News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Helping Valve to power up Steam devices by tapoxi on Friday November 21, 2025 @06:06PM (#46010140)
> They invented loot crates. Hats. Etc.

Don't forget the part where they're encouraging kids to gamble with real money on Counter-Strike skins. They rely on an API that Valve freely provides and makes no effort to curtail.

But they like Linux and give refunds so they get a free pass.

Re:Helping Valve to power up Steam devices by jsheard on Friday November 21, 2025 @06:09PM (#46010169)
> and give refunds so they get a free pass.

They only begrudgingly conceded refunds in 2015 after the no-refunds policy they had maintained for 12 years was found to be illegal in Australia.

Re:Helping Valve to power up Steam devices by mikkupikku on Friday November 21, 2025 @06:34PM (#46010380)
Whatever the reason for their policy, it provides a nice sense of safety to Linux gamers. They can buy the game without worrying about compatibility; if the game doesn't run then its two clicks for an automated refund.
Re:Helping Valve to power up Steam devices by protimewaster on Friday November 21, 2025 @06:57PM (#46010569)
Also, competing stores like EA's Origin had a pretty friendly refund policy before Valve did, helping to put some pressure on Valve.
Re:Helping Valve to power up Steam devices by rockskon on Saturday November 22, 2025 @02:34AM (#46012896)
I seem to recall Origin initially reserving the right to revoke your license to play games you purchased after a few years of inactivity.
Re:Helping Valve to power up Steam devices by abustamam on Saturday November 22, 2025 @11:01AM (#46015690)
Classic EA.

"Oh, you haven't played this game in a while. You should pay us again if you wanna play it again. Give you a sense of pride and accomplishment!"

(reference for those who haven't seen it https://www.reddit.com/r/StarWarsBattlefront/comments/7cff0b... )

Re:Helping Valve to power up Steam devices by protimewaster on Friday December 05, 2025 @09:28AM (#46161707)
AFAIK Steam has this too. The Subscriber Agreement clearly states that you're not guaranteed continued, free access to Steam. If they decided they wanted to charge you to access games you already bought, they could.
Re:Helping Valve to power up Steam devices by nananana9 on Friday November 21, 2025 @06:22PM (#46010279)
They made the new refund policy worldwide, which they absolutely did not have to.
Re:Helping Valve to power up Steam devices by jsheard on Friday November 21, 2025 @06:36PM (#46010399)
Sure, but I imagine they saw the dominoes falling and realized that the optics of going down kicking and screaming in endless battles against basic consumer rights would be exceptionally bad. If they hadn't fully conceded then the EU would have been up their ass too before long.
Re:Helping Valve to power up Steam devices by aranelsurion on Friday November 21, 2025 @08:09PM (#46011074)
> kicking and screaming in endless battles against basic consumer rights

“Apple has entered the chat.”

There are so many examples of other companies doing exactly that.

Re:Helping Valve to power up Steam devices by jchw on Friday November 21, 2025 @07:21PM (#46010743)
I truly believe that Valve has two fundamental things working in their favor:

Firstly: Despite inventing or at least popularizing a lot of new microtransaction concepts, they've just never been the greediest company in the business when it comes to microtransactions. Mobile gacha games have cleaned up their business quite a lot lately, with most of them being significantly less predatory than they used to be, but even back when TF2 introduced lootboxes and hats, the important thing was that the game was not pay to win; you could get all of the items in relatively short order just by playing, and the only benefit to paying was cosmetics.

Contrast this to the earlier reign of Korean MMOs: pretty much all of them had egregious microtransactions. MapleStory, PangYa, Gunbound, etc, and even some current platforms like Roblox. Valve also came into this whole thing before lootboxes became the root of all evil, and while TF2's lootbox mechanism looks bad in retrospect, there was simply no stigma against a system like that, and it never felt like a big deal during the game's heyday. Just my opinion, but I strongly believe it to be true.

Secondly: The most egregious things going on are not things Valve is directly involved in, they are merely complicit, in that they don't do much to curtail it. It's not even necessarily cynical to say that Valve is turning a blind eye, they benefit so significantly from the egregious behavior that it is hard to believe they are not influenced by this fact. But: It is consistent with Valve's behavior in other ways: Valve has taken a very hands-off stance in many places, and if it weren't for external factors it seems likely they would be even more hands-off than they are now. I think they genuinely take the position that it's not their job to enforce moral standards, and if you really do take this position seriously it is going to wind up looking extremely bad when you benefit from it. It's not so dissimilar from the position that Cloudflare tries to take with its services: it's hard to pick apart what may be people with power trying to uphold ideals even when it is optically poor versus greedy companies intentionally turning a blind eye because it might enrich them. (And yes, I do understand that these sites violate Valve's own ToS, but so does a lot of things on Steam Workshop and elsewhere. In many cases, they really do seem consistently lax as long as there isn't significant external pressure.)

Despite these two things, there is a nagging feeling that every company gives me that I should never take anything but a cynical view on them, because almost all companies are basically lawnmowers now. But I really do not feel like I only give Valve the benefit of the doubt just because they support Linux; I actually feel like Valve has done a substantial amount to prove that they are not just another lawnmower. After all, while they definitely are substantially enriched by tolerating misuse of their APIs, they've probably also gotten themselves into tons of trouble by continuing to have a very hands-off attitude. In fact, it seems like owing to the relatively high standards people have for Valve, they get criticized and punished more for conduct than other companies. I mean seriously, Valve has gotten absolutely reamed for their attempt at adding an arbitration clause into their ToS, with consequences that lingered long after they removed and cancelled the arbitration clause. And I do hate that they even tried it -- but what's crazy to me is that it was already basically standard in big tech licensing agreements. Virtually everyone has an insane "you can't sue us" rule in their ToS. It numbs my mind to try to understand why Valve was one of the first and only companies to face punishment for this. It wouldn't numb my mind at all if it was happening to all of them, but plenty of these arbitration clauses persist today!

So when I consider all of this, I think Valve is an alright company. They're not saints, but even if the bar wasn't so terribly low, they'd probably still be above average overall. That can be true simultaneously with them still having bad practices that we don't all like.

Re:Helping Valve to power up Steam devices by Hikikomori on Friday November 21, 2025 @07:47PM (#46010919)
The same api users use?
Re:Helping Valve to power up Steam devices by koolala on Saturday November 22, 2025 @07:25AM (#46014263)
a social chat interface where bots pretend to be humans.

so its a UI not a API yeah

Re:Helping Valve to power up Steam devices by cornhole on Saturday November 22, 2025 @01:54AM (#46012720)
there are worse capitalists to give money to
Re:Helping Valve to power up Steam devices by tarsinge on Saturday November 22, 2025 @04:39AM (#46013465)
Yes everybody is trying to find rational reasons but to me like in recent politics a lot has to do with irrational tribalism.

I stumbled on an article of Gabe talking about his new yacht[0] and it made me realize he is not different than other billionaire (and maybe worst than average because he doesn’t even give to charity). But he looks like he is "one of us" and he likes Linux, so it’s okay.

Would gamers keep the rose colored glasses if Valve was exactly the same but the CEO was a business suit style type?

[0] https://fortune.com/2025/11/17/gabe-newell-leviathan-superya...

Re:Helping Valve to power up Steam devices by rpdillon on Saturday November 22, 2025 @09:11AM (#46014954)
It isn't tribalism, at least not from my side. There's a tangible, noticeable, immediate difference between buying a piece of hardware from Valve and buying a piece of hardware from Google or Apple. I really resented Valve after the Steam box debacle that left me with a $1,200 paperweight, but since then, they've done enormous amounts of work to regain my trust through tangible increases in the quality of the gaming experience, including not having to use Windows to game anymore, and providing me with open hardware that I can install whatever I want on, including using their hardware as my own personal PC when e.g. traveling.

Its weird to me that people choose what companies to buy from on the basis of whether or not the CEO owns a yacht or how rich he is. That is not the operative criteria when I choose what products to buy, but rather how well that product suits my needs and how much I trust the relationship with the company that produced it.

Valve is just miles ahead of every other manufacturer in this regard.

Re:Helping Valve to power up Steam devices by sehansen on Tuesday November 25, 2025 @06:37AM (#46044840)
Hard disagree. The difference between "good" and "bad" billionaires is in how the operate the entities they control. No matter how much money Bill Gates gives to charity, he should mainly be judged based how Microsoft acted while he were in control. Similarly, Gabe Newell is a much "better" billionaire than Mark Zuckerberg or Jeff Bezos.