News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by gsibble on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @03:07PM (#4577410)
It's sad to see the executive branch forcing the judiciary into an awkward position.

What exactly is the judge going to do? Fine DHS/TSA? Where will that money go? Right back into the treasury where it came from.

Ugh. TSA makes me sick.

Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by roc on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @03:21PM (#4577489)
> "What exactly is the judge going to do?"

Hold those in charge personally responsible. Find them in contempt. Lock them up. Go as far up the executive chain as necessary. Have the civilian police deactivate/seize any scanners until the TSA falls into compliance.

The TSA has definitely forced an awkward situation. But it's not one without recourse. The government is always accountable to the people and must obey the law.

If the country paid anything more than lip service to the rule of law and personal liberty, these actions would have already been taken or at least credibly threatened to force this issue along.

Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by rayiner on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @03:29PM (#4577531)
Don't be dramatic. The US government is very accountable as far as governments go. The judge hasn't held anyone in contempt yet because foot-dragging isn't really an egregious disrespect to the court in a procedural battle like this one. What the judge is ordering the agency to do is have a public notice & comment on regulations governing the use of these scanners. Writing up proper notice takes a lot of time because any defects in the notice set up a later legal challenge. They're late on this, but agencies always are.
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by roc on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @03:39PM (#4577571)
> "They're late on this, but agencies always are."

Months-late could be attributable to the somewhat understandable slow wheels of over-careful i-dotting and t-crossing. But we're going on years-late. And the court had to order the TSA to give so much as a status update after 13 months of failure to comply and official silence.

That's well into egregious disrespect.

Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by verelo on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @05:57PM (#4578263)
> "Don't be dramatic. The US government is very accountable as far as governments go."

Its fairly responsible, despite a few large events, however this is one issue that the US is not grasping the magnitude of.

The TSA is not just impacting your own citizens, think about foreigners visiting, what a great first impression! I've stopped flying through SFO or LAX whenever i visit Sydney or Toronto. I now go through Vancouver every time. It costs me more, but i'm tired of US immigration / TSA shenanigans.

Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by rayiner on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @09:23PM (#4578865)
I agree, TSA is a very egregious agency that seems to have been let loose like a bull in a china store. But it's unusually bad as far as federal agencies go.
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by joering2 on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @04:36PM (#4577892)
if you live in the US, this is more correct: The people are always accountable to the government and must obey the law [set forth by the latter].
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by rayiner on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @03:25PM (#4577504)
There are things judges can do that they don't in practice. A common punishment to foot-dragging is to force the agency to pay attorneys' fees for plaintiffs. This comes out of the agencies litigation budgets, which makes it harder for them to fight other challenges and tends to get results.
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by jerrya on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @03:51PM (#4577631)
I don't know what an Appeals Court can do, and I would like to know.

It almost certainly could provide the relief the plaintiffs were asking for, right?

Can it:

    * provide a writ of mandamus stopping the machines until the ordered report is provided?
    * tell the TSA 19 months is too long, they have 90 more days to comply?
As it was, IIRC, the TSA said 19 months, the judge said 20 months!
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by scythe on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @03:54PM (#4577647)
I thought the TSA's argument as described at the end of the article was patently absurd ("ever-evolving threats"). Did they actually get away with saying that? If there is any decency in the world, that wouldn't stand with SCOTUS.
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by alttag on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @05:27PM (#4578155)
One of the interesting (to me) items in the article is that it framed the use of body scanners as clearly an agency (administrative) decision, rather than a legal (that is, codified) one.

For rule-making authority to have the force of law, the 90-day comment period is mandated ... does that mean the decision to apply these scanners isn't enforceable (and thus, litigable)? TSA has seemingly worked around this, as there is no aggrieved party (and thus, no standing), due to their opt-out provisions. That seems doubly wrong, and disrespectful of the legal process.

Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by ims on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @06:20PM (#4578332)
Administrative decisions can often be made without corresponding rulemaking actions. Even when a rule is made the 90 day comment period (normally 60 days after the Notice of Proposed Rulemaking and 30 after the Final Rule) is more of a guideline. You could call it strongly encouraged by several Executive Orders, most recently E.O. 13563.
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by cpeterso on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @04:51PM (#4577965)
I always opt-out of the scanners when I fly, but my estimate is that less than 0.5% of other people opt-out. 1 in 200! Most people are too impatient or uninformed to care about privacy or potential health risks.
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by ninjin on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @10:03PM (#4578975)
I opt-out as well, I am a non-US citizen so I am a bit scared to cause any fuss considering the general friendliness of the US federal government.

I was physically searched all three times passing security, opting to do so in public rather than in a booth as I prefer to be violated where there are witnesses. All-in-all, the TSA treated me fairly well considering the circumstances apart from in San Francisco where a passing female TSA agent smirked and commented saying "Come on, he is enjoying it!", laughing as she passed me by. That, that was a bit of a punch below the belt...

The Dutch are now trying out the same scanners and they were not even remotely friendly when you opt-out. My plead to you over there in the states is to stop this madness before it spreads. Just as with liquids and all else, the US has a great influence on the rest of the world and in this case, I fear, for the worse.

Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by rayiner on Thursday September 27, 2012 @02:29AM (#4579620)
> All-in-all, the TSA treated me fairly well considering the circumstances apart from in San Francisco where a passing female TSA agent smirked and commented saying "Come on, he is enjoying it!", laughing as she passed me by. That, that was a bit of a punch below the belt...

Yeah, TSA is a jobs program for the otherwise unemployable.

Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by bicknergseng on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @06:46PM (#4578416)
I've been told I can't twice. I always want to protest, but never do for fear of ending up on the irrational, incontestable no fly list.
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by ewams on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @08:53PM (#4578798)
Which airport was this? I fly 4-6 times a week and opt-out every single time. Never once been told no. They try to convince me sometimes to go through the scanner but still refuse.
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by Jach on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @11:29PM (#4579156)
Just insist on a patdown. (The several times I've flown in the past few years, they either let me through the regular metal detector like normal or I go through/around the metal detector for a patdown, which so far hasn't been invasive and I'm certain I could smuggle a ton of crap on my person.)
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by enraged_camel on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @05:01PM (#4578021)
Do we actually have any conclusive evidence that these scanners are harmful? I thought all the "potential health risks" were just speculative.
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by mtgx on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @06:00PM (#4578273)
EU banned x-ray scanners in all EU airports because of health risk factors:

http://www.forbes.com/sites/daviddisalvo/2011/11/15/europe-b...

Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by josephlord on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @05:05PM (#4578039)
Yes but the absence of health risks is pretty speculative too and based on the assumption that the particular machine you are stepping into is functioning as designed.

Do you feel lucky?

Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by jlgreco on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @06:36PM (#4578383)
I think all programmers should know that even medical grade equipment can go terribly wrong (Therac-25 anyone?). The fact that this stuff isn't medical grade, isn't being operated by people who understand the risks, and isn't allowed to be inspected makes me feel very unlucky.
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by CamperBob2 on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @10:51PM (#4579062)
isn't being operated by people who understand the risks

This is the key point as far as I'm concerned. In what other profession am I allowed to use X-ray machines on the general public without any training whatsoever?

Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by DrStalker on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @11:34PM (#4579172)
Mad scientist?
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by cpeterso on Thursday September 27, 2012 @12:40AM (#4579383)
I don't think that counts; they would have had to have gone to school to study mad science.
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by jlgreco on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @11:35PM (#4579179)
Supervillian maybe ;)
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by dalke on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @05:20PM (#4578119)
I thought the "potential benefits" were also speculative.
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by enraged_camel on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @05:55PM (#4578256)
Oh yes, I'm certainly not claiming that the devices are useful by any means, at least when it comes to ultimately making us safer. It's just that arguments on both sides seem to be spacious, which I thought was worth pointing out.
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by jlgreco on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @06:44PM (#4578410)
That the arguments for both sides is spacious is in fact an argument in favor of not using the machines. "When in doubt, default to not x-raying people." is a pretty good policy as far as I am concerned.
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by cpeterso on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @11:46PM (#4579204)
As a thought experiment, I sometimes imagine a Children of Men-like scenario where, twenty years from now, scientists discover that most American teenagers are sterile.
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by dalke on Thursday September 27, 2012 @01:20PM (#4581711)
Do you only see two sides? I see at least four: "we need more tools to identify banned objects", "we need personal privacy", "we don't know the health effects" and "we need cost effective ways to handle the threat of terrorism."

The lack of solid benefits and the known cost of the machines seems heavily weighted against them being cost effective, even ignoring any privacy and health concerns.

Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by krichman on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @11:20PM (#4579130)
How is privacy a spacious argument?
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by camiller on Thursday September 27, 2012 @09:42AM (#4580615)
"... It's just that arguments on both sides seem to be spacious ..."

"How is privacy a spacious argument?"

spacious

1. Generous or large in area or extent; roomy.

specious

spe·cious (sp sh s). adj. 1. Having the ring of truth or plausibility but actually fallacious: a specious argument.

Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by po on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @09:54PM (#4578955)
I also opt-out when I fly to the US (several times a year) but I get the impression that it's becoming more rare for people to do that. They used to sometimes treat you with a bit of contempt, and now it's more like "really?". I think a lot of the pressure has died down and the public has unfortunately learned to just live with it.
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by acheron on Thursday September 27, 2012 @08:56AM (#4580422)
The past few times I've flown the agents have automatically redirected me to the regular metal detector rather than the backscatter machines. All you need to do is be holding an infant. If you don't have one of your own, maybe borrow one from a friend.
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by krichman on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @11:18PM (#4579126)
I opted-out last year while I was there. I've only ever seen myself choose that.
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by mtgx on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @03:29PM (#4577523)
US should have a different agency that takes comments and complaints about the TSA and then sends a periodical report to Congress about it. From my understanding, right now the complaints are sent to TSA themselves? That's pretty much pointless then.
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by nathanb on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @04:20PM (#4577801)
Are you sure that's accountable and transparent enough? Perhaps we should establish a third agency to handle complaints regarding the second agency and ensure that everything is aboveboard.
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by cpeterso on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @04:37PM (#4577895)
We could have one agency to plan the TSA's mission, a second to carry out the plan, and a third to review complaints.
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by skermes on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @05:01PM (#4578024)
You joke, but http://www.improbable.com/ig/winners/#ig2012

  LITERATURE PRIZE: The US Government General Accountability Office, for
  issuing a report about reports about reports that recommends the preparation
  of a report about the report about reports about reports.
Never try to out-do the government at bureaucratic recursion.
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by camiller on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @04:35PM (#4577884)
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by flyt on Thursday September 27, 2012 @04:13AM (#4579833)
Seriously. We should have a Government Accountability Office to keep an eye on things like this.
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by ChuckMcM on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @07:35PM (#4578581)
And I would encourage you to use http://PostCongress.io to express your displeasure to your representative.
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners by jksmith on Thursday September 27, 2012 @03:50PM (#4582525)
If you have to raise your hands over your head like you're some kind of perp, at least throw two bird fingers while they're taking the xray. You want them to see that you don't have any explosive devices on your middle fingers.