News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Five-Cent Diabetes Pill From 1958 May Be New Cancer Drug by tptacek on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @02:09PM (#4577062)
Huh? How do you patent metformin? It's an extremely widely prescribed drug.
Re:Five-Cent Diabetes Pill From 1958 May Be New Cancer Drug by stephengillie on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @02:16PM (#4577100)
You don't. You patent "Nocan", a drug with an extremely similar (most would say "identical") chemical structure. Metformin is a diabetes medication, while Nocan will be a cancer drug, so they're totally different. The diseases aren't even handled by the same medical specialists. ;)
Re:Five-Cent Diabetes Pill From 1958 May Be New Cancer Drug by tptacek on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @02:23PM (#4577138)
If metformin works for cancer the way aspirin does for heart disease, with an overall long-term prophylactic effect, people will just take metformin. It is very easy to get metformin.
Re:Five-Cent Diabetes Pill From 1958 May Be New Cancer Drug by danielweber on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @02:35PM (#4577225)
I was going to say that your doctor won't be allowed to prescribe metformin, but I checked and the FDA is fine with your doc independently prescribing drugs for off-label use. The manufacturer of metformin isn't allowed to market it as an anti-cancer drug, but what doctor won't be aware of this?
Re:Five-Cent Diabetes Pill From 1958 May Be New Cancer Drug by cowsandmilk on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @02:16PM (#4577102)
at least it is a new indication, see the Makena Pricing Controversy to learn about what the Orphan Drug Law allows https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/KV_Pharmaceutical#Makena_prici...
Re:Five-Cent Diabetes Pill From 1958 May Be New Cancer Drug by timClicks on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @03:23PM (#4577500)
It's possible to receive a patent for applying a known drug to a new area.
Re:Five-Cent Diabetes Pill From 1958 May Be New Cancer Drug by tptacek on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @03:25PM (#4577506)
First of all, are you sure about that?

Second of all, how does that even work? Metformin is very very widely prescribed.

Re:Five-Cent Diabetes Pill From 1958 May Be New Cancer Drug by refurb on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @03:49PM (#4577621)
It's called a "use" patent.

There are many different ways to patent a drug. Composition patents, formulation patents, use patents, etc.

The problem is that if you get a "use" patent, it only stops other company from promoting the drug for the use you patented. In the case of metformin, it's already available as a cheap generic.

So if a company were to conduct studies proving that it reduced the risk of cancer and got a patent on it, there is nothing to stop a doctor from prescribing the generic version.

So unless a company can find a way to recoup their R&D costs associated with running the trials, they won't bother.

Re:Five-Cent Diabetes Pill From 1958 May Be New Cancer Drug by DigitalJack on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @04:19PM (#4577794)
I wasn't aware of use patents. Informative post, thank you.
Re:Five-Cent Diabetes Pill From 1958 May Be New Cancer Drug by ginko on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @04:21PM (#4577807)
So who would break patent law in the case that a doctor prescribes the $0.05 diabetes pills to a cancer patient?

The doctor? He doesn't really make a profit of this and at least over here in Austria, a doctor may prescribe any substance he wants as long as he can argue that it is for the well-being of his patient.

The producer of the diabetes drugs? They don't sell it as a cancer drug.

The apothecary? He's just following the doctor's orders.

Re:Five-Cent Diabetes Pill From 1958 May Be New Cancer Drug by refurb on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @05:14PM (#4578087)
Nobody would be sued because nobody is breaking any patent laws.

That's why you rarely (never?) see a drug company take an old, off-patent drug and try and get a patent for it (in it's original form) on a new disease. Since there is no way to recoup any investment costs, they simply don't make the investment.

What does happen is that drug companies will take an old, off-patent drug and modify it somehow so that it can be patented. They can do that a number of different ways: create a unique formulation of the drug, create a drug-device combination product or try and create a slightly modified (and hopefully improved) version of the original drug.

Under the current system, unless you have a patent (or marketing exclusivity from the FDA) you have no opportunity to recoup any investment you made in the drug.

Re:Five-Cent Diabetes Pill From 1958 May Be New Cancer Drug by pyre on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @03:53PM (#4577644)
The parent is saying you can patent "using Metformin to prevent Cancer" separately than "using Metformin to help with diabetes."

I'm not 100% sure of this, but I'm pretty sure that this is the way the FDA approval process for drugs work. You can't just 'decide' to prescribe Metformin for cancer one day.

A single drug has to go through the approval process N separate times for N separate applications/diseases.

Re:Five-Cent Diabetes Pill From 1958 May Be New Cancer Drug by tptacek on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @04:01PM (#4577702)
Yes, you can. Doctors prescribe drugs for off-label use all the time. The FDA approves the marketing of drugs for specific health problems, but nobody cares about marketing metformin.