News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:$99 Raspberry Pi-sized “supercomputer” touted in Kickstar... by abcd_f on Friday September 28, 2012 @06:13AM (#4584887)
Car analogy is off.

Going from A to B is exactly an example of a task that can't be solved in parallel fashion. On the other hand, if you needed to merely cover N miles, then a pool of cars would work just fine.

Re:$99 Raspberry Pi-sized “supercomputer” touted in Kickstar... by josephlord on Friday September 28, 2012 @07:01AM (#4584951)
Many computing problems can't be parallelised and in almost all there are dependencies and synchronisation issues that mean a single double speed CPU is almost always better than two normal ones. Exception might be that when a buggy programme gets locked in a tight loop it will only be able to take half the resources.

To use another car analogy. Counting clock speed is like counting the cars max RPM instead of actually measuring the performance. And then they have totalled the max RPM figures as if they have have 90,000RPM engine.

Re:$99 Raspberry Pi-sized “supercomputer” touted in Kickstar... by alexchamberlain on Friday September 28, 2012 @09:49AM (#4585451)
Conversely, there are many problems, most notably in the low-level mathematics, which can be parallelised. Matrix multiplication for example...
Re:$99 Raspberry Pi-sized “supercomputer” touted in Kickstar... by josephlord on Friday September 28, 2012 @08:45PM (#4588457)
Yes there are infinitely* many problems that can be parallelised but even in the best case they will only equal the single processor at double the speed.

http://home.wlu.edu/~whaleyt/classes/parallel/topics/amdahl....

I should have referenced Amdahl's law in the previous post but didn't want to misspell it and bother to look it up.

*Infinite numbers exist of both parallel and serial computing requirements. Practically there will almost always be additional cost in parallel implementation even if the extra is insignificant such as higher start up cost and coordination for shutdown.

Re:$99 Raspberry Pi-sized “supercomputer” touted in Kickstar... by mclarkk on Wednesday October 03, 2012 @08:07PM (#4610267)
Amdahl's Law did throw a damp cloth over the fire of enthusiasm about parallel computing...for a while. But then we got Gustafson's Law:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gustafson%27s_Law

Gustafson and Barsis pointed out that Amdahl assumed a fixed input size. If instead you grow the problem size along with the number of processors, the speedup from parallelism grows indefinitely. Of course, like Amdahl, they assume perfect load balancing and don't factor in communication overhead. But parallel still beats the pants off of serial if we want to keep solving larger and larger problems.

Re:$99 Raspberry Pi-sized “supercomputer” touted in Kickstar... by danbee on Friday September 28, 2012 @08:13AM (#4585103)
Actually it can. If you have 16 people to move and 1 car that seats 4 it will take 4 round trips. 4 cars will do it in 1 one way trip.

People = threads and cars = cores.

Re:$99 Raspberry Pi-sized “supercomputer” touted in Kickstar... by laumars on Friday September 28, 2012 @08:39AM (#4585176)
You missed his point. Clock frequencies cannot be combined as it's a measure of the frequency a single core operates at - not how many operations per second can be processed. This is why multi-core CPUs don't say 8GHz even though they have 4x 2GHz cores.
Re:$99 Raspberry Pi-sized “supercomputer” touted in Kickstar... by abcd_f on Friday September 28, 2012 @09:06AM (#4585278)
Of course I haven't missed the point. You did :)

You can nitpick as much as you want, but for a lot of applications it's perfectly OK to sum up the frequencies. A job that can be spread over 8 cores will be executed at about the same time as it would execute on a single core at 8x the frequency

Re:$99 Raspberry Pi-sized “supercomputer” touted in Kickstar... by whatusername on Friday September 28, 2012 @09:54AM (#4585486)
As mentione by backprojection: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4585346 the term you want is FLOPS.
Re:$99 Raspberry Pi-sized “supercomputer” touted in Kickstar... by laumars on Friday September 28, 2012 @09:40AM (#4585404)
No it wouldn't. You have overhead generated by running threads concurrently (eg thread management, communication between nodes, etc). You have issues where not all threads are going to have the exact same complexity (eg some might consist of more floating point calculations than others), this could even result in threads sitting idle while they wait for another thread on a different core to finish.

Plus there's absolutely no precedence for using clock frequencies cumulatively like this anyway (which I've already demonstrated with my multi-core CPU example), thus the figures Adapteva are touting are not only scientifically and mathematically inaccurate, but also breaking established advertising convention too.

Thus their figures are incorrect - period. So accusing us of nitpicking incorrect figures is just plain dumb when there's absolutely no merit to the 13GHz figure what-so-ever.

[edit]

And it's a sad day for geeks worldwide if discussing the correct usage for scientific measurements is considered nitpicking. Had this been Fox News or the Daily Mail, then your view point could be forgiven. But this is a hacker forum, so I'd expect a higher level of technicality rather than simply ignoring counterarguments in such a dismissive manner. :(

Re:$99 Raspberry Pi-sized “supercomputer” touted in Kickstar... by abcd_f on Friday September 28, 2012 @10:52AM (#4585802)
Describing a gadget in terms of cumulative frequency of its cores is an A-Ok method of giving approximate performance, especially when it's obvious that it's a sum of cores. You and I and anyone moderately interested by this project know exactly what this number means. It is also pretty clear that they haven't meant to mislead or trick someone into thinking that they are building a 1THz computer for $99. So, yeah, it's nitpicking.

A better angle would be - given the project and its goals, do you really think it's worth putting them down for something as trivial (and technically correct) as this -

  Once completed, the Parallella computer should deliver 
  up to 45 GHz of equivalent CPU performance
That, as they say on TechCrunch, is a dick move. If anything, they deserve a pat on a back and a donation.
Re:$99 Raspberry Pi-sized “supercomputer” touted in Kickstar... by laumars on Friday September 28, 2012 @12:17PM (#4586284)
I'm not putting them down. My opinions of them are irrespective of the statistics they present. I love the idea of their project - I hate the idea of people like yourself perpetuating the same misconception that clock frequencies can by summed across cluster nodes. so my issue is with you regurgitating the same dumb fallacies.

If you had even the slightest idea about how cores are rated and the complexities of multi-threaded development, then you'd realise that summing the frequency of the cores is completely inaccurate. Hell, don't you think Intel would be doing this with their multi-core processors if it was a legitimate statistic? (a point I've made several times now but you keep ignoring).

You've been told by a multitude of people what the correct measure of cumulative processing power is, and instead you're still holding onto the same myth which the clickbait headlines are perpetuating. So really, you're just reinforcing my point about how they shouldn't be using such a dumb statistic because people who don't know any better will fall for it.

Anyway, and FYI, core frequency isn't even a good measure of CPU performance on single core systems. A 1GHz RISC CPU will perform vastly differently to a 1GHz CISC. Then you have the plethora of RISC architectures; and even on x86, different CPUs will have different co-processors, caching, pipelining and even additional instructions, thus will perform differently on different stress tests.

So crudely summing clock frequencies on a cluster is about as accurate a description of performance as remarking on the colour of the motherboard. But let's not let a pesky thing like science get in the way of our deeply held beliefs ;)

Re:$99 Raspberry Pi-sized “supercomputer” touted in Kickstar... by abcd_f on Friday September 28, 2012 @03:02PM (#4587232)
You are smarter than me. At least you seem to think so.