News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by mmoustafa on Thursday November 13, 2025 @02:56PM (#45919704)
We do not live in a democracy, we live in a representative democracy. The founders simply had no option, you had to pick a person, put them in a carriage, and send them to the capitol to do your bidding (also why electoral college exists for reporting votes, but I digress).

I always wonder what they would’ve created if everyone had a device in their pocket to send their preferences directly to the capitol at the speed of light.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by astroflection on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:25PM (#45920058)
Too bad there are no technologies that would allow the citizenry to communicate nearly instantaneously and cast their votes in a pseudo-anonymous manner.
Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by swarnie on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:34PM (#45920166)
Impossible, we must interpret the intentions of some blokes who died 220 years ago and try to assume what they would have wanted.

Its the only way.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by Towaway69 on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:37PM (#45920198)
It’s a blockchain moment - finally a use case ;) /s
Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by smileysteve on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:39PM (#45920227)
It's worse than the founding though because Congress has artificially capped its growth. If the house of representatives followed the per capital ratios of the early 20th century, we'd have more than 2x the representatives, if it went back to the 18th century ratios we'd have thousands.

Only, since the 1930 house appropriation, the technology has existed - the automobile, the telephone; by 1960 we had flight, by the 90s we had widespread Internet and faxes.

Theb, the Senate is only made to be like the house of lords, which by itself it now an antiquated concept.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by JumpCrisscross on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:38PM (#45920201)
> We do not live in a democracy, we live in a representative democracy

We live in a republic. Republics mix representative and direct democracy with other featurs to become larger, safer and more powerful than pure democracies have historically been able to be.

The American republic, in my opinion, oversamples representation and undersamples plebescite, lot and ostracisation. (In Athens, elections were assumed biased to the elites. Selection by lot, i.e. by random.)

In my opinion, a lot of the supermajority requirements for legislation are better replaced with plebescite. (We have national elections every two years.) In my opinion, Supreme Court cases should be allocated by lot to a random slate of appelate judges. And in my opinion, every election should have a write-in line where, if more than X% of folks write in a name, that person is not allowed to run for office in that jurisdiction for N years.

The first requires a Constitutional amendment. The second legislation by the Congress. The last may be enactable in state law.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by Aperocky on Thursday November 13, 2025 @02:58PM (#45919735)
Could it actually be worse?
Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by cheschire on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:11PM (#45919903)
I absolutely think so. Can you imagine if voting was influenced directly by whatever memes were on Tiktok?
Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by godzillabrennus on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:35PM (#45920178)
Given how Mamdani won in NYC I think we are already at that stage.
Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by mothballed on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:38PM (#45920208)
That one definitely reflects that the founders tended to limit voting to those with higher level of stakes in society (usually land owners).

While I'm not defending the practice, the parallel here is lifelong NYC dwellers with family roots in NYC were far less likely to vote for Mamdani than more recent immigrants or residents. It was largely a vote of those with the least stakes in NYC voting to overpower those with the highest stakes in NYC.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by Razengan on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:19PM (#45919988)
You could have actual semi-immortal magic users claiming to be the Senate.
Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by lazide on Thursday November 13, 2025 @02:57PM (#45919715)
As the Greeks found, the only think worse than representative democracy is direct democracy.
Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by wing-_-nuts on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:14PM (#45919942)
Vehemently disagree. I would much rather take our most contentious issues (abortion, M4A, etc) put them on a national ballot and let the general public decide. I don't agree with everything passed on ballot in my state, but I respect that at least the majority voted for it.
Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by jdc0589 on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:22PM (#45920016)
I agree. I don't, and never will, trust politicians (of any party) to actually represent their constituents accurately. I understand everything can't be a direct democracy, but we need some sort of a middle ground.

It's really weird to think about. I am a straight white CIS male, with no extreme political or social views, my family has been in the US for 150 years, im financially well off, and I don't feel like I have accurate trustworthy representation in government at any level. I am the person that everyone says is over represented

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by SoftTalker on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:28PM (#45920085)
There's a widespread misunderstanding about what congresspeople do.

They are not elected to represent the views of their constituents. Constituents, rather, elect those representatives whose agendas they most closely support. There's a subtle difference.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by wing-_-nuts on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:47PM (#45920326)
>They are not elected to represent the views of their constituents.

Yet another thing I vehemently disagree with.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by lazide on Saturday November 15, 2025 @01:11PM (#45939340)
I guess it’s a question of semantics.

If a rep basically says ‘I don’t care what y’all say, I’m doing z’, and they get elected.

Does that mean they got elected because everyone wants z? Or they got elected, and plan to do z?

