Re:Marc Benioff: Future Software Will Look Like Facebook
by DeepDuh on Sunday September 30, 2012 @05:25AM
(#4592459)
I like your plan. Let's join forces and disrupt the gardening and bird watching space using cutting edge crowdsourced location aware mobile technology.
Re:Marc Benioff: Future Software Will Look Like Facebook
by dkersten on Tuesday October 02, 2012 @01:00PM
(#4602970)
I agree - hence the "semi" part. I wouldn't do it on my own, but if somebody local were to want to partner and do it, I'd very seriously consider it. Though right now I'm too busy with a startup, but post-startup, it sounds like quite an appealing option.
Re:Marc Benioff: Future Software Will Look Like Facebook
by edtechdev on Sunday September 30, 2012 @06:18AM
(#4592523)
This has already been happening for quite a while now. Not exactly a radical prediction.
Learning management systems like Blackboard and Instructure Canvas are basically imitating facebook now. Edmodo goes the other way and basically starts from facebook and then adds in some learning/teaching features like quizzes and assignments.
Of course github has taken off the past few years, and it has feeds and likes (starring projects) and follows.
For things that aren't enough to warrant social attention to 'like' (like posting 100 times), there seems to be more use of badges like on forums and stack exchange.
Re:Marc Benioff: Future Software Will Look Like Facebook
by jkaljundi on Sunday September 30, 2012 @05:41AM
(#4592471)
Feed-based enterprise products can be a nightmare for users to follow. There must be structured filtering, categorizing, subsets etc to make sure you can find needed information quickly, not miss important stuff and not having to read through absolutely everything in the newsfeed. For many types of information, using the newsfeed paradigm would be absolutely incorrect.
Re:Marc Benioff: Future Software Will Look Like Facebook
by Zenst on Sunday September 30, 2012 @10:41AM
(#4592951)
Agreed any feed based system, even with filters adhears to one fixed albeit customised set of filters. When you can have a different filter set that takes into account what is important to you right there and now, which changes. Then it will be more managable, but that is still away of as predicting the weather 100% right all the time. Compters are good after all at learning from there mistakes once said mistakes have been highlighted to them, it is when they learn human mistakes which the human is unaware of that starts to become an area of conflict.
But if feed based products were the way to go then USENET would of been growing in popularity above and beyond the binary feeds.
We after all as humans are still pefecting ourselfs and with that we are shy of any software that dictates direction for us. For most a forum were the input feeds are moderated and sanatised by others prior to you getting it is the common form, be it via crowd sourced forums like this or teirs of managment filtering what is interesting. Though the ability to overide those filters is just as important than having them and any other way is dictating and controlling the information in a way that makes most uncomfortable in the expectation that they are missing something which to them is important. Just as if this forum had no search option and the ability to view only the deemed top news items, well you know how that would work out badly, even if most don't use search or the new options much.
Re:Marc Benioff: Future Software Will Look Like Facebook
by Cherian_Abraham on Sunday September 30, 2012 @11:54AM
(#4593146)
Over a year ago, I wrote up an early product requirements doc for how law enforcement investigations will function if investigators could follow cases, evidence, firearms, events, suspects, persons of interest, locations similar to how we follow people on Twitter or Facebook. It would make it incredibly easier for them to be notified when something changes, instead of having to manually be alerted about something of relevance.
Re:Marc Benioff: Future Software Will Look Like Facebook
by gojomo on Sunday September 30, 2012 @05:31AM
(#4592463)
My hunch is yes, there are successful patterns in Facebook that will propagate to many other software categories, both because they are beneficial and users have een trained to expect them... but then no, those patterns won't dominate completely, because certain countervailing needs will change/moderate/negate them.
For example, the 'news feed' is super compelling and attention-grabbing, but at least partially in attention-abusive ways. By intermixing updates of wildly different importance, provenance, and topic, a heightened sense of novelty is created. By the use of reverse-chronological order, a false urgency is created -- "I must read/reply before it scrolls out of view!" -- even when the topics aren't really urgent. So this pattern is a sugar/steroid/stimulant for engagements... against which the mentally-healthy will eventually have to disengage and replace with something more respectful of their attention, with truer cues about novelty and importance.
So I expect the 'feed' pattern to be copied everywhere it might offer a quick bit of 'sizzle' to interactions... but also for new ameliorative antipatterns to be developed, and modify or displace the 'feed', as well. Especially in productive contexts where entertainment/diversion/distraction is not the highest value, it will be tried but then modified or discarded.
Re:Marc Benioff: Future Software Will Look Like Facebook
by eyevariety on Sunday September 30, 2012 @01:45PM
(#4593436)
It is ADD for sure, but there is a measured dopamine response to this type of interaction. The easiest way to understand the history of any object is through a timeline, so when appropriate I do think you are going to see a lot more of it.
From my vantage all of the modern social networks feel like the newest incarnation of the blog model, which has always had that timeline model.
Re:Marc Benioff: Future Software Will Look Like Facebook
by gojomo on Sunday September 30, 2012 @02:22PM
(#4593568)
If you want a summary history for a unified object, the revchron presentation is natural and minimally abusive. (Though, we may yet find better standard presentations for hiding info that is attention-grabbing but lower-value.)
Mixing unrelated things, and making this mixed-history the default view, and optimizing it relentlessly for impressions/engagement -- those are all thiings that trend towards abusing people's attention. People will become more aware and less tolerant of such 'false excitement' UX over time, presenting more opportunities for designs and businesses that respect rather than squander our mental cycles.
Re:Marc Benioff: Future Software Will Look Like Facebook
by sigsergv on Sunday September 30, 2012 @09:08AM
(#4592769)
And I expect that simple feed will evolve into something more complex than just plain list of entries. The obvious option: feed is sorted by some other item propety, not time but importance+time.
Re:Marc Benioff: Future Software Will Look Like Facebook
by ktizo on Sunday September 30, 2012 @08:45AM
(#4592734)
Facebook looks like tv listings and classifieds pages from old print magazines to me. If the future of software looks like facebook, there will be a hell of a lot of disappointed people.
Is this not the Google Wave Fallacy?
Is that like one of those Swiss army knives with a built-in compass?
Learning management systems like Blackboard and Instructure Canvas are basically imitating facebook now. Edmodo goes the other way and basically starts from facebook and then adds in some learning/teaching features like quizzes and assignments.
Of course github has taken off the past few years, and it has feeds and likes (starring projects) and follows.
As someone commented on slashdot, even AutoCAD added a 'design feed' feature http://www.autocadws.com/blog/introducing-the-design-feed/
For things that aren't enough to warrant social attention to 'like' (like posting 100 times), there seems to be more use of badges like on forums and stack exchange.
Future software will look like Facebook except when it doesn't.
Much better.
But if feed based products were the way to go then USENET would of been growing in popularity above and beyond the binary feeds.
We after all as humans are still pefecting ourselfs and with that we are shy of any software that dictates direction for us. For most a forum were the input feeds are moderated and sanatised by others prior to you getting it is the common form, be it via crowd sourced forums like this or teirs of managment filtering what is interesting. Though the ability to overide those filters is just as important than having them and any other way is dictating and controlling the information in a way that makes most uncomfortable in the expectation that they are missing something which to them is important. Just as if this forum had no search option and the ability to view only the deemed top news items, well you know how that would work out badly, even if most don't use search or the new options much.
For example, the 'news feed' is super compelling and attention-grabbing, but at least partially in attention-abusive ways. By intermixing updates of wildly different importance, provenance, and topic, a heightened sense of novelty is created. By the use of reverse-chronological order, a false urgency is created -- "I must read/reply before it scrolls out of view!" -- even when the topics aren't really urgent. So this pattern is a sugar/steroid/stimulant for engagements... against which the mentally-healthy will eventually have to disengage and replace with something more respectful of their attention, with truer cues about novelty and importance.
So I expect the 'feed' pattern to be copied everywhere it might offer a quick bit of 'sizzle' to interactions... but also for new ameliorative antipatterns to be developed, and modify or displace the 'feed', as well. Especially in productive contexts where entertainment/diversion/distraction is not the highest value, it will be tried but then modified or discarded.
From my vantage all of the modern social networks feel like the newest incarnation of the blog model, which has always had that timeline model.
Nir Eyal has some nice thoughts on it: http://www.nirandfar.com/2012/08/the-webs-slot-machine.html
Mixing unrelated things, and making this mixed-history the default view, and optimizing it relentlessly for impressions/engagement -- those are all thiings that trend towards abusing people's attention. People will become more aware and less tolerant of such 'false excitement' UX over time, presenting more opportunities for designs and businesses that respect rather than squander our mental cycles.