News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Waymo begins freeway rides for the public by throwup238 on Wednesday November 12, 2025 @01:01PM (#45903423)
It’s more complicated than that because several (most?) states have contradictory laws about impeding traffic. It can technically be illegal to drive at (or below) the speed limit because it creates an unsafe environment for all the other cars on the road that are driving faster, even if they’re all breaking the legal speed limit.

It’s not a viable defense if you get a ticket for speeding but in practice the speed limit is really the prevailing speed of traffic plus X mph, where X adjusted for the state. I.e. in my experience Texas is more strict about the speed limit even on their desolate highways, LA is about 10 mph faster than San Francisco, in Seattle it depends on the weather, you’ll never hit the speed limit in New York anyway, and in Florida you just say the gator ate the officer who pulled you over.

Re:Waymo begins freeway rides for the public by mikestew on Wednesday November 12, 2025 @01:20PM (#45903740)
It’s more complicated than that because several (most?) states have contradictory laws about impeding traffic.

No they don’t, you’ve misinterpreted what was written. “Not impeding traffic” is not codified as “exceed the speed limit if everyone else is, or get a ticket”.

Or perhaps you have a documented counter-example.

Re:Waymo begins freeway rides for the public by throwup238 on Wednesday November 12, 2025 @01:49PM (#45904213)
I don’t know what you mean by “documented” but here is Georgia:

> No person shall drive a motor vehicle at such a slow speed as to impede the normal and reasonable movement of traffic, except when reduced speed is necessary for safe operation. [1]

Versus California:

> No person shall drive upon a highway at such a slow speed as to impede or block the normal and reasonable movement of traffic unless the reduced speed is necessary for safe operation, because of a grade, _or in compliance with law_. [2] (underscore emphasis mine)

It’s part of the Uniform Vehicle Code but each state has its quirks in how they adopt it since theres no federal mandate.

My apologies though, this seems way less common than I thought. As far as I can tell Georgia and Oregon are the only two states left that don’t have that compliance exception.

On the other hand “in compliance with law” is it’s own barrel of monkeys because it doesn’t specify priority.

[1] https://law.justia.com/codes/georgia/title-40/chapter-6/arti...

[2] https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySectio...

Re:Waymo begins freeway rides for the public by bcrosby95 on Wednesday November 12, 2025 @01:59PM (#45904415)
> I don’t know what you mean by “documented” but here is Georgia:

Georgia isn't going to punish you for going the speed limit in the right lane, they passed that law recently and called it the 'slow poke law'.

> On the other hand “in compliance with law” is it’s own barrel of monkeys because it doesn’t specify priority.

It really isn't.

Re:Waymo begins freeway rides for the public by throwup238 on Wednesday November 12, 2025 @02:39PM (#45905218)
> Georgia isn't going to punish you for going the speed limit in the right lane, they passed that law recently and called it the 'slow poke law'.

So you’re saying they had to pass a law clarifying a contradiction in previous laws? Those contradictions were my original point. And it still only applies to the slow poke lane.

> It really isn't.

Oh you sweet summer child.

Re:Waymo begins freeway rides for the public by bcrosby95 on Wednesday November 12, 2025 @02:45PM (#45905338)
> Oh you sweet summer child.

It's very clear in this instance if you don't view the law as a programming language, aren't a 2 year old, and don't go around viewing everyone in the world as a bunch of NPCs in the main story of your life.

I get that even that's hard for some people. But it really isn't. We just stop trying to teach people to not be assholes once they leave elementary school.

Re:Waymo begins freeway rides for the public by throwup238 on Wednesday November 12, 2025 @02:49PM (#45905390)
Projection. Projection. Projection.

You’re literally viewing the law as a precise programming language, whereas I’m arguing that the reality is that laws are written in natural language that contains not only semantic ambiguity, but temporal ambiguity where one law is not coherent with another because they were created by different people at different times with different incentives.

You also didn’t bother responding to the meat of my argument, but hey you do you. Personally I’ve found that anyone who refers to other human beings as “NPCs” is void of any substance.

Re:Waymo begins freeway rides for the public by SoftTalker on Wednesday November 12, 2025 @03:26PM (#45906037)
The rule in Indiana is that on a multilane highway you must move to the right to allow overtaking traffic to pass. You are not there to enforce the speed limit; the fact that another car that is passing you might be speeding does not give you the right or duty to block them.

"a person who knows, or should reasonably know, that another vehicle is overtaking from the rear the vehicle that the person is operating may not continue to operate the vehicle in the left most lane"

With of course some reasonable exceptions.

https://law.justia.com/codes/indiana/title-9/article-21/chap...

Re:Waymo begins freeway rides for the public by mikestew on Wednesday November 12, 2025 @04:08PM (#45906708)
The rule in Indiana is that on a multilane highway you must move to the right to allow overtaking traffic to pass.

That's a rule just about everywhere, but that's not what's being discussed. I'm in the right lane doing the speed limit, and OP claims that's "technically" illegal due to contradictory laws. (Where there is no real contradiction, because the Chesterton's Fence is that we don't want Farmer Jones driving his tractor to his fields down I-75 through Atlanta.)

Re:Waymo begins freeway rides for the public by SoftTalker on Wednesday November 12, 2025 @04:25PM (#45906947)
Right. What's (maybe) illegal (and definitely unsafe) is staying in the left lane, although driving at the posted speed limit, and impeding traffic that wants to pass.
Re:Waymo begins freeway rides for the public by mikestew on Wednesday November 12, 2025 @04:46PM (#45907220)
Oh, as a Washington resident[0] I completely agree.

[0] The "joke" here being that WA drivers are notorious about parking in the left lane while driving 5mph under the limit.

Re:Waymo begins freeway rides for the public by sbuttgereit on Friday November 14, 2025 @05:44PM (#45933054)
What does happen in that situation sometimes is that if you're speeding along with everyone else, that sometimes gets allowed as a defense against a speeding ticket; basically the argument is that if driving the speed limit when all surrounding traffic is driving over the speed limit, that the relative speed difference can matter. At least that was true when I learned to drive (many, many years ago).
Re:Waymo begins freeway rides for the public by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday November 12, 2025 @01:55PM (#45904325)
> It’s more complicated than that because several (most?) states have contradictory laws about impeding traffic

As others have mentioned, this is dead wrong.

But the actual complication is enforcement usually requires a margin of error, and in some states (e.g. Wyoming) you can go 10 mph over when passing.

Re:Waymo begins freeway rides for the public by lo_zamoyski on Wednesday November 12, 2025 @03:23PM (#45905978)
> It’s not a viable defense if you get a ticket for speeding but in practice the speed limit is really the prevailing speed of traffic plus X mph, where X adjusted for the state.

A lot of laws aren't enforced consistently in practice, sure. The implicit point is that while that may be so, it is nonetheless enforceable and nonetheless the law. So while individual people may be comfortable about being flexible in following traffic laws, having that behavior encoded or permitted by software is basically a declaration of broad intent to violate the law made by a company.