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by QuercusMax on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:42PM (#45920258)
why do you write 'cis' in all caps? It's not any kind of acronym, initialism, or otherwise; it's a Latinate prefix.
Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by JumpCrisscross on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:47PM (#45920324)
> it's a Latinate prefix

Hehe cis masculus.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by jdc0589 on Thursday November 20, 2025 @11:02AM (#45994054)
I didnt know, its not a term I use frequently/ever
Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by JumpCrisscross on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:47PM (#45920318)
> would much rather take our most contentious issues (abortion, M4A, etc) put them on a national ballot and let the general public decide

Those are actually great examples of where federalism plus direct democracy works better than aggregated democracy. There are fundamental worldview differencs on abortion that a plebescite can't reconcile. The failure of direct democracy is it short circuits deliberation. So to make it work, you need another layer where deliberation occurs.

The Swiss seem to have solved this neatly: the representative body deliberates, and then the population gets and up-down vote.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by petsfed on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:33PM (#45920142)
Granted, but the problem with direct democracy is that you either let issues be decided only by the most engaged voters or you require participation from all, and issues are decided based on who can present the most sexy case on otherwise very unsexy issues.

I'm not a huge fan of representative democracy, but for direct democracy to work, we have to change society sufficiently to let ignorant lay people become informed enough on various issues to have a meaningful opinion on them.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by wing-_-nuts on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:37PM (#45920200)
I'm ok with congress handling the day to day minutia of government, but we should take all the highly partisan crap and put it to the ballot, and be done with it.
Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by lazide on Friday November 14, 2025 @05:34AM (#45925647)
Sufficiently framed, the highly partisan crap is the day to day.

The gov’t shutdown was precisely using the day to day crap to get leverage!

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by kyrra on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:20PM (#45919999)
The problem is that proper legislation is a balance of interests and working through the details of the policy. If you put "abortion" on the ballot, what would that mean? There are a ton of different possible policies on what is or is not permissible.
Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by oblio on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:27PM (#45920076)
Haven't the Swiss solved this?

Maybe you Americans should figure out the first step of engineering, which is to look at existing solutions and learn from them :-p

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by gsf_emergency_4 on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:40PM (#45920229)
The main thing the Swiss have that Americans don't are referendums that can seriously challenge federal action. And then there are the state versions of that. And they don't have to wait for "the cycle". Or have results made null by arbitrary veto powers.
Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by lazide on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:32PM (#45920136)
The Swiss have a representative democracy with a slightly different way of ‘representing’.
Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by oblio on Friday November 14, 2025 @03:57AM (#45925141)
We can move the goalposts as much as we like, but the Swiss have the closest approximation of a direct democracy in the world, right now.

So before dreaming about 100% democracy, maybe the US could slide away from "flawed democracy", first: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Economist_Democracy_Index#...

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by lazide on Friday November 14, 2025 @05:26AM (#45925619)
Sure, but who is going to be elected who would do that?

And as has been quite apparent, since the most folks will do is peacefully protest if outside the voting system - and be ignored - how else is it going to change?

And if either of those were working, we wouldn’t be complaining about this online anyway eh?

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by oblio on Sunday November 16, 2025 @10:25AM (#45945770)
I highly doubt the US system can be fixed peacefully. I really wish it were, since the US affects a lot of the rest of the world (including where I live).
Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by chimeracoder on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:21PM (#45920013)
> Vehemently disagree. I would much rather take our most contentious issues (abortion, M4A, etc) put them on a national ballot and let the general public decide

The problem with true direct democracy isn't how people would handle high-level issues that are direct reflections on people's basic values and principles, like the two examples you mentioned.

The problem with true direct democracy is that every single person becomes responsible for understanding the intricacies of mundane-but-critical details of administration, like the third-order effects of specific tax policies, or actions that are currently delegated to executive agencies.

Except in the extremely small scale, it quickly becomes prohibitive to reasonably expect all those people to be able to make informed decisions about all the necessary parts.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by rootusrootus on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:29PM (#45920090)
I'd like a hybrid system like we have in a number of states. A mechanism for nationwide initiative petitions would be nice. Then we can get nationwide consensus on the high-level issues and leave the rest for the people whose job it is to work out the details.
Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by wing-_-nuts on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:34PM (#45920172)
Exactly. Stop playing political football with issues. Put them to the people at let the voting public decide, and be done with it.
Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by lazide on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:33PM (#45920160)
The worst laws come from direct amendments and petitions because only the stuff no lawmaker actually wants their name on (or could pass) goes there - and it gets gamed to hell.

See the CA propositions - they turn into insane population wide gaslighting competitions.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by wing-_-nuts on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:46PM (#45920304)
I'd rather have CA's props than an elected congressman who ignores the will of the people
Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by mothballed on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:53PM (#45920386)
Why not a mixture of both? CA for instance had their populace vote to ban gay marriage in prop 8, CA then just told the voters to go fuck themselves and tied it up and overturned it in court.

So you can see even if you literally amend the constitution in california by popular referendum, those in power can just tell the populace to go fuck themselves and they won't be recognizing it, no matter that the constitution is the supreme law of the state.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by chimeracoder on Thursday November 13, 2025 @05:32PM (#45921549)
> Why not a mixture of both? CA for instance had their populace vote to ban gay marriage in prop 8, CA then just told the voters to go fuck themselves and tied it up and overturned it in court.

