Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners
by enraged_camel on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @05:01PM
(#4578021)
Do we actually have any conclusive evidence that these scanners are harmful? I thought all the "potential health risks" were just speculative.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners
by mtgx on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @06:00PM
(#4578273)
EU banned x-ray scanners in all EU airports because of health risk factors:
http://www.forbes.com/sites/daviddisalvo/2011/11/15/europe-b...
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners
by josephlord on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @05:05PM
(#4578039)
Yes but the absence of health risks is pretty speculative too and based on the assumption that the particular machine you are stepping into is functioning as designed.
Do you feel lucky?
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners
by jlgreco on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @06:36PM
(#4578383)
I think all programmers should know that even medical grade equipment can go terribly wrong (Therac-25 anyone?). The fact that this stuff isn't medical grade, isn't being operated by people who understand the risks, and isn't allowed to be inspected makes me feel very unlucky.
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners
by CamperBob2 on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @10:51PM
(#4579062)
isn't being operated by people who understand the risks
This is the key point as far as I'm concerned. In what other profession am I allowed to use X-ray machines on the general public without any training whatsoever?
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners
by DrStalker on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @11:34PM
(#4579172)
Mad scientist?
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners
by cpeterso on Thursday September 27, 2012 @12:40AM
(#4579383)
I don't think that counts; they would have had to have gone to school to study mad science.
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners
by jlgreco on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @11:35PM
(#4579179)
Supervillian maybe ;)
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners
by dalke on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @05:20PM
(#4578119)
I thought the "potential benefits" were also speculative.
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners
by enraged_camel on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @05:55PM
(#4578256)
Oh yes, I'm certainly not claiming that the devices are useful by any means, at least when it comes to ultimately making us safer. It's just that arguments on both sides seem to be spacious, which I thought was worth pointing out.
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners
by jlgreco on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @06:44PM
(#4578410)
That the arguments for both sides is spacious is in fact an argument in favor of not using the machines. "When in doubt, default to not x-raying people." is a pretty good policy as far as I am concerned.
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners
by cpeterso on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @11:46PM
(#4579204)
As a thought experiment, I sometimes imagine a Children of Men-like scenario where, twenty years from now, scientists discover that most American teenagers are sterile.
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners
by dalke on Thursday September 27, 2012 @01:20PM
(#4581711)
Do you only see two sides? I see at least four: "we need more tools to identify banned objects", "we need personal privacy", "we don't know the health effects" and "we need cost effective ways to handle the threat of terrorism."
The lack of solid benefits and the known cost of the machines seems heavily weighted against them being cost effective, even ignoring any privacy and health concerns.
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners
by krichman on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @11:20PM
(#4579130)
How is privacy a spacious argument?
Re:Appeals Court Caves to TSA Over Nude Body Scanners
by camiller on Thursday September 27, 2012 @09:42AM
(#4580615)
"... It's just that arguments on both sides seem to be spacious ..."
"How is privacy a spacious argument?"
spacious
1. Generous or large in area or extent; roomy.
specious
spe·cious (sp sh s). adj. 1. Having the ring of truth or plausibility but actually fallacious: a specious argument.