News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by NoMoreNicksLeft on Thursday November 13, 2025 @12:07PM (#45917392)
The Senate was absolutely one of the best features of government. Unicameral legislatures are uniformly godawful. In as much as it is imperfect, it is only so because Congress has become more unicameral-like... senators are little more than representatives that stay in office six years instead of two.
Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by CalChris on Thursday November 13, 2025 @12:17PM (#45917540)
WHY is the Senate absolutely one of the best features of government? In Britain, its name more honestly reflected the class it represents, House of Lords.
Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by NoMoreNicksLeft on Thursday November 13, 2025 @12:28PM (#45917714)
In Britain there is no Congress. The name of the House of Lords has nothing to do with the United States' Senate. If we are to believe that its form and function were inspired by some other nation's government, then let's talk about its true namesake: the Roman Senate.

I reject your Peel all apples because orange rinds are bitter! nonsense.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by CalChris on Thursday November 13, 2025 @12:52PM (#45918065)
The Roman Senate was a unicameral form of government. Bicameralism principally comes from Britain, the country which we were formerly a colony of and which gave us our dominant language, legal code, ….

That said, again, WHY is the Senate absolutely one of the best features of government?

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by macintux on Thursday November 13, 2025 @02:58PM (#45919733)
My take on some of the Senate's advantages:

- No gerrymandering

- Longer terms mean that senators can spend more time governing, less time running for election, and they can take a longer view on the impact of their decisions

- Filibuster means that a tiny minority cannot force legislation through

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by cthalupa on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:10PM (#45919872)
The filibuster is not a feature inherent to the Senate and could be removed at any time with a simple majority, just like it has been done for the filibuster for several types of nominations, and was threatened during this past shutdown.

I also assume you meant tiny majority, as the minority cannot force legislation through regardless of whether the filibuster exists or not.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by macintux on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:19PM (#45919992)
Yes, I meant tiny majority.

I recognize that the filibuster isn't guaranteed, but it has served as a powerful tool for a very long time.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by CalChris on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:08PM (#45919862)
The States are a gerrymandering. Five states have populations less than a million and three wouldn't even qualify for Member of Congress by census. Yet they get two Senators, a Member and three Electoral College votes.

You've got filibuster backwards. Filibuster grants rights to a Senate minority.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by macintux on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:16PM (#45919964)
> You've got filibuster backwards. Filibuster grants rights to a Senate minority.

Yeah, I meant that 50.1% can't force legislation through. I should have said tiny majority.

States aren't gerrymandering because the people decide for themselves where to live.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by CalChris on Thursday November 13, 2025 @04:15PM (#45920647)
> States aren't gerrymandering because the people decide for themselves where to live.

The people can also decide for themselves where they want to live with respect to gerrymandered Congressional and other districts. So by your logic, gerrymandering doesn't exist at that level either.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by the_gastropod on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:33PM (#45920151)
“No gerrymandering”. Wut? The Senate is the most egregious example of anti-democratic systems in any country you could reasonably call democratic. It’s far worse than the worst examples of gerrymandering.
Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by rootusrootus on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:54PM (#45920396)
I get what you are saying, but I think gerrymandering is a specific thing -- voters being chosen rather than being the ones to choose. You pick the state you want to live in, and the boundaries are not going to change. But at least every 10 years the congressional district you live in may change without you having any say. So it is definitely worse though I think the lopsided representation due to the senate is pretty shitty too.
Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by CalChris on Thursday November 13, 2025 @05:31PM (#45921544)
> voters being chosen rather than being the ones to choose

With the Missouri Compromise, when territories were admitted, their voters were being chosen for political reasons. Territories were admitted two by two, slave holding and free to maintain a status quo. This falls under your definition of gerrymandering.

