News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by CalChris on Thursday November 13, 2025 @12:52PM (#45918065)
The Roman Senate was a unicameral form of government. Bicameralism principally comes from Britain, the country which we were formerly a colony of and which gave us our dominant language, legal code, ….

That said, again, WHY is the Senate absolutely one of the best features of government?

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by macintux on Thursday November 13, 2025 @02:58PM (#45919733)
My take on some of the Senate's advantages:

- No gerrymandering

- Longer terms mean that senators can spend more time governing, less time running for election, and they can take a longer view on the impact of their decisions

- Filibuster means that a tiny minority cannot force legislation through

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by cthalupa on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:10PM (#45919872)
The filibuster is not a feature inherent to the Senate and could be removed at any time with a simple majority, just like it has been done for the filibuster for several types of nominations, and was threatened during this past shutdown.

I also assume you meant tiny majority, as the minority cannot force legislation through regardless of whether the filibuster exists or not.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by macintux on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:19PM (#45919992)
Yes, I meant tiny majority.

I recognize that the filibuster isn't guaranteed, but it has served as a powerful tool for a very long time.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by CalChris on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:08PM (#45919862)
The States are a gerrymandering. Five states have populations less than a million and three wouldn't even qualify for Member of Congress by census. Yet they get two Senators, a Member and three Electoral College votes.

You've got filibuster backwards. Filibuster grants rights to a Senate minority.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by macintux on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:16PM (#45919964)
> You've got filibuster backwards. Filibuster grants rights to a Senate minority.

Yeah, I meant that 50.1% can't force legislation through. I should have said tiny majority.

States aren't gerrymandering because the people decide for themselves where to live.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by CalChris on Thursday November 13, 2025 @04:15PM (#45920647)
> States aren't gerrymandering because the people decide for themselves where to live.

The people can also decide for themselves where they want to live with respect to gerrymandered Congressional and other districts. So by your logic, gerrymandering doesn't exist at that level either.

Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by the_gastropod on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:33PM (#45920151)
“No gerrymandering”. Wut? The Senate is the most egregious example of anti-democratic systems in any country you could reasonably call democratic. It’s far worse than the worst examples of gerrymandering.
Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by rootusrootus on Thursday November 13, 2025 @03:54PM (#45920396)
I get what you are saying, but I think gerrymandering is a specific thing -- voters being chosen rather than being the ones to choose. You pick the state you want to live in, and the boundaries are not going to change. But at least every 10 years the congressional district you live in may change without you having any say. So it is definitely worse though I think the lopsided representation due to the senate is pretty shitty too.
Re:Hemp Ban Hidden Inside Government Shutdown Bill by CalChris on Thursday November 13, 2025 @05:31PM (#45921544)
> voters being chosen rather than being the ones to choose

With the Missouri Compromise, when territories were admitted, their voters were being chosen for political reasons. Territories were admitted two by two, slave holding and free to maintain a status quo. This falls under your definition of gerrymandering.

There is no justification for this gerrymandering. There's nothing so great about Wyoming such that it should have such an outsized influence on the body politic while possessing the GDP of a mid-sized county.