> So you can see even if you literally amend the constitution in california by popular referendum, those in power can just tell the populace to go fuck themselves and they won't be recognizing it, no matter that the constitution is the supreme law of the state.

Your argument would make sense if the courts had overturned Prop 8 on the basis that it was unconstitutional at the state level. But that's not what happened.

The state case against Prop 8 was upheld by the courts. The federal courts ruled against it, in a completely separate case, on the basis of the Equal Protection Clause in the US constitution. Prop 8 amended the state constitution; it did not amend the US constitution.

It's also a moot point, because Prop 8 was also repealed by a subsequent ballot initiative, with 61% of the vote.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by lazide on Friday November 14, 2025 @05:32AM (#45925643)
So you’re saying popular votes are not sufficient to avoid flip flops on contentious issues, and popular voting also can step on minority groups recognized rights on a whim?

What problem is it solving again?

And notably, California is one of the most consistently gay friendly states and still flip flopped on this exact topic.

The more direct the democracy (and the shorter the timeframes between elections!), the easier it is to game the population or poke people’s buttons and make them vote on things they later regret - or deeply enjoy.

The whole court system and bill of rights is to try to put guard rails, so there aren’t (for example) purges/genocides, removing a little under half the populations rights, etc. etc. but there is only so much rules can do.

There is no free lunch.

Notably, imagine direct democracy and the [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Satanic_panic]!

Without guardrails on the levers of power, a lot of people would have died. As it is, a lot of lives still got ruined.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by rootusrootus on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:38PM (#45920204)
So then it boils back down to 'most people are stupid' and the reason we have representative democracy is so we can cultivate a class of elites who are smart enough and have enough skin in the game to make good decisions for the rest of us.

People recoil at the idea, but isn't that sort of what the founders were doing? They had beautiful, lofty ideals on paper, but they were all wealthy, white, male landowners. Their idea of "the People" might have been a wee bit more limited than the generally accepted definition today.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by lazide on Friday November 14, 2025 @09:43AM (#45927174)
It doesn’t require most people to be stupid. It just requires people to have other things they need to do, and pay attention to, and limited ability to give a shit.

If everyone has to be paying attention all the time (and it would be 150% of the time with modern society), everyone is susceptible to being drowned in bullshit and either checking out or being manipulated.

Even with what we have now, that is exactly what is going on. Direct democracy would be even worse.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by lazide on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:32PM (#45920125)
You have a huge, huge misunderstanding of how direct democracy turns out.

Everyone with a job gets inundated with bullshit, even eventually stops showing up (or paying attention) because it’s impossible to live and actual do that.

So then you end up with nut jobs doing whatever they want while having the votes because they are the only ones who show up at 11am on a Tuesday when the daily vote is happening.

Apps just tiktok’itize the whole process.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by QuercusMax on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:43PM (#45920275)
You seem to have a very particular idea of how direct democracy might be implemented; there's no reason it has to be "show up at 11am on a Tuesday".
Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by lazide on Friday November 14, 2025 @05:29AM (#45925626)
There is on average over 1 new bill a day that gets voted on in Congress. Those are the bills that get past committees.

Everyone still complains it is impossible to get Congress to actually do anything, since this is a huge country with 300+ million people.

If we didn’t have a ton of filtering (by whom? And who gets to decide that, is who has real power!) we’d probably have 10K+ new laws a day being proposed.

What do you expect the voting process to actually look like?

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by QuercusMax on Friday November 14, 2025 @12:57PM (#45929565)
I don't know what I expect the voting process to look like, but you seem to be assuming the worst without even thinking it through very much.
Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by QuercusMax on Friday November 14, 2025 @12:58PM (#45929573)
I don't know what I expect the voting process to look like, but you seem to be assuming the worst without even thinking it through very much. I'm not an expert, I just don't think we should throw out ideas based on poor strawman implementations.
Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by lazide on Friday November 14, 2025 @01:33PM (#45930126)
It’s well trod history, hah. The founding fathers directly wrote about and considered it too.

There are reasons why literally nobody does it, and it isn’t because it works too well.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by wing-_-nuts on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:45PM (#45920289)
I'm not saying we put every insignificant little thing on the ballot, but lets say once every 4 years we take the real hot button issues that congress perennially uses as political football, and put them on a ballot. Abortion legal before the age of viability, yes or no. Medicare for all, yes or no. Legalizing cannabis, ditto.

I am sick and tired of congress basically ignoring the will of the people because some rich dudes with superpacs feel otherwise.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by lazide on Friday November 14, 2025 @05:30AM (#45925636)
Who gets to decide what is insignificant or not?

They’re going to be the ones with the real power. Who gets to decide who they are?

The reasons these issues get used as political football is precisely because there is a lot less consistent belief on what ‘the right thing’ is to do on those issues than you’d think, which is why they can be polarizing. And trying to force everyone to follow the same rule is undesirable for a large portion of the population.

Why would they vote to be stomped on?

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by sershe on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:33PM (#45920150)
Federalist papers were very explicitly against direct democracy, so... Not much?