There is no justification for this gerrymandering. There's nothing so great about Wyoming such that it should have such an outsized influence on the body politic while possessing the GDP of a mid-sized county.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by tehjoker on Thursday November 13, 2025 @12:10PM (#45917444)
The senate was explicitly designed to provide a brake on the democratic aspirations of the lower classes by the founders.

American government is a system of baffles designed to frustrate democratic will and preserve the property and political control of elites.

The senate should be abolished along with the undemocratic supreme court (as currently constituted with lifetime appointments and the ability to overrule congress at a whim) and the imperial presidency.

To be honest, we need a new constitution that promotes democracy.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by NoMoreNicksLeft on Thursday November 13, 2025 @12:26PM (#45917677)
>American government is a system of baffles designed to frustrate democratic will

The "democratic will", like the people who manifest it, is so bizarrely stupid that there are no insults strong enough to properly insult it. If it can be tolerated at all, then it is so only when there are brakes strong enough to slow it down and force it to think carefully.

>To be honest, we need a new constitution that promotes democracy.

Why would I (or anyone like me) ever agree to a new constitution that someone like yourself approves of? The whole point of the constitution as written was that people like yourself couldn't easily come in and change all the rules when our vigilance relaxed a bit, but here you are not even trying to hide it: you want to change all the rules in one fell swoop. No thanks. Do it the hard way to prove to yourself (and the rest of us) that a vast majority want those changes.

I think senators should be appointed by the states again, repeal the 17th.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by tomhow on Friday November 14, 2025 @08:50PM (#45934341)
Please don't fulminate or make personal attacks on HN, no matter who or what you're replying to. The guidelines make it clear we're aiming for something better here, and we've had to ask you several times to try harder to observe them. We eventually have to ban accounts that keep commenting like this.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by dismalpedigree on Thursday November 13, 2025 @12:34PM (#45917805)
Lets hear it for Tyranny by the Masses!
Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by kulahan on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:16PM (#45919961)
People that say this are only looking to ensure the repression of those at the bottom of the totem pole remain oppressed! It's a direct path to fascism, and it is designed entirely to massively accumulate wealth at the top of the pyramid while ensuring all others starve and suffer!

If you're going to make inane comments about how ahckchtually everything in the world is a creation of the man who just wants to keep us down, you'll need to qualify the statements.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by rootusrootus on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:57PM (#45920431)
> ability to overrule congress at a whim

That can be stopped easily enough. The Constitution makes it clear that Congress is the ultimate source of power; the SCOTUS power of judicial review was granted to itself by itself. Congress can (and has, a few times, though not often) make legislation not subject to judicial review.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by unethical_ban on Thursday November 13, 2025 @04:23PM (#45920734)
The problem is that it is far, far more difficult for the legislature to "fix" a decision by SCOTUS than it is for SCOTUS to "fix" an unconstitutional law.

Supermajorities in both houses + 3/4 of the states is unlikely to ever happen again unless we face an existential threat or civil conflict.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by rootusrootus on Thursday November 13, 2025 @05:14PM (#45921358)
> Supermajorities in both houses + 3/4 of the states is unlikely to ever happen

I agree, we seem to have perfected the art of splitting of the population into fairly stable tribes similar in size. Unless one side goes batshit insane (and even then, I think current evidence counters this idea) there is probably not going to be a supermajority in the foreseeable future.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by NoMoreNicksLeft on Saturday November 15, 2025 @06:29PM (#45941440)
The funny thing is that the discussion we're having, about congressional representation, already has an amendment out there floating around, waiting to be ratified. Already has 11 or 12 states who have ratified it (I forget). It can't be canceled or expired or cockblocked. If you live in a state outside of New England, you could petition your state legislators to ratify it tomorrow. And if even one state were to ratify it, others would notice and follow.

It's not unlikely. It's just... I don't know. It's as if some Svengali is out there hypnotnizing you dolts to ignore it. No other explanation makes sense. Seriously, this could be down to 2-3 jackass state representatives in Iowa or New Mexico or Florida just getting a wild hair up their ass.