There's also an open question of how possible it is to run a system that doesn't collect/store data in a way that makes it possible to be collected by the government. The US government can force companies to compromise their systems or shut down their services if they refuse. In the past they've even threatened that shutting down a service instead of compromising it could still get operators in legal trouble.
At this point anyone who wants to keep the US government out of their data should avoid using any US company.
More recently they've started collected the contents of messages into the cloud too, yet to this very day their privacy policy opens with the lie: "Signal is designed to never collect or store any sensitive information." which hasn't been true for a very very long time. I consider their refusal to update their privacy policy to be a massive dead canary warning people that the service has already been compromised, but feel free to take your chances.
I'm also not sure where you've read that they collect the contents of messages, because as far as I'm aware they still aren't doing that and I can't find any info online that indicates that they are (other than their secure backup feature that's opt-in only I suppose)
The fact that Signal users are still unaware of where their data is going and when should tell you all you need to know about how trustworthy the service is. Not being 100% clear about the risks people take when using software which is promoted for use by people whose freedom and/or lives depend on it being secure is a very bad look for Signal.
As for message backups they are at least opt-in (for now anyway) and you can learn more about them here: https://signal.org/blog/introducing-secure-backups/
Alternatives?
Was hard enough getting my circle on signal.
You do realize that Signal's CEO is a "former" CIA asset, don't you /s
It seems the solution is ages old. Don't have the holding incorporated in an empire...
ROTFL
https://blogs.microsoft.com/on-the-issues/2025/04/30/europea...
Not all countries have an equivalent to the USA CLOUD Act.
Not yet, anyway. Unfortunately, pretty much every country seems to be getting less and less open and free over time. Some are better than others, but it does feel like everyone is regrettably rowing in same direction.
If you don't have a spine, sure
That's what US companies are seen as from a European perspective: Spineless and untrustable
It's a great sales argument for locally grown software though, so I'm not complaining :)
I've never understood this take. A lot of people were saying this sort of thing when Proton Mail turned over some user data to authorities in Europe a while back.
If you're running a tech company and run afoul of the law in some or another jurisdiction, it doesn't matter how much spine you think you have. When a group of men with guns, i.e. the police, shows up at your door and gives you the option of turning over some customer data or spending the next 10 years of your life in a steel cage, I'm betting that practically no one is going to choose the cage, spine or not.
The only way to keep user data safe is to not collect it in the first place.
Not according to both Amazon's and Microsoft's historic marketing materials. They have always claimed that data stored in your local jurisdiction is not accessible to law enforcement abroad. And the US judiciary initially agreed with that: https://petri.com/microsoft-wins-appeal-data-stored-abroad-s...
...which then led to the US CLOUD act and here we are, once again, proving that the past is alterable; just like Oceania has always been at war with Eurasia.
Your home country can tell you "Give us your data" and you have to comply.
"I will never give up customer data" is a very tough promise to keep, if the government threatens you with your business license being revoked, your servers and domains being forcibly seized by the police, and you personally going to jail.
(Under the current US administration, we can add "A close examination of the immigration status of all foreign nationals employed by your company, followed by probable deportation or jail" to the list of potential consequences for resisting the government.)