings are of no consequence and unhinged people are usually removed from executive control through various means. But it's trust based on feelings and the information I got. Most people involved in these projects are mature and controlled enough to not mix politics with their work. It's not a good sign to not be in control of such impulses.

And I rather take a chance with the unknown bad, than rationalize the known. Luckily most people with a collectivist FOSS mindset don't turn out to be monsters. Who could have predicted that?!

Your turn.

Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by sandblast on Sunday November 23, 2025 @10:36AM (#46024326)
I was just asking to know your thought process, but this discussion probably won't lead to anything anyway — in my view a person's stance on vaccines, gay rights, what have you, doesn't make you any worse developer. If the technology is sound — which I can vibe-check (by a glimpse on how the code is maintained, documented etc.) — I have no reason to peek into one's private views. Your opinion is different, I still don't fully understand it, but we'll just have to agree to disagree.
Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by jijijijij on Sunday November 23, 2025 @11:15AM (#46024622)
We are not talking private opinions, we're talking public ones. Lol.

If you fail to understand why human rights and state repression stances don't matter evaluating trust in secure and private communication means, we indeed don't need to discuss any further. It is a bit silly tho.

Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by jrflowers on Sunday November 23, 2025 @02:21PM (#46026450)
I like that you asked

>could you point to such code reviews from vibe-independent auditors for continuous verifiable simplex builds targeting common communication platforms?

and sandblast has written a lot of words that indicate “no”, so they’ve been pretty consistently arguing not to use simplex.

Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by jrflowers on Sunday November 23, 2025 @02:16PM (#46026392)
This makes sense. Trusting a stranger’s code is bad but trusting a stranger’s opinions about code is good.

Unless you mean that only users personally capable of walking through the code line by line and their immediate friends and family should run code written by neo nazis

Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by srean on Sunday November 23, 2025 @07:03AM (#46022895)
In an ideal world yes, what you say is true.

However, human being human beings, they find it very hard to sequester their beliefs, emotions from their work. It's a common human failing. Often they are not even aware of it.

Having politically or socially divisive beliefs publicly also makes such a person a target of coercion and encouragement to yield to a "harmless" temptation by way of appropriate 3 letter like agencies.

To ensure that this does not happen will require maintaining a paranoid level of vigilance on the code all the time. That is a lot of work, very expensive and is unlikely to happen. Perhaps not fair to his creation, but that's just how it goes.

My comment is at a high level. This is the first time I heard of Simplex chat, so I don't even know what views its developer has.

Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by dist-epoch on Sunday November 23, 2025 @06:22AM (#46022642)
Any ultra-secure messaging app will inevitably attract the drug dealers which will inevitably attract the police trying to infiltrate it.

You are much more secure blending in the vast masses using WhatsApp than on a ultra-targeted ultra-small app like SimpleX.

Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by csydas on Sunday November 23, 2025 @07:22AM (#46022994)
i don’t think that’s the right take

black markets and opposition members i’ve used / talked with focus on disposability not security

the premise of their communications is always “the platform is bugged” and in case of opposition members “the government can always just beat you and trick you into unlocking your phone”

deals happen on messenger all the time and burning messages / rotating phones and accounts is very common. for opposition members, messaging apps are purely for benign communication and actual discussion happens in person or in truly destructible formats or it’s not recorded at all

periodically anon burner message apps appear on app stores and rotate out pretty fast once they start getting too much attention

the idea of a perfectly secure app for communication is currently mostly a fantasy; if a malicious actor wants to get your info and communication they will. this doesn’t mean give up completely and be insecure but instead just be in a position to ditch the app when it becomes necessary, if you need that level of security

it’s better people be trained to understand the reality of what can be done with the communication methods they use and how they can be punked so they can make informed decisions — i’m fine with signal’s goals and efforts but i’m not a fan of signal advocates treating security and privacy like another round of the OS wars, that teaches people the wrong lesson and makes it harder to convince ppl privacy and security are a problem we need to take seriously not just for criminals but for everyone. privacy and security benefit us all or it benefits no one

Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by sandblast on Sunday November 23, 2025 @06:24AM (#46022659)
The "police trying to infiltrate it" means nothing unless they can do so successfully. We know that it's vastly easier to undermine users' privacy on WhatsApp than on SimpleX.

So where exactly is that "much more security" you're touting?

Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by dist-epoch on Sunday November 23, 2025 @06:46AM (#46022794)
There are few stories of drug smuggling gangs being caught because they used WhatsApp.

There are many about how they were caught because the used ultra-secure "phones for criminals".

Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by sandblast on Sunday November 23, 2025 @06:52AM (#46022834)
SimpleX is not a phone and its model of distribution and being open-source makes it much harder to infiltrate than these projects you're hinting at.
Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by beeflet on Sunday November 23, 2025 @07:26AM (#46023015)
There are already drug dealers on whatsapp
Re:Signal knows who you're talking to by jijijijij on Sunday November 23, 2025 @06:47AM (#46022806)
The only reason drug dealers aren't getting busted on WhatsApp is nobody cares enough. They wouldn't care